Mista Kotta, Mista Kotta!
Filed under: Comedy, Casting, Deals, The Weinstein Co., Newsstand, Remakes and Sequels
Ok, I'm a huge hypocrite. Every time a remake shows up in
the news, I get angry and depressed, and you guys have to listen to it. But now I read about a movie version of
Welcome Back, Kotter (Which is sort of a remake, right? It, too, finds an established story and cast and
decides that it just wasn't good enough the first time around.), and I find myself giggling with glee. Why the
excitement, you ask? Well, apart from the fact that I'm sort of a sucker for anything cultural that reminds me of being
a kid (Yes, including parachute pants.), the revelation that ICE CUBE IS GOING TO PLAY MR. KOTTER is more than enough
to make my day. Apart from Cube's mere presence, there are a few other details about the project that suggest it might not suck. First of all, he loves the show, which hopefully means he'll be eager to do it justice. Additionally, since the rights are held in part by Gabe Kaplan (aka Mr. Kotter himself) who has long-resisted a movie version of the show, the fact that he's OKed this project suggests that he's pleased with the approach (either that or The Weinsteins broke the bank to get him on board). The only major flaw so far is that Tom Brady (the guy who wrote and directed The Hot Chick, not the quarterback) is both penning the script and directing the film, but I'm choosing to ignore that troubling news and assuming instead that the movie is going to be a little bit of brilliance. Assuming, of course, that Rob Schneider doesn't show up in any capacity.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
3-16-2006 @ 2:25PM
Devra said...
I hope they film it in Brooklyn! My claim to fame? You know the kid on the unicycle as the credits roll? No, I'm not that kid, BUT I lived on that block! That is MY street!
Does Ice Cube have a Yiddish coach? He might be wise to get one of those. ; )
Looking forward to the film and I agree, Rob Schneider needs to keep back!
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 2:33PM
Jamie said...
PERSONALLY, I think what made the show was the huge variety of cultural background of the ensemble. Kotter as a Jew, Boom Boom Washington, Vinnie Barbarerro (SP?) It was a melting pot just like our country. Who are they going to get to laugh like Horshack? I am not sure Ice Cube is a good choice. Ice-T would have been interesting to me. Why mess with success though and change the character so much by changing their cultural background.
JMO
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 2:45PM
Louie said...
Here we go again...the show was awesome, but the movie will stink...why? How can Ice Cube play Kotter? Kotter was a JEWISH!!! It's just like with Kojak...Kojak was GREEK...how can a black guy play him? What's next? Denzel playing Baretta? It's Horsesh*t...another thing...they'll probably make the whole thing a hip hop rap type of deal...and get some rapper to slaughter John Sebastian's excellent theme song...
One last thing....what ever happened to the angry, militant, down with AmeriKKKa Ice Cube? Guess he's found the wrror of his ways. Hell, he's the new Sinbad ain't he?
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 2:59PM
eddie said...
Ice Cube as Kotter is a joke...it's like Cedric the Entertainer being Ralph Kramden in the Honeymooners movie...did ANYONE see that or did that open only on overseas flights? Gary Shandling would be perfect, actually after seeing Kaplan on TV in the poker tournament he still looks like he could pull off his own role.........ed
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 3:15PM
Karen said...
I LOVED "Welcome Back Kotter" as a kid and when I read that it was being made into a movie, I was like "Awesome, I can't wait!". Now that I read that Ice Cube will be/might be playing Mr. Kotter, I'M PISSED! It makes absolutely no sense! The ethnic diversity really made the show and that's where alot of the humor comes from. I agree with the person that asked "Who saw the Honeymooners remake with Cedric the Entertainer?" I sure didn't - they botched it... and if Ice Cube plays Mr. Kotter, that movie will be botched too! Nobody's saying Ice Cube is not a good actor. I'm just saying, that's not the right role for him. Please Ice Cube - get your big ego out of the way and let Mr. Kotter be cast properly! There will be other roles for you!! (And this is not a racial thing, 'cause I'm black).
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 3:30PM
Me said...
Wouldn't it be a riot to have John Travolta play Kotter !!! Now that would be a twist !
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 3:39PM
Jason Frerking said...
HAHAHA! I SAW The Honeymooners ON an overseas flight... twice. It's bad when that's your best option on the plane. And some rapper already DID remake the song... Mase's "Welcome Back" anyone?
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 3:41PM
Don said...
What's this crap about another black man playing a white role.There have been blacks playing Kojak and the Honeymooners and now you say Kotter?Give me a break!!How would blacks like a white guy to play the life of Martin Luther King.It is rediculous.There has even been a black version of the Wizard of Oz--pure sacrilege!!! What a perverted bunch we have in tv and movies now.
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 3:46PM
Mr Weasel said...
I think its stupid for them to switch people like this. Like its already been said, Kotter was a Jew, not black. The fact that Ice Cube, or whatever his name is, is in it, probably means its going to be some sort of lame black comedy. I do not trust him with this remake. I will however see it, to see how it fares in comparison to my expectations. cheers.
