Jet Li's Fearless lawsuit
Filed under: Action, Drama, Foreign Language, Celebrities and Controversy, Newsstand, Cinematical Indie
The grandson of Kung-Fu master Huo Yuanjia, portrayed by Jet Li in his new film, Fearless,
filed a lawsuit last week against the film's producers and distributors in an effort to halt Fearless' release.
According to Huo Shoujin (who, by the way, along with the elder Huo's sons and other grandsons, doesn't exist in the
film - Li's Huo has no decedents), the film "contains numerous fabrications about his grandfather's life and
besmirches his reputation," though the lawsuit offers no specifics about said fabrications and besmirchments. The
decedents of the elder Huo have previously complained about film's depiction of his upbring as posh, whereas in fact
their grandfather was poor as a boy. Huo is demanding both a "written apology," and that the film be pulled
from release (it's already out in a lot of Asian territories, and will hit Japan, the US, Germany, Korea, and France
later this year).Correct me if I'm wrong here, but it's always been my understanding that filmmakers are allowed to take a whole lot of license with their fictional projects. Hell, if the all-powerful William Randolph Hearst couldn't stop Citizen Kane (at least not through legal channels), it's unlikely this case will go anywhere. At least, it better not - if courts started to set precedents whereby the relatives of those portrayed in fiction films control content via lawsuits, all hell would break loose.*
*The angry cannibal case from earlier this month is different, because that decision was based not on the film's content, but on the fact that its presence in the public discourse might affect an on-going trial.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-01-2006 @ 7:47PM
shaun cottle said...
The film does not claym to be a documentary work & as a drama it was excellently made the story is well told & the acting is superb so why would anyone have a problem with it.Have the descendant of Huo Yuanjia, nothing better to do with there time than cause this fuss which means eveb more publicity for the film surley no one believe everything in dragon or fighter in the wind
Reply
5-01-2006 @ 12:32PM
t said...
jesus christ this is just a movie, Huo Yuanjia must be really pleased that his name is now known to a hell of alot more people, so what if some parts of the film is untrue.
If it dosent depict Huo Yuanjia in a negative way then who cares right?
i for one cant wait to see the film.
Reply
6-09-2006 @ 11:21AM
Carlito Bayne said...
I agree with the family. If you are not going to tell the story right you shouldn't tell it at ALL!I nust admit the movie was good, but if it's no where near the truth then his family, students and schools have a right to be upset. It's not just a MOVIE IT'S HIS LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply