Review: 300 -- Scott's Review
Filed under: Action, Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Warner Brothers, Theatrical Reviews, New in Theaters, Comic/Superhero/Geek
.jpg)
If Gladiator and Sin City had a baby, it'd look a whole lot like Zack Snyder's 300. And that baby would be a 22-pound boy who shot out of the birth canal bearing several tattoos, snarling like a jackal and wielding a spiked club. Almost completely mindless but admirably stone-faced (with only an infrequent wink at the audience to remind us how crazy it all is), this is probably the closest thing we'll ever get to a feature-length action sequence -- and I for one think it's a big ball of testosterone-soaked entertainment. Based on the (very cool) graphic novel by Frank Miller, 300 offers a pretty simple story: Ancient Sparta is about to be invaded by a massive horde of bloodthirsty Persians. Typically muddled politics prevent Sparta's powerhouse army from getting involved, so it's up to King Leonidas and his band of 300 Spartans to keep the armies at bay while his queen does all she can to sway the politicians to her way of thinking. Period. That's all there is to 300, story-wise. It's not startlingly unique or anything, but it's enough of a story frame on which to hang two solid hours of high-end mayhem.
Visually arresting and wildly cut together, 300 is (despite its well-earned R-rating) precisely the kind of movie that turns 14-year-old boys into ravenous movie geeks. It's got more battles, brawls, monsters and maniacs than the entire Mad Max series and it approaches each new gimmick like it's the world's coolest new action figure. (Some of the most memorable characters in 300 don't utter a single word.) The action sequences are numerous, frequent, cleverly mounted and pretty damn creative. And since 47% of the movie is basically swords, shields, spears and skin-slices, it helps that Mr. Snyder has lots of nifty ideas on how to shoot his carnage. Truth be told, two hours of non-stop insanity would start to grow a little tiresome, and since much of 300's plot is linear at best (and entirely predictable at worst), it helps that we have a few strong actors in the mix. As Leonidas, Gerard Butler is a wild-eyed force of nature.
He growls and glowers and skewers and slices. If the actor had dialed it up one more notch, he'd be wading into the pool of self-parody. But because 300 has a sly (and impressively subtle) sense of humor about itself, we can go along with the severed-limb lunacy without taking it all that seriously. That's not to say that 300 is jokey, but it delivers some fairly outrageous images in a decidedly off-kilter fashion. (I can almost see Snyder chuckling to himself as he cut certain sequences together.) As far as the rest of the cast goes, Lena Headey stands out as a powerfully sexy Queen Gorgo, Vincent Regan makes for a very suitable sidekick, and Dominic West has some good fun with a particularly oily role. If you're talking volume and variety of eye candy, 300 is like Halloween Night meets Easter Sunday. In addition to the endless array of soldiers, killers, hunchbacks and blade-armed executioners (?), we're also treated to hundreds of "comic book panel"-style moments.
Characters actually stop to pose once in a while, just so we can appreciate the gooey, geeky artistry of it all. Sword battles are sped-up and slowed-down as the pulse of the battle rages on; billions of red-spot blood splatters dot the screen like so much crimson confetti; the whole movie seems awash in a gloomy, sepia-toned haze -- it's a mood that suits a strange and exciting experiment such as this one. It might be a fairly mindless affair (I'll leave the political subtext to those who choose to decipher it), but 300 is also proof positive that "mindless" movies don't necessarily have to be "bad" movies.
Basically, if you sat through stuff like Gladiator, Troy and Alexander and wished those movies were just a little more ... "fun," then I'm pretty sure you'll dig into 300 with both fists and come up grinning. It's a sundae buffet for the eyeballs, packing a fairly satisfying shot of adrenalin and moving quickly enough that the sillier moments quickly float away in favor of more sword-swingin' insanity. Plus it gives us a very viable new action star in Gerard Butler. The flick's got non-stop beefcake for the ladies, incessant and crazy carnage for the guys, and some really slick cinematography / special effects / music for all the movie geeks like me. Taken as elaborately bombastic escapism, 300 is simply a damn fun time.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
3-08-2007 @ 9:34AM
Jason said...
"The flick's got non-stop beefcake for the ladies, incessant and crazy carnage for the guys, and some really slick cinematography / special effects / music for all the movie geeks like me."
Well as a gorehound action-geek gay guy, I appear to have been the true core audience for this movie. And I CANNOT WAIT.
Reply
3-08-2007 @ 10:25AM
Steve said...
Seriously, Jason...
Seriously.
Reply
3-08-2007 @ 10:27AM
Flit said...
Already have my tickets :D
Reply
3-08-2007 @ 10:27AM
Steve said...
Word, Jason...
Word.
Reply
3-08-2007 @ 12:52PM
Gilbert Davis said...
Like Flit - I already have my tickets - IMAX tickets! Waiting for a movie like this is like being a kid and waiting for Christmas. The fun is in the anticipation and here's to hoping that it's half as good and as fun as some of us are hoping it is.
Reply
3-08-2007 @ 1:09PM
Ralph said...
Don't care about any reviews, positive or negative. I'm going to see it and I'm pretty sure I'm going to love it. I loved the graphic novel, I like Miller's style of storytelling, and enjoyed the visual style of SIN CITY and the tone of GLADIATOR.
Now, c'mon, stop screwing around and do Miller's version of THE DARK KNIGHT RETURNS already, damnit.
Reply
3-08-2007 @ 3:59PM
RatherNotSay said...
