Cinematical Seven: Westerns You Should Watch
Filed under: Drama, Cinematical Seven

I love Westerns. They're such great stories full of symbolism and pathos, often with great performances and compelling characters facing life and death situations. Westerns explore what it means to face your fears, to carve out a life among the harsh wilderness -- to be an American. Cowboys, one of the most enduring and recognized symbols of America, are a part of our history and who we are as a nation.
I remember the first time I watched a Western. My father was a huge John Wayne fan (still is) and when I was pretty young, he took me to see "The Duke" in the movie The Shootist. Even as a young man I reacted to the story about the last days of a gunfighter who knows he's about to die from cancer but wants to go out on his feet, fighting, instead of on his back. After watching the movie, I was hooked. Of course, my experience was made even more special by the fact that The Shootist was John Wayne's last film. How fitting that it should be a Western.
From then on, I watched as many Westerns as I could. Over the years as I grew older, I came to appreciate Westerns not just for their stories, but because of what the stories, characters and situations represent. Over time, I made a list of the Westerns that typify the Western -- those films that would serve as an excellent introduction for anyone wishing to explore this genre. In truth, I could populate this list with films mostly from the same director -- John Ford. His westerns are among the best and most widely acclaimed of all time.
He's an icon of the genre whose best work featured the stalwart and similarly iconic John Wayne. But to be fair, there are many other Westerns that have come out in the history of Hollywood that deserve your attention. Even if you don't love the genre, these films are still an entertaining mix of action, suspense, drama, and romance. They also happen to have compelling characters, horses, fist fights and even the occasional gun fight. And yes, stuff even blows up once in awhile too.
So, settle in at the saloon, pour yourself a shot of rye, and let's take a look at some great Westerns.
Red River (1948) - Directed by Howard Hawks -- Besides John Ford, Hawks is another legend of the Western genre (and many others). In the film, John Wayne plays hard-drinking, tyrannical and often cruel Tom Dunson, boss of a group of cowboys driving a herd to market along the Chisholm Trail. Red River follows Dunston's descent into darkness and the eventual crisis where his dominance is supplanted by the younger, and perhaps better, man Matt Garth -- superbly played by Montgomery Clift. Wayne's performance in this film defies his critics and proves, as voiced perfectly by John Ford, that "that sonuvabitch could act." Yes he could.
High Noon (1952) - Directed by Fred Zinnemann -- A great film told in a very unique way -- in real time. From the moment the film starts, you are counting the minutes -- literally -- until the bad guys arrive on the train for the big showdown with Sheriff Will Kane -- Gary Cooper in one of his best performances. Also outstanding is the luminescent Grace Kelly as the girl who wants Sheriff Kane to give up his violent ways, leave town and live a "normal" life. Some critics of the film, including director Howard Hawks, contend that High Noon isn't a good example of a Western because the main character -- the Sheriff -- asks the townspeople for help fighting the bad guys and in so doing, looks weak and somehow less of a man.
That's probably one of the reasons the role of Will Kane was tuned down by so many actors, including Marlon Brando, Montgomery Clift and Gregory Peck, before Cooper stepped up. Still, when you watch this film there's no other person who could have pulled off Kane's combination of strength, anxiety, uncertainty and vulnerability the way Cooper does. He truly is Will Kane and this film, despite its critics, truly is a great Western and a great film. Sure, it's different -- but in this case, different turns out to be a very good thing.
The Searchers (1956) - Directed by John Ford -- This film is often thought of as one of the best Westerns of all time -- and I couldn't agree more. For me, this revenge tale with a surprise twist ending is the quintessential Western because it explores all the themes and characters of the genre as well as the themes of race and integration during the time just prior to the Civil Rights movement in this country.
The cast is perfect, especially Jeffrey Hunter as Martin and John Wayne as the morally and racially conflicted Ethan Edwards. Of all the Westerns I've seen in my life, this one is my favorite. I watch it every year and each time discover a new appreciation and love for the film. The final scene where Wayne's Ethan Edwards is left standing in the doorway, outside, while the rest of the family goes inside the house is one of the most powerful moments in the history of this or any other genre.
The Magnificent Seven (1960) - Directed by John Sturges -- Made during the time when Hollywood was creating bigger and better spectacles to compete with television -- and based, of course, on the classic Akira Kurosawa film Seven Samurai -- this updated telling of the story which concerns a group of Mexican villagers who seek help from a band of misfits and outlaws to fight off a bigger, and badder, bunch of outlaws, is an extremely entertaining widescreen spectacle.
