Review: Knocked Up
Filed under: Comedy, New Releases, Universal, Theatrical Reviews

"Isn't it weird that when you have a kid all of your hopes and dreams go out the window?" -- Knocked Up
Once Monday morning rolls around, two things will be certain: 1) Everyone who did see Knocked Up over the weekend will find it to be the funniest film of the year so far, and 2) Judd Apatow will officially become the proud father of an instant classic. Both will happen fast -- almost instantaneously -- and you might not notice until the memorable quotes begin flying out the mouths of your fellow co-workers during that dreaded morning meeting. With no zany high concept, no major set pieces, no A-list stars and practically no physical comedy, you'd think Knocked Up would struggle to find even the mildest scattered laughter during its whopping (for a comedy) 129-minute running time. But thanks to Seth Rogan and the outstanding supporting cast, Judd Apatow picks up right where The 40 Year Old Virgin left off -- delivering a flawless situational comedy that feeds off a smorgasbord of delicious, relatable dialogue and enough heart to transform even the coldest, non-committal bachelor into the kind of guy who's just dying to start a family ... right after he gets back in line to watch the year's greatest comedy one more time.
Remember that group of stoners from school who always laughed off the corporate nine to five job and were convinced they'd discover the perfect get-rich-quick scheme providing them with enough money to sit on their asses and smoke pot for the rest of eternity? Well that's Ben (Rogan) and his best pals; all of whom are in their early twenties and sitting on top of, what they believe, is buried internet treasure -- a website that tracks nude scenes in movies and tells users exactly which point in the film said nudity shows up. Flesh of the stars.com. Ain't it grand? When they're not busy getting high or humiliating one another, the boys like to engage in some extra-curricular activities, such as sitting around at the bar -- staring at the beautiful women -- and doing nothing. That is, until Ben takes a chance and strikes up a conversation with Alison (Katherine Heigl); a pretty blonde out celebrating a job promotion with her self-conscious, do-you-think-I'm-still-sexy older sister Debbie (Leslie Mann). One drink leads to several, and before you know it Ben and Alison are waist-deep in a one-night-stand; an encounter that will change each of their lives forever.
Well, it's called Knocked Up for a reason, and not only does Alison (who just landed an on-air gig with E! Entertainment) regret kissing this chubby slacker with a Jew-fro, but now she has to decide whether or not to keep his baby. She's cute, he's not. She's successful, he doesn't have a dime to his name. She has everything to lose, and he has a really sweet glass bong. Together, they're a match made in heaven. What first started out as a throwaway fling with a drunken stranger now has to become something more, and when Alison chooses not to have a smushmortion (trust me, you'll get it), these opposites begin to look for a way to attract. Apatow had been prepping Rogan for this role his entire career; from Freaks and Geeks all the way through 40 Year Old Virgin, the pair were collaborating, pushing the boundaries, and trying to convince the masses that their brand of humor was worth every penny. The dialogue is refreshingly real; these same obscure pop-culture references are found in every dorm room, every living room and every bar across the country. Ben isn't just a character; he's the guy you know, knew or remember hearing about. If this isn't your life, it's pretty damn close to the one you almost lived.
And that's why we care. Apatow is very keen on dragging the reality out of every scene; every situation. The names of his main male actors (Jason Segal, Jay Baruchel, Martin Starr and Jonah Hill) are the same as their characters (Jason, Jay, Martin and Jonah), and it's clear that a majority of the banter between them is improv; off the grid (or script, if you will). But if you can't relate to a bunch of twenty-somethings bumbling their way through life's happy accidents, then perhaps you'll sympathize with Debbie, the housewife whose white-picket-fence of a family is falling apart because Peter (Paul Rudd), her husband, is hiding a double life that may or may not spell the end of his marriage. Debbie and Peter are what Ben and Alison could be 10 years from now; throughout the film, they'll learn from one another and subsequently teach us how important it is to communicate, to trust and to always give the one you love another chance; be it boyfriend, girlfriend, wife, husband, friend or family. And it's not like no one has ever done this on screen before, it's just that Apatow has a way of injecting this sort of hilarious comfort into everything he does -- his entire life (and the lives of everyone he knows) spill out of his brain like foul-mouthed obscenities in the operating room during a natural birth.
But those are just the main characters; we haven't even gone near the bit players -- those folks sprinkled throughout whose small roles combine to add the cherry on top of this sensational meal. Harold Ramis, Charlyne Yi, Kristen Wiig and, yes, Ryan Seacrest show up with more than a few laughs up their sleeves. Wiig, especially, is very amusing as the bland E! assistant with a not-so-subtle jealous streak. If there's a flaw in the film, audiences will find it in its length. Apatow is convinced that, with the right comedy, people won't mind dancing a bit close to the check-your-watch time. It just about works in Knocked Up (for those who, unlike me, don't need to go the bathroom real bad at the 100-minute mark) and with a finale that includes a memorable, Farelly-esque (the zipper got caught) sight gag, the film's running time will be the last thing on your mind as the credits begin to roll. The perfect comedy blends humor and heart in a way that leaves you feeling