This is another subliminal brainwash movie to get us ready for another war. See what the real Greeks think about this historically inaccurate bigoted spin on their history:
http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2007/03/08/arts/EU-A-E-MOV-Greece-300.php
By ancient Persia, they refer to modern Iran whose soldiers are portrayed as bloodthirsty, underdeveloped zombies, he wrote. They are stroking racist instincts in Europe and America.
Please don't subsidize bigotry.
Reply
3-08-2007 @ 5:59PM
jack said...
Don't worry, Scott Weinberg seems to have a problem conceding that 300 might appeal to gay and bi men. He can't even bring himself to adequately admire the male physiques in it.
In any case, he's another in a long line of reviewers who fail to point out the homophobic omission in 300. It omits to tell you that the 300 were lovers of men in a very sexual sense.
Reply
3-08-2007 @ 10:03PM
The Kretan said...
Thanks for the review mate! Totally siked about this movie. I hope it makes you all wish you were Greek but hey, if we were all Greek than this world would just be to full of hot people. Leave the hotness to us few Greeks. I'm leaving now to get my ticket(s).
Reply
3-09-2007 @ 12:28PM
cyn said...
Oh God - I can barely wait - I'm an action-frantic, movie geek hetero woman - so I guess I'm the OTHER true core audience. I would pay just to watch that man pose with a big sword.
Reply
3-09-2007 @ 3:37AM
Nick James said...
I don't see how anyone could NOT like this movie. It has everything for everyone... well, at least everyone who enjoys action movies, methinks.
Fucking fantastic. I smell a special effects nomination next year...
Reply
3-09-2007 @ 12:45PM
Tricia Connor said...
"300" swept Thursday's midnight audience into Sparta and inspired us as Gerard Butler became OUR King Leonidas. As if in unison with the Spartans, the visceral experience of the audience was expressed in gasps, belly laughter, stunned silence, cheering, and applause (twice). "300" is a story about democracy, freedom, and what it takes to keep them.
The violence is offset by the beauty of the Spartans' physiques in motion. Unlike most modern films, this story shows the true purpose of male physical strength and the violence is provoked and necessary. Leonidas and his army exemplify the best of all any man can be - motivated by love of self, family, and country, dedicated to excellence, honor, and teamwork... for the purpose of protecting the women, the children, and the aged, so they may live in freedom.
As the Mom of an American soldier, I thought of the ancient Grecian women when my son left 7 years ago. I also did not say goodbye, --I said, your shield or you head. It means, come back in victory or die with honor. So, the "300" holds a deep and powerful meaning for many of us.
Gerard Butler deserves an Oscar because the energy he exuded through the screen and into the hearts and minds of the theater goers last night, is an awesome feat.
A must see movie!
Reply
3-09-2007 @ 1:10PM
Pimpkie said...
""300" is a story about democracy, freedom, and what it takes to keep them."
...that is truly one of the scariest things I've read in reaction to this movie.
Reply
3-09-2007 @ 2:03PM
Nathaniel said...
At least someone can write a decent review on this site. I saw this on Tuesday and I'm with you 100% Scott. Tell those other blowhards to keep their audience in mind when writing a review. Anyone who's going to pay for a ticket to this kind of movie has a certain expectation and this movie fulfills it, even if it does have some flaws.
Reply
3-10-2007 @ 8:05AM
jon said...
Although lacking the details of the actual battle and the impact the spartan navy played in their ultimate victory over persia, this movie INSPIRED me.
To learn more about the history, more so than my dandruff powered school teachers.
If a movie can motivate me to learn more than a scholastic proffesional...well right on. Sorry that "sleepless in seattle" didnt make me drive to the library to do research.
Catch the history channels special on this battle and you'll understand the importance this battle played in saving western civilization. As with music, I look to movies to be inspired. Something few media types fail to do lately.
Reply
3-10-2007 @ 4:59PM
boo said...
I know Pimpkie - I'm always hoping that a cup of tea and a bouquet of flowers should do it. Snort.
Reply
3-10-2007 @ 7:51PM
cedsnyder said...
Scott, Agree with your comments, although I have to admit that I'm almost 70 years old(not 14) and this film was one that could turn me into a ravenous movie "geek". An excellent & very "picturesque" depiction of a classic battle which helped shape our world....I go to movies for entertainment, not intellectual inuendos, and "300" certainly gave me my money's worth and more...Kudos to Mr. Snyder & the cast along with the special effects team...Ed
Reply
3-15-2007 @ 5:42PM
spanky said...
I went and saw 300 yesterday and all i can say is
AMAZING!
This movie is one of the best acient war movies ive seen.
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 7:58PM
Jackal said...
"Although lacking the details of the actual battle and the impact the spartan navy played in their ultimate victory over persia, this movie INSPIRED me." -Jon
Just wanna make a correction there Jon, it was not the Spartan navy that played a major role in the victory over Persia, it was the Athenian navy who dominated the seas at that time. I noticed that in the scene where they first acknowledged the immortals at the city of Athens, there was no tale about how they came to Athenian aid.
Of course this is all beside the point...everytime I talk to people about this movie they always seem to want to discuss its historical inaccuracy and I say time and time again that it was based on a graphic novel by Frank Miller who merely based his novel on the battle itself.
I loved this movie, had everything I could have ever wished. It was truly a movie that had my whole home-town theater in an uproar with claps, laughter, awe, shock, cheering, and disbelief...As for those of you that want to make it a politically motivated film...we hear enough politics in the news, don't invade our movie reviews..I wish you were here so I could laugh in your faces.
Overall excellent movie, I'm going to see it for a third time tonight!
-Jackal
Reply