Syriana Censored, Brokeback Denied
Filed under: Drama, Romance, Thrillers, Mystery & Suspense, Distribution, Newsstand, Politics
Somewhat surprisingly, Syriana is playing in the United Arab Emirates right now, and it's
(mostly) intact. About two minutes of footage have been removed from Stephen Gaghan's epic tale of oil and corruption at the request of
government authorities; among other things, those two minutes include "scenes showing mistreatment of Asian
workers in the Gulf;" "a brief shot showing the late Saudi King Fahd in a photograph:" "a comment
made by Matt Damon's character linking the business interests of the Bin Laden's family to the holy city of
Mecca." The film was more carefully reviewed than most that are showed in the UAE, and was actually examined by
two different government bodies before the final cuts were made.In other censorship news, a foolishly idealistic distributor in the Middle East has scrapped plans to show Brokeback Mountain there (what with homosexuality being both illegal and morally condemned in many Middle Eastern nations). According to a representative of Italia films, when they asked various governments in the region for their feelings about releasing the movie, the consensus response was "they would rather not deal with it." Gee, that's a shock.












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-19-2006 @ 3:46PM
keating said...
Why do you feel it alright to make such abject generalizations about the Middle East? Have you seen what happened when reporters asked President Bush about whether he had seen 'Brokeback Mountain', he shrugged it off and said something to the effect of 'not wanting to deal with it'. Look I understand you wrote this on a blog and well bloggers are essentially accountable to no one. Still it doesn't give you the right to speak with such prejudice, albeit passive and subdued, towards the Middle East. Before you get the wrong idea, I am American and a scholar of Middle Eastern area studies and it truly pains me to see this kind of writing on a blog which I read quite regularly.
Reply
4-19-2006 @ 4:28PM
Martha Fischer said...
Keating-
The size of posts makes it difficult to go into too much detail, but I'm sorry to have offended you. Please feel free to offer the details I have left out, and of which I and others may be ignorant. (Also, please, understand that the "not wanting to deal with it" thing is a quote, not a sentiment I arbitrarily made up.)
Reply
4-22-2006 @ 12:53PM
Jason said...
One question: has President Bush (or any other part of the American government) EVER stoned anyone to death for being gay? Maybe Bush didn't want to "deal with it" but the facts speak for themselves: oppresive regimes in the Middle East kill gay people. That is not generalization. As a gay person, I find it offensive that people like you insist on defending a faith that one rather see me dead.
Reply