TIFF Review: Zidane: A 21st Century Portrait
Filed under: Documentary, Drama, Sports, Theatrical Reviews, Festival Reports, Toronto International Film Festival

There is a majesty to soccer that fans of the sport can find in all but the most pedestrian games; a grace and dignity to the flow and shape of the game, the discovery of which can spark a life-long obsession. Within the sport itself, there are certain players who embody those traits, through their styles of play and the way they carry themselves. These are not necessarily the greatest players -- as great as they are, Luis Figo, Andrei Shevchenko and Ronaldinho don't have the presence I'm talking about -- but when you see them play, you recognize the spark immediately. Italian icon Paolo Maldini has it. And, French god Zinédine Zidane, despite -- or maybe because of -- his ever-present temper -- has it too. There's an economy to his movements and an easy, natural poise to the way he watches the pitch that sets him apart from others, and makes it impossible to keep your eyes off him, despite his deceptively simple style of play.
In April, 2005, video artists Douglas Gordon and Philippe Parreno went a step further, training 17 cameras on Zidane for the length of a single La Liga game. The cameras were scattered all over the stadium, and recorded images ranging from intimate close-ups to beautiful long shots that take in the whole pitch; from unfocused collections of colors to more traditional, television-style action shots. Zidane: A 21st Century Portrait is the 90-minute compilation of those images and, for lovers of the game, it's awe-inspiring. More an art film that a sports documentary, Zidane is something that must be experienced on the big screen.
The movie is difficult to describe, because it's a feeling as much as anything else. Compiled from a dizzying array of cameras, angles and footage sources, the movie's only constant is that, during the game, Zidane is always on screen. The only exceptions are a few replays, but for the most part he is our focus, not the game. So when the action is taking place in the Real Madrid end, we stay with Zidane. He wipes his face, taps his toes, stalks the pitch. Away from the ball, he's relaxed, but not really -- there's a coiled strength in him, always, and when he explodes into action it takes your breath away. Even at the end of his career, Zidane's power and pace are breath-taking, particularly when we've been isolated with him, watching, away from the speed of the game.
Even when Zidane is the not the exclusive focus of what we see, there's something about him that has always drawn the eye. He's brutishly, powerfully handsome, and his low brows give his already intense eyes an added, intimidating power. And even seen from afar, when he's nothing more than a white jersey and a mostly bald head, we can pick him out with ease. Unlike everyone around him, Zidane plays with his back straight, and his shoulders back. His posture sets him apart, as does the simplicity of his movements. When he runs, there's a relief and joy to it, as if his body has finally been released to serve its true purpose. Other players -- David Beckham, for example, and Wayne Rooney -- run with a strange, barely contained fury; there's a sense that they're battling not only those around them, but their bodies as well. With Zidane, there's an almost laughable peace that comes when he's finally allowed to run; the ease of his pace and efficiency of his movements make us instantly aware that we're watching something special.
In Zidane, all of these glorious moments are held together by a carefully wrought, virtually perfect soundtrack. The audio in the film is a combination of diegetic sound -- crowd nose, shoes on grass, shouts, the impact of bodies -- and a phenomenal, hypnotic score, created by the Scottish band Mogwai. Though the on-pitch sounds were all created after shooting, they remain utterly realistic, and it's strangely moving to hear the level and clarity of the sounds change as Zidane himself moves in and out of the game. At times, there's total, pure silence; at others, the noise of 80,000 fans is almost deafening. As the game progress and Zidane's focus increases, the score begins to rise, suggesting the player's growing distance from the world around him. There's a wonderful, melancholy feel to Mogwai's dreamy music that adds to the film's emotional impact; there's no doubt the work as a whole would be less coherent without their contribution.
Zidane: A 21st Century Portrait washes over the audience in a combination of light, sound and emotion, somehow encapsulating everything that is great about soccer into a single man, in a single game. If you don't love the game, stay far away. If, however, you're one of the people for whom soccer is a fact of life, do everything you can to see this movie: It's both a revelation and a simple confirmation of everything you've ever believed, and an incredibly powerful, deeply emotional experience.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-14-2006 @ 5:56PM
Sarah said...
