12 Days of Cinematicalmas: Best Christmas Movies

So...it's Christmas! Are you wondering what to watch tonight, or maybe you'd like to get some holiday DVDs for friends or family? Here's a handy guide, my choices for the best Xmas movies of all time, along with links to Amazon where you can buy the DVDs (the cool thing about Christmas DVDs? A lot of them are pretty cheap!).
And if you're wondering: both National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation and White Christmas juuuuuust missed the list.
It's A Wonderful Life - Really, do I even have to explain why this is number 1?
Miracle On 34th Street - This is a close second, because the film is just so marvelously entertaining and Edmund Gwenn is the perfect Santa. And it's a very American film, set in NYC during the holidays and featuring department stores Macy's and Gimbels as not just locations but characters in the film. Natalie Wood is quite excellent too (she was filming another film at the same time she filmed this, and it's amazing such a young kid could be so compelling while juggling two jobs.)
Bad Santa - You ever notice that you often won't laugh at a comedy, even if it's incredibly funny, if you're watching it alone? This is one of the rare movies where you will. One of the funniest flicks I've ever seen: nasty, dirty, hilarious, with a perfectly cast Billy Bob Thornton. Oh, this is good (and get the Badder Santa version).
Three Days Of The Condor - I hesitated putting this movie on the list. Not because it's not a great film (it's one of the great thrillers of all-time), but because I wasn't sure if I wanted to include any "non-holiday" holiday movies on the list. Movies that are set at Christmas but aren't necessarily "Christmas films." But this movie is too damn good, too well written, too well cast and directed (Sydney Pollack) that I just can't leave it off. And if you're looking for holiday elements in the film, you can see some decorations, hear Christmas music in a store as Faye Dunaway buys skis, watch Robert Redford buy a pretzel in the New York City cold, and the film ends with the ominous echo of a classic Christmas carol. So, hey, it's a Christmas film. Even if several murders take place and Redford has to run for his life.
A Christmas Story - One of the ways I went about choosing these films is, I thought of the movies I absolutely have to watch every December. The movies that, if I don't watch them, I feel that I didn't have the best Christmas that I could have. This is one of those movies. It's so funny and real. It's clever and has a great cast and is well written (by Jean Shepard, based on his story), and shows another directorial side to Bob "Porky's" Clark.
A Christmas Carol (1984)/ A Christmas Carol (1951) - The 1984 version is actually a TV movie, starring George C. Scott as Scrooge, and it's possibly the best screen adaptation of the Dickens story among the approximately 300 that have been filmed. The 1951 version is almost as good. Both films deserve mention here. (The 1951 version is also sometimes called Scrooge, not to be confused with Bill Murray's Scrooged.)
Elf - Jon Favreau does another fantastic job of directing (after the excellent Made). He manages to make a big screen Christmas movie that's actually funny, sort of a mix of live-action and those Rankin/Bass TV specials. Will Ferrell is funny, Zoey Deschanel is charming, the plot is fun, and Peter Dinklage steals the movie. I even buy the really sappy ending. A fun family flick that even the cynical adults will love.









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-05-2005 @ 4:30PM
Bryan said...
You forgot Die Hard.
Thanks for not calling them "Holiday Movies"
Reply
12-05-2005 @ 4:35PM
Bob Sassone said...
Yeah, there was only room on the list for a non-Xmas Xmas movie, and I gave it to Condor.
Reply
12-05-2005 @ 5:32PM
Marsha said...
No Grinch?? Not an animated film in the bunch. No Charlie Brown Christmas, no Heatmiser, no Land of Misfit Toys....
Reply
12-05-2005 @ 5:52PM
Bob Sassone said...
Marsha: those aren't really movies, they're TV specials. That's a whole other list I'm sure we'll be covering over at TV Squad. :)
Reply
12-05-2005 @ 6:01PM
Ross Miller said...
Nightmare Before Christmas? I'm just throwing that out there...
Reply
12-05-2005 @ 6:25PM
The Jeremy said...
*A Christmas Story*. Awesome flick. It even has the real Kolchak the Night Stalker in it too...with a lamp fetish.
*Batman Returns*. A Christmas time action flick, even if it is the worst of the Burton Batman films.
*Bad(der) Santa*. 'Nuff said.
*Die Hard* was already cited, but I thought the sequel was also set during Christmas. Just had a discussion about that with a co-worker. Same goes for at least one of the *Lethal Weapon* films.
Next?
Reply
12-05-2005 @ 7:36PM
Michael Glatz said...
The last surviving adult actor from "It's a Wonderful Life" is Argentina Brunetti, at 98 years young. You can catch her colorful site at www.argentinabrunetti.com Seems to be a truly amazing woman, with a history among the stars of now and yesterday, that one cannot fanthom. Supposedly, after writing the 150 year family history into her recently published book "In Sicilian Company" (a must read book available through www.InSicilianCompany.com) someone asked "what now?" to which she went off and did an exercise video. Amazing woman!
