Another Lying Author Torpedoes the Movie
Filed under: Comedy, Drama, Romance, Deals, Warner Brothers, Newsstand, Dreamworks
Yet another plagiarism scandal is screwing up a
studio's movie plan. Last time, it was James Frey's largely made up "memoir" A Million Little
Pieces, the film adaptation of which is being "reevaluated" (studio speak
for "has been drawn and quarter with much malice, and is now rotting in the basement") by Warner Brothers,
and now it's DreamWorks that has been screwed over by a writer to whom they gave a lot of money.The writer in question is Harvard sophomore (Yes, she's disgustingly accomplished. Or least she was.) Kaavya Viswanathan who didn't copy anything, exactly, she just "read Megan McCafferty's books [so] voraciously in high school" that she "unintentionally mimicked them" in her debut novel, How Opal Mehta Got Kissed, Got Wild, and Got a Life, which features dozens of passage that are virtually identical to those found in McCafferty's works. (Don't you hate when that happens? While trying to write posts, I often find myself accidentally typing exact passages from Middlemarch -- it's just so hard to control these things.)
Despite that whole "it was an accident!" thing, Viswanathan's book has been pulled from stores, and DreamWorks, which has already received the first draft of the film version's screenplay, has reportedly decided to cut their loses and bury the project.












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-28-2006 @ 3:19PM
Cath said...
Doesn't it scare you that a publishing company can vet a book and not catch widespread and flagrant plagiarism? Makes me wonder about the scientists involved in our nuclear program.
Reply
4-30-2006 @ 11:47AM
T. said...
It's not like a publishing house can have every passage of every novel ever written committed to memory. It wasn't like she stole from a universally-known book like Catcher in the Rye or Tale of Two Cities. I'd cut them some slack.
I think it's more of a sign about how publishing houses jump on any book that fits whatever current trend is in the market now. There's an indian female author trend cuz of Jhumpa Lahiri? Let's get that. There's a minority femeale empowerment trend thanks to Terry McMillan and Amy Tan? Let's get any book that relates to that.
I think this author was just being calculating in giving the publishing houses a book that contained as many trends as possible: Ivy league author, Indian background, female empowerment (c'mon, doesn't the title and cover look just like an INdian version of "How Stella Got Her Groove Back?")
http://johnnytriangles.blogspot.com
Reply