I really want to see this movie. I love Zidane! Do you have any idea when it is going to be released further? I live in Tennessee...any chance of it coming here?!
Reply
9-14-2006 @ 7:23PM
Awperator said...
Wow, amazing review. I want to see this really bad now. Zidane (in my opinion) is the most talented football player out there. Excellent ball handing skills. Amazing to watch. Too bad he retired, I would love to see him play some more.
Reply
9-14-2006 @ 7:22PM
Sawsan said...
Thank you dear writer, for an exceptional, imposing and brilliant article about " Zidane ". I have read many wonderful sports reviews about this incomparable and great person, but honestly, non like this one! You have given him the proper and impartial words to portray his elegance and unique stylishness, about his presence that has a beautiful enigma, his love of the game that was shown in the way he played. To so many that adore him and know how outstandingly, gracefully and charmingly he plays.. he will be in our minds and souls, as the man who stole our hearts and made football a passionate game that made the difference in out lives. Thank you Zidane, for the beautiful years we have shared with you. You shall be greatly missed.
Reply
9-18-2006 @ 1:01PM
Y Dhiman said...
Where can you see this movie in LA area
Reply
9-14-2006 @ 8:20PM
Martha Fischer said...
For those of you who have asked about seeing this film in the US, unfortunately it doesn't have US distribution (and is unlikely to get it). My guess is that your best bet would be to check out modern art museums; they might screen it because of the reputation of the directors. Otherwise, we can always hope for a foreign DVD ...
Reply
9-15-2006 @ 1:29AM
Chapman Choi said...
Great review! I was there yesterday watching this film too. One interesting thing I want to point out. I saw a couple of audience wearing Zidane's jersey. I could imagine that they are fans of Zidane, but I don't know how much of a fan they are. Because I would say this film is not for normal soccer fans (unless you are crazy for Zidane that you want to watch only him for 90 minutes), but for true film lovers who also like soccer. And it looks like Universal is the distributer in North America, I am not sure though. But I doubt they would release this film the the theatres, since this film is more of an art film that unlikely to make money.
Reply
9-17-2006 @ 12:48PM
hornblower said...
With Zidane, there's an almost laughable peace that comes when he's finally allowed to run; the ease of his pace and efficiency of his movements make us instantly aware that we're watching something special. the simplicity of his movements. When he runs, there's a relief and joy to it, as if his body has finally been released to serve its true purpose. . . Zidane's power and pace are breath-taking, particularly when we've been isolated with him, watching, away from the speed of the game. . . With Zidane, there's an almost laughable peace that comes when he's finally allowed to run; the ease of his pace and efficiency of his movements make us instantly aware that we're watching something special."
When I read these words I thought that if one were to replace your name for Zidane's and analogize the depiction of his athleticism to a description of your written words-- I could aptly portray the ease and beauty with which you write.
Thank you
Reply
9-18-2006 @ 12:43PM
SF said...
Thanks for the sensitive review, which came to me via my daily Google Zidane Alert!
Could you be the fellow-NYer next to whom I was standing in line for this film at the TIFF with my soccer-playing nephew? I take note because it's not often I meet fellow female football fanatic cinephiles! (Zidane and Godard paper my cube at work.)
Do you blog about soccer anywhere?
gaiesavoir@gmail.com
Reply
9-18-2006 @ 1:29PM
gai savoir said...
As the author indicated, it does not yet have theatrical release, so you should look for it at the museums and the art house cinemas--places like the Nuart. I'm sure the author will post if she hears about a theatrical release planned for the states.
Good luck!
Reply
9-27-2006 @ 10:18AM
sandrahn said...