And, let's not forget the music composed by the late Elmer Bernstein -- as big a part of the movie as anything else -- and which demonstrated a style -- images and music instead of words -- later imitated by other directors, like Sergio Leone, who took up the mantle of the Western. Plus, the cast, including Yul Brynner, Steve McQueen, Charles Bronson, James Coburn, Robert Vaughn and Eli Wallach as the Mexican bandit Calvero, help make this film the hugely fun experience it is.
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (1966) - Directed by Sergio Leone -- Based on another Akira Kurosawa film, Yojimbo, this film is one of the best and most successful of the crop of "Spaghetti Westerns" that came out during this time. Leone's genius was taking an iconic hero of the western - the cowboy - and making him a true anti-hero. Plus, these films cemented the indelible image and career of former TV actor Clint Eastwood and paved the way for his "Dirty Harry" character as well as many other anti-heroes to follow.
Over the years, much has been said about Leone's style in this film, and others that followed. His use of extreme closeups, jump cuts, unusual and often jarring camera angles and long action sequences without dialog all helped change how films are made and influenced a generation of directors. Plus, scene-stealing performances by Eli Wallach as the evil and conniving Tuco and Lee Van Cleef as the cold-blooded and brutal killer Angel Eyes, help elevate this film to the classic status it deserves.
The Wild Bunch (1969) -- Directed by Sam Peckinpah - Before John Woo or anyone used slow motion, Peckinpah used it. His depiction of violence and its aftermath is a visceral ballet that many directors, like Quentin Tarantino, seek to emulate. This film features a stellar cast including William Holden, Ernest Borgnine and Peckinpah staples Warren Oates and Ben Johnson. It explores the lives of cowboys and outlaws at the turn of the century and the end of their way of life. Change with the times or die. Which do you think they choose?
The Wild Bunch is regarded by many, myself included, as Peckinpah's greatest film -- his anti-Western Western. Though many other films have featured the so-called "noble" anti-hero, this film casts aside the "typical" trappings of the western hero and instead shows outlaws, and the lawmen pursuing them at any cost, who seem not to have much knowledge of, or use for, any kind of "Code of the West." Plus, the final gunfight is a visually stunning and extremely brutal tableau of violence that is not to be missed.
Unforgiven (1992) -- Directed by Clint Eastwood - This multi Oscar winning story of a farmer (and former gunfighter) who just wants to work his farm in peace but is forced back into service, revitalized the Western and, yes, reimagined it for the modern world. The spin here is, as director Eastwood maintained, this extremely violent film actually has a strong anti-violence message of violence as a last, but sometimes necessary, resort.
Plus, great performances by Eastwood, Morgan Freeman and academy award winner Gene Hackman, elevated this film to the level of the classic Westerns that proceeded it. The success, both commercially and critically, of this movie helped continue a renaissance for the genre which led to other films (both Westerns and Western-hybrids) like the The Quick and the Dead, Tombstone, The Mask of Zorro, Lone Star and the excellent Deadwood.
If you watch these Westerns, you'll get a very good picture of the power, style and glory of the genre. Plus, you'll have a great time and may even learn one or two things about the nature of man (and woman). Ok, those are my "magnificent" seven. What are yours?










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-30-2006 @ 12:42PM
Akbar Fazil said...
My contributions to the list:
Forget GBU. While it is good it does not hold a candle to Leone's masterpiece "Once Upon a Time in the West"
The Professionals http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0060862/
Not too many people know this one from my experience. Excellent cast and a great film.
Some may think I am crazy for this but
Quigley Down Under
Sure it does not take place in the old west (or even the northern hemisphere but a great tale of classic good guy bad guy. I even got my wife to watch this one and she hates westerns.
Reply
11-30-2006 @ 12:41PM
Jeff said...
One that definitely should be on your list is "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance". That is an all time classic Western. Another one of my favs is El Dorado that starred John Wayne, Robert Mitchum, and a young James Caan. Not the greatest film but a lot of fun to watch.
Reply
12-01-2006 @ 8:51AM
John Mulholland said...
Nice list. Check out THE WESTERNER, with Cooper and Walter Brennan. made a year after STAGECOACH, but has grown richer over the years, while STAGECOACH looks more and more dated. This is against the law of auteurism, since Ford directed STAGECOACH, and William Wyler directed THE WESTERNER. Wyler is not an "auteur" and therefore cannot have done a western the equal of Ford. But check out these two together, and I suspect you'll find out what I say is spot-on.