Reply
12-05-2005 @ 7:39PM
Bear Silber said...
Not a Christmas movie but rather a holiday movie, "8 Crazy Nights"
Reply
12-05-2005 @ 8:58PM
Chris said...
No love for "Muppet Christmas Carol"? Sad.
Reply
12-05-2005 @ 11:30PM
cathie osullivan said...
Merry Christmas Bob! I will definately agree with you on It's a Wonderful Life, A Christmas Story, Miracle on 34th Street and even Bad Santa....but you HAVE to include the Griswold's Christmas Vacation! Every year I look forward to suffering and rejoicing along with Clark and his forlorn, but loving family!!! I also wonder why not The Grinch? We have all heard and/or read the story and seen the animated one a hundred times!!
Reply
12-06-2005 @ 12:27AM
Diana said...
Hi, Bob! Came here via Throwing Things ... Had to mention one of my fave holiday movies, "The Ref." Thanks for your list. I added "A Christmas Story" and the George C. Scott "A Christmas Carol" to my Netflix queue because, after seeing your list, I realized my daugher, 7, hasn't seen these yet. Oh! And "Elf" is magical ... wasn't it produced by Peter Billingsley of "A Christmas Story" fame? Perfect, huh?
Reply
12-06-2005 @ 6:24AM
Argentina Brunetti said...
Approaching my 99th year, I am the last surviving adult cast member of "It's a Wonderful Life," . When we filmed it in 1946, none of us had any idea that the film would would become a Christmas Classic, in fact, in it's original release, it actually lost money. I have many fond memories of making the movie and the several cast reunions held in the 1990s that I recount among many other hollywood stories in my bio novel, "In Sicilian Company" which can be ordered on amazon.com and at book stores across America. The book, like the movie, is all about love and the triumph over adversity. Its proceeds will go to childrens charities, so they too can have a wonderful life.
Merry Christmas,
Argentina Brunetti
Reply
12-06-2005 @ 9:20AM
Scott said...
You didn't mention The Ref. Judy Davis, Kevin Spacey and Dennis Leary.
Reply
12-06-2005 @ 2:06PM
armen said...
what about Home Alone!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply
12-10-2005 @ 4:56PM
ChristmasCloud said...
Great list, but you don't have any animated films on your list. How about "The Happy Elf"? It's kind of like "Elf" but animated. Really cute and great for the kids. www.thehappyelf.com is where you can see the trailer.
Reply
12-12-2005 @ 12:18AM
sean taylor said...
The Iron Giant. The basic themes and plots have nothing to do with Christmas, but when the snow begins to fall in the beautiful north eastern setting...nice.
Reply
12-22-2005 @ 9:19AM
Michael Glatz said...
DATELINE - ROME, ITALY - 20 DECEMBER 2005: ARGENTINA BRUNETTI passed away in her sleep last night at the age of 98. She left us with the knowledge that she had fulfilled her dream of recounting the story of her theatrical family to the world and that her novel on this subject, “In Sicilian Company”, had finally been published. Among her last wishes were that proceeds of her book and any future related movie or TV mini series would go to the Argentina Brunetti Foundation, to help needy children throughout the world. She also did not want to have her ‘Argentina Brunetti‘s Hollywood Stories’ weekly weblog stopped. Her son, Mario Brunetti, has promised his mother that all these programs will continue. Argentina’s entertainment legacy began in 1907 when she was born and baptized on the stage of the Arbeo Theater in Buenos Aires, Argentina. Her dream of following in her mother’s footsteps as an actress would not be daunted and through tenacity and determination, she overcame many adversities in her long life, following that dream, first expressing her artistic attributes as a painter and pianist in school, then appearing in stage plays all over the world, voice synchronizing motion pictures in Hollywood, followed by her acting in movies, beginning with “It’s a Wonderful Life” and television, totaling one hundred and thirty five films. She was also a song writer, radio script writer and talk show host, Voice of America narrator, Hollywood Foreign Press journalist, author and even weblogger. She has been honoured for her artistic and journalistic achievements throughout her career and was awarded the title of "Cavalier of the Republic" by the government of Italy, for her efforts in enhancing Italian – U.S. relations through her many positive film portrayals of Italians and Italian Americans. She has also been nominated for a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame. Throughout her life, Argentina always had a positive attitude and considered life a series of challenges where anything and everything was possible if one made the required efforts. She not only hoped for a better world, but did many things to make it happen and for this she will be truly missed by family and friends around the world. Argentina will rest in peace along side her husband Miro at Holy Cross Cemetery in Los Angeles, California. Visit her webblog at www.ArgentinaBrunetti.com
Reply