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 4:10PM
shawn said...
ICECUBE IS BOTH AN ACCOMPLISHED ACTOR DIRECTOR PRODUCER AS WELL AS RAPPER/ENTERTAINER SO ALL OF THESE NEGATIVE COMMENTS AMMOUNTS TO NO MORE THAN RACIST COWARDS WHO ONCE AGAIN USE RACE IN AN ATTEMPT TO HOLD BACK AN AFRICAN AMERICAN'S CONTRIBUTION IN MAINSTREAM MOVIES/THEATER.THE AMERICAN FLAG SHOULD BE BLACK RED AND WHITE B/C WHEN MOST WHITES SEE BLACK THEY TURN RED. IN CLOSING IF U WANT TO BE UPSET ABOUT A THIEF THAT CHOPPED UP A GREAT ART THINK ELVIS.
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 4:31PM
Bubba said...
To repeat what was stated earlied, why do people think that by remaking something anc completely changing the whole thing it will be a big hit, examples honeymooners (which none of the actors ever heard or seen the show before they got the role), wild wild west where will smith trashed a legendary series, and every other role that should be white person given to black actor for reperations. I can only imagine the uproar if someone wanted to remake a movie version of whats happenin' and jim carey was cast as jimmy walker, you would think there were public lynchings in hollywood
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 4:37PM
Jason said...
This will suck. Just like the horrible Honeymooners movie... it just shows that those in Hollywood haven't an original bone in their collective bodies. Ice Cube will play Kotter? So instead of it being campy on an all white scale it will be made into a 'Barbershop' movie in a schoolhouse... Sorry.. this is going to suck... its not like IceCube is Lawrence Olivier... If Samuel Jackson or Morgan Freeman (seeing as they seem to want an African American lead) were to be cast it would be a movie id give a chance to... now? It will be out for 3 weeks and be in Blockbuster in the "yeah.. this was actually a real movie" section in 4.
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 4:48PM
Rob Schneider said...
This is going to be be so good who cares if MR. Kotter was a jooo Ice cube playing him this is going to be great I cant wait I'll definetly pay 7 bucks to see this even if I cant be in it.
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 4:57PM
A said...
Wow i'm with Shawn you guys are racist! For God's sake IT'S AN INNER CITY SCHOOL IN BROOKLYN NY! And Having Ice Cube as Kotter is perfectly fine! now if it was based in freak'n Nazi Germany in WWII then complain! and Kotter being Jewish doesn't mean he can't be African-American! they both can co-exist in one person you uncultured vultures should learn how to suck it up!
Kudos to Ice Cube for take'n on Kotter!
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 5:06PM
fred said...
Ice Cube entertainer yes actor yes , so he can play the role right , umm not right , I love welcome back kotter , but as was previously said kotter was jewish , on the other hand how about remaking Sanford and Son or how about Goodtimes or even Whats Happening , I would love to see these remade ,I think hollywood has gone way too far to the left , and is just out to prove something , thanks
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 5:21PM
Jared said...
I agree about hollywood running out of original ideas. Welcome Back Kotter was one of my favorite shows growing up! Ive thought about it and I dont mind Ice Cube playing Kotter AS LONG as they keep him the same type of guy. I mean Kotter was somewhat of a dork with a terrible sense of humor, he stood for what he believed in but was in no way a strong imposing individual, which is typically how I see Ice Cube and his characters. And yes like someone mentioned, Judaism is NOT a skin tone its a religios affiliation. Hopefully they will do the original much more justice than the honeymooner remake did. I was kind of excited to see the Honeymooners but once I saw it I was so disappointed! I look forward to seeing Welcome Back Kotter's remake.
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 5:21PM
Martin said...
I think Frankie Muniz should play Lionel.
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 5:25PM
Tami said...
Wow, how angry this topic seems to make people. When/if this movie comes out, sounds like it might be a good idea to read a book that day instead.
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 5:28PM
linda said...
All these negative comments about Ice Cube being Mr Kotter, and how
bad it will be for a BLACK MAN to play him. Gabe Kaplan gave his
approval, so he thinks it will be good. If some of you had your way,
there would be NO African Americans on T.V, on Theaters screens or on
stage.Besides, I didn't think the original was all that anyway. A
bunch of delinquents, oh, that's real funny. Why don't you keep your
negative comments on hold until after the movie's made. ICE CUBE CAN
ONLY MAKE A BAD SHOW BETER.
----------------------------------------------
Reply
3-16-2006 @ 5:32PM
Jill said...
Who cares what color the teacher is? The premise came from the CAST being multicultural. I've seen Ice Cube in such diverse rolls from WAY back when that I think he just MAYBE can pull this off. Okay, you have a Latino, Italian, Black, and Jew; has everyone forgotten that these kids came from the same place? Lived in the same neighborhood? As did Mr. Kotter. What made that show was that despite the differences of ethnicity these people came from the same place with the same experiences. SIGNED - JUAN EPSTEINS MOTHER!!! LOL!!!
Reply