A shame, really, that the auteur theory has marginalized so many fine films, so many fine performances, so many fine scripts, etc.
Reply
11-30-2006 @ 4:08PM
EO said...
The Searchers and High Noon are so over-hyped.
Winchester '73, Terror in a Texas Town, Forty Guns and Seven Men From Now. Real Westerns.
Reply
11-30-2006 @ 2:09PM
Scott Weinberg said...
EXCELLENT list, Chris, and a perfect place for any "western newbie" to start.
For your next piece, I'd love to see you do seven lesser-known westerns.
Reply
11-30-2006 @ 4:14PM
Christopher Campbell said...
In honor of Altman's death, and the fact that it is my favorite western, I would include McCabe and Mrs. Miller in there.
Reply
12-01-2006 @ 2:31AM
Matt Holmes said...
Can't leave out Once Upon a Time in the West.
The great western about westerns! Everything you need to know about the genre you can watch in that film.
I like John Ford's The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance too.
Reply
11-30-2006 @ 5:47PM
Dave Jones said...
Three things:
One: "Good/Bad/Ugly" is not based on "Yojimbo". "A Fistful of Dollars" is based on "Yojimbo". Getting that fact wrong makes me suspect of the rest of the information in the list.
Two: "Once Upon a Time in the West" is Leone's greatest Western, and should be at the top of the list. "Good/Bad/Ugly" is a popular favorite, but isn't nearly as good a film.
Three: Everyone who loves "The Searchers" seems very happy to ignore the subplots including the Swedes, the musical interludes, and the silly comic relief. But they're all still there, weighing down on the film.
-d
Reply
11-30-2006 @ 9:54PM
Mike Morgan said...
I agree that "Once Upon A Time in The West" was better than "The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly". But Sergio Leone is one of my favourite directors so I love all his westerns.
And I do think that "A Fistful of Dollars" was the Leone film that was based on "Yojimbo" and he got sued for it.
Reply
11-30-2006 @ 5:52PM
Mohaski said...
Even though it takes place in Australia (personally, I don't think locale should matter, and in this instance, it really doesn't), I would nominate THE PROPOSITION as one of the great westerns of all time. It's a beautiful film to look at, the acting is top notch throughout, and Nick Cave's story/screenplay is harrowing, compelling, and oftentimes poetic.
For my money, the best film I saw all year, and an instant classic.
Reply
11-30-2006 @ 7:37PM
Dan said...
Great starter list but as intro for people who maybe a little reticent on the genre, Hawks' Rio Bravo is a great starter. Funny and sharp, it converted my fiance in two hours and we enjoyed many Westerns thereafter.
Will second the Winchester 73 love as well. Al the Mann/Stewart collaborations are great but this one might be the best for newcomers.
Reply
11-30-2006 @ 7:54PM
Kevin said...
I wouldn't suggest Once Upon A Time In The West to a Western beginner. It is much easier to enjoy when you're familiar with some of the fixtures of the genre. That being said, the scene where the wagon rides over the hill, carrying Cardinale and reveals Monument Valley as the music swells is nothing short of hair raising. Amazing stuff.
The Searchers is an amazing film and certainly deserves to be mentioned as a top 5 western. I feel like its humor adds an odd enduring factor to it and I've actually grown to really enjoy its seemingly odd placement in the film.
My Darling Clementine is one of my favorites. Entertaining and with a phenomenal performance out of Fonda.
Overall, my seven would be:
My Darling Clementine
High Noon
The Searchers
The Good, Bad and the Ugly
The Wild Bunch
Unforgiven
The Proposition
Reply
12-01-2006 @ 12:39AM
sean sweeney said...
Okay, breath
I was about to pound out Once Upon A Time In The West, but about 10 people faught for it already (top five favorites - any genra)
But a great one
that I've intoduced to "non western folk" (mostly women)
and everyone has dug
SHANE
George Stevens beautiful anti-capitalism mythical flick.
Sooo good.
It holds up a lot better then Red River and High Noon
Hey personal, I like HIGH PLANES DRIFTER and ecspecially OUTLAW JOSIE WALES more then Unforgiven.
Some others great flicks that streych the boundarys of standard westerns.
My Darling Clemintine
3:10 To Yurma
Little Big Man
Major Dundee
Duck You Sucker
Leone's two Dollars flicks
The Beguiled
Lonesom Dove (TV)
Ulzana' Raid
Hombre
The Road Warrior
Reply