Cinematical

In my opinion, Order of the Phoenix isn't a weak book necessarily, but the pacing is definitely sluggish at times. Though it is my least favorite of all of them, but I haven't read it in a while.

Reply

For anyone who needs to brush up on their HP background before the release of the OOTP movie, wiseGEEK has put together a collection of articles about Harry, Hogwarts, and other happenings! There's predictions and theories for us experts, but also lots of definitions and background for HP novices!

I thought it'd be a great resource for you and your readers:
http://www.wisegeek.com/the-life-and-times-and-possible-death-of-harry-potter.html

Reply

order of the phoenix is a very internal book. A lot of it has to do with the main characters not talking to each other and being mad at each other (at least as I recall). The adults are all trying to position themselves to deal with Voldemort's return, and the kids feel left out. There are a few set action scenes with lots of magic flying about the room, but it's more of a mood piece. I remember reading it and saying to my wife that it would be difficult to turn this one into a strong movie, so we'll see.

Reply

I liked Order. I just finished rereading it. I am more afraid the movie will cut out too much of the book. The producer, I think, already said there will be no Quiddich in the movie. That takes out a big storyline with Harry, Fred and George being banned for life, so Ginny and Ron join the team. And that also leaves out Weasley is Our King. As these books get longer and the studio still dictates the running time, I hope they are filming extra stuff so they can do a directors cut later one. While I loved the Goblet of Fire movie, but it felt a little hollow because alot of the book got cut out or changed. I realize movie adaptations aren't the same as the book but the first Potter movie was almost spot on to the book and with a fan base like Potter has, they can afford a longer movie, or even releasing it in two parts like Tarantino did with Kill Bill.

Reply

As an elementary school teacher, I do find that this is the sluggish of all the books. This will probably effect the movie. But the sixth book is much faster and more enjoyable. So this just maybe a movie to get to the final chapters.

http://blog.mctimages.com

Reply

Not sluggish. The movie should have a certain feeling of..i dunno, it should def. show the repression and all in the school, but i doubt it will. I didnt think the previous films were all that good, but hopefully this one will nail it

Reply

I found it one of the more compelling books with some of the most intensely real school events of the series. But too often the films spend too much time on ancillary things while disregarding the emotional direction of the story. The prior one was so fantastically directed, it tends to put the others in more obvious contrast.

Reply

I loved OotP just because of the whole Dumbledore's Army idea. I think that if they don't cut that out then it should be enjoyable.

Reply

Well I just read a review over at Mugglenet by someone at the screening who is a Potter fan and I am left disappointed. It seems they cut some good plotlines altogether, and the one I feel will be the oddest is they changed from the book and had Cho be the person who told Umbridge about the DA, and then used that for the reason Cho and Harry broke up. I know they have to cut the book to fit a movie in a two-three hour timeframe, but thats just sloppy and it could come back to bite the movies in the butt if Cho plays largely in Deathly Hallows after being made out to be a traitor in the movie. I wonder if she will also suffer the hex Hermionie used or if she will even be involved in Dumbledore's dismissal from Hogwarts.

Reply

The book actually is the worst book of the whole series so far - not only did the plot actually have holes in it and loose ends, but it rambled on for hundreds and hundreds of pages. Not surprised the movie plot is similar, but I was kind of hoping they'd clean it up for the screen.

Reply

i wouldn't say book 5 was terrible but i do agree it is the worst of the potter books. rowling herself admitted (forgot where) that there are some parts that can be edited out. *SPOILER* i definitely didn't like sirius dying and harry kissing cho. the girl's too emotional for him. i don't think the book being sluggish will have too much of an effect on the movie though. what i'm worried about is the marauders. they weren't really established in the third film and they have a flashback scene of them in OotP. non-readers may not get it.

Reply

I didn't find OOTP sluggish at all! It was very good, and though it was the thickest, I felt everything in there was essential to understanding Harry's depression at the end of the book. Everything falls into place at the end, and it is one of the finer books of the series to date. I don't feet OOTP could have been fit into another book at all! The plotline might not be as definite, but for the most part, the story is about Harry growing up. Had this book not been just the way it was, Harry would not be as understandable a character as he is today.

Reply

Good points about Order of the Phoenix; but I still feel that it was a bit rough... I feel like it was two books in one, and way too packed. Maybe it would have came out better if the pre-Hogwarts and the Hogwarts parts were better blended.

Reply

"As an elementary school teacher, I do find that this is the sluggish of all the books. This will probably effect the movie."

Tsk, tsk. I hope you're not an English teacher. :)

Reply