Thank you so much for this beautiful review, and thank you to the posters for writing such wonderful things about the greatest footballer in the post-Maradona era. It's wonderful to know his fans have not abandoned him. Zidane is exceptional, he brought magic and art and majesty to the pitch. I had the great privilege of watching him play live at 3 different matches - I can tell you that TV does not do justice to him. Everyone who sees him play in person is awed by his perfect touches on the ball, his visionary control, the way the ball clings to him, the way he changes the very nature of a match in an instant...I have watched the game since I was 5 years old and have loved many players but no one overwhelmed me like Zizou. The sport has lost something great with his retirement. This movie will be made available for purchase soon (keep checking amazon) so I definitely plan to buy it.
Reply
9-28-2006 @ 2:34AM
Xavier said...
Great review, for anyone who wants to see a great Zidane compilation check out:- http://youtube.com/watch?v=7uZf0GtgZK0
Reply
9-29-2006 @ 6:39AM
EL said...
I disagree fundamentally with this review. “Zidane: Un Portrait du 21e Siecle” is, in effect, a modern remake of Hellmut Costard’s curious underground film “Fussball wie noch nie”, thirty-six years after the fact, with Zinedine Zidane replacing George Best. There are, of course, significant differences between the two films in terms of scale and ambition. Costard trained 6 primitive cameras on Best, whilst Zidane had 17 cameras mixing super 35 mm and high-definition following his every move and capturing his every bead of sweat during Real Madrid’s league game against Villarreal in 2005. However, whilst exponentially "bigger" in scale, ambition and technical expertise, like most remakes the film appears to be an overblown imitation of the original.
Significantly, Costard was fascinated by the image and physical appeal of Best, rather than football. The makers of “Zidane” (a Turner Prize winner and a Frenchman!)clearly see football as art and their protagonist as representative. Such conceits have produced an unsatisfying mixture of documentary and art installation, which is nothing like football as we know it. Again, the camera isolates Zidane and makes him the focal point, but the film neither deconstructs the man and his sport nor properly expresses the artistic value of either. The sub-titles which convey Zidane’s thoughts, the use of tv replay and the odd soundtrack are a cop-out, mitigating against Zidane’s “art” speaking for itself, and failing to leaven the tedium of watching one man – albeit supremely talented – run, jog, walk, watch and mope in isolation. There is an implicit and arrogant presumption that only this type of film can do justice to Zidane and “the beautiful game”. At the end of it all we have seen him create a goal, and receive a red card after a familiar explosion of violence, but the film lacks the drama and narrative of a real football match and fails in its artistic objectives. If nothing else, “Zidane” underlines the truism that football is dependent on context, space and perspective. Without these factors, for all the sweat, saliva, physicality and technical trickery, “Zidane, Un Portrait du 21e Siecle”, begs the question: "is that all there is?
Reply
11-20-2006 @ 8:15AM
Perki said...
On reading the original review, I have had to ask whether or not the reviewer and I were watching the same film. 'Zidane: A 21st Century Portrait' strikes me as a noble effort to capture what it claims to capture, namely 'not only the greatest football movie ever made, but also one of the finest studies of man in the workplace, an ode to the loneliness of the athlete and the poise and resilience of the human body' (taken from its official website). To say it fails miserably, is not an understatement but an accurate observation.
Had I not read this description of it before viewing it and hence been waiting and searching for which aspects of the film might present these profound revelations, I would have been entirely bemused by the inability of the film to gloss over a number of paradigms inconsequentially but fail to engage, reflect on or delve further into any of them in a way which might have been described as 'adequate'. There are moments where one may (or may not) be struck by the athleticism of Zidane, and even the nomadic sense of his existence on a football pitch, but the whole the lack of space, context and perspective (identified by EL) makes watching a draining enterprise. The film in no way, as it claims, shows the match from Zidane's perspective - rather it focuses on him from our perspective. The alleged 'commentary' consists of very few, although meaningful, ultimately cliched comments.
I would certainly concur that it is a film for artistic cinema fans ahead of football fans, but even in this sense it is shallow and forgettable. The small mercy is Zidane's sending off, which spares us a final few minutes. Zidane himself remains an inspirational, sublimely talented and clearly deep-thinking genius - but this film fails to uncover or reveal anything about him.
Reply