Sources Say Shyamalan May Be Struggling To Sell Latest Script
Filed under: Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Thrillers, RumorMonger, Scripts, Steven Spielberg
I'm not going to take this opportunity to say that I always believed M. Night Shyamalan is a hack. Sure, I never bought into the hype that he was the next Spielberg or Hitchcock, but I do like one of his films (Unbreakable) and I think he has some brilliant scenes in two others (The Sixth Sense and Signs). After two flops, though, he seems to be running out of good ideas and out of loyal defenders. Of course, he's still a talented director of suspenseful scenes, and he's still pretty young.In a post about the biggest flops of last year, I wrote that it is probably a good time for Shyamalan to try directing someone else's script. And maybe he was reading (I doubt it), because two weeks later the announcement came that he was, yes, directing someone else's script. Or, at least adapting someone else's idea and then directing that. However, it now appears he's still trying his luck (and his own ideas). Insiders told TMZ recently that Shyamalan is shopping his latest original script around Hollywood, and so far he isn't seeing a lot of interest.
The script is reportedly titled Green Planet, and it has something to do with an alien invasion. Claude Brodesser-Akner at TMZ thinks the concept sounds too much like War of the Worlds, but even so, I think it is more of a problem that we've already seen an alien invasion story from Shyamalan. And despite an amazing sequence midway through that story, the film, Signs, is a pretty silly thriller. At this point, Shyamalan should just be happy with his potential franchise in Avatar: The Last Airbender.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
1-28-2007 @ 8:50AM
rockne said...
just curious: what amazing sequence halfway through are you referring to?
Reply
1-28-2007 @ 9:22AM
jkmkay said...
I'd like to know also,what amazing sequence?
Reply
1-28-2007 @ 1:57PM
Richard von Busack said...
I don't know what this rough outlines sounds more like: Invasion of the Body Snatchers or Day of the Triffids. Anyway, as Homer Simpson said, it's a coincidence worthy of one of M. Night's increasingly lousy movies.
Reply
1-28-2007 @ 11:03AM
david said...
he must be talking about the scene on the basement, it was good, but it was a ripped off of "the birds"
Reply
1-28-2007 @ 1:39PM
Rich said...
Its about time Hollywood stopped feeding that man's ego. He got lucky twice and felt he was the next great director. The powers at be fell for it and supported his egomania.
He really needs to just take a break permanently. If he never did another movie again I would be happy. He should have stopped at Unbreakable.
Reply
1-28-2007 @ 10:12PM
Christopher Campbell said...
I was referring to the scene in the basement. Maybe it rips off the scene from The Birds, but I still found it to be effective and brilliantly shot. Or maybe at least in comparison with the rest of the film. Also the South American birthday party scene is well done.
Anyway, the Body Snatchers scenario might be right. I read that he was thinking of making his next film in that tradition.
Reply
1-29-2007 @ 1:29PM
Cath said...
I also always thought he was rather a hack. Sixth Sense was only okay with a totally predictable ending 20 minutes into the film (so who was surprised who knows anything about plotting?). His other films have been all mood and no story. But after dissing folks who were only trying to help him, few in Hollywood will trust him again, especially when he held them out to ridicule. And it turned out that they were right. Next, you'll be seeing him directing Joe Eszterhas' sequel to Burn Hollywood Burn.
Reply