Sneaky Twee Brit Comedy
Filed under: Comedy, Casting, New Releases, Newsstand
Let me confess -- I get Google news alerts all day long on my favorite actors in the vain hopes of scooping the other, more ingenious cinematical correspondants. I pick weird, quirky actors who bring something more to the picture than just their celebrity-status, and my favorite quirky actors almost always tend to be foreign, more often than not British (with the exception of Dianne Wiest, Ellen Burstyn, and, well ... Donald Sutherland is Canadian).
So I'm amazed that the word on Keeping Mum is, er ... mum, despite its flagrantly awesome cast. From my list of people to watch: Maggie Smith and Rowan Atkinson, as well as Kristin Scott Thomas (who was almost kicked off the list for making out with Harrison Ford, and Up at the Villa, both of which were astoundingly lame movies I will not link to for our collective benefit). Atkinson plays a pastor so preoccupied with penning the perfect sermon that he fails to realize his family's up to no good. At some point The Swayze (I prefer to leave the 'e' silent, because it sounds cool to say The Swayze) shows up, either to distract the family or alert Atkinson.
If you're wondering if you might have seen Ms. Thomas and Mr. Atkinson in a prior comedic flick, also involving a clergyman, you have. If you feel the need to ask whether you've seen Ms. Thomas and Ms. Smith in a film together, you'll get a failing grade in the class titled 'Recent Masterpieces in Twee British Cinema,' because of course they've been in a movie together! I think we all know Mr. Atkinson can do comedy. Ms. Smith has a good deal of comedic bite, and those of you old enough to overlook her Harry Potter role should look to her prime work and say fascisti with a prim face in a wildly exaggerated Scottish accent.
Your bonus question for the comments: What is it that makes British comedy so much more clever than American comedy? Don't be afraid to be obvious.









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-28-2006 @ 4:14PM
Dani said...
I like the anthropological take. I s'pose I can validate that by relating the time in high school when everybody had to memorize and recite the opening passage to the Canterbury Tales, and we slept through everybody's until the hot British kid read his, and all the ladies (including me) swooned.
Reply
9-28-2006 @ 4:23PM
Heather said...
It's the accent that makes BritCom more clever. Americans automatically associate a posh British accent with authority/wisdom (cultural genetic memory from pre-Revolutionary times, I assume), so BritCom automatically is perceived by Americans as being more witty or pithy. And smart (or those believed to be smart) people doing silly things is always hilarious.
Reply
9-28-2006 @ 5:36PM
Scott Macdonald said...
It was released over the pond ages ago. It scrapes the bottom of the barrel for laughs.
http://www.eyeforfilm.co.uk/reviews.php?film_id=11197
Reply
9-28-2006 @ 8:00PM
Geoff said...
I have a nice English accent!
Uh, yeah. Over here, the accent probably means less. BritCom (horrid phrase) is seen as being a bit more cutting, and less likely to please everyone. Political correctness tends to enter into it less - Fawlty Towers, Blackadder and The Office being prime examples of laughing at the less fortunate.
We also tend to have what I have heard described as "self-depreciating charm", which I think is a nice way of saying that we hate being British and enjoy letting everyone else know about it.
Reply
9-30-2006 @ 2:06PM
mike rot said...
Yeah the BBC film reviewer Mark Kermode gave a scathing review of it. Not one laugh. Not that I always agree with Mr. Kermode, he of little faith in Gus Van Sant, but for what it's worth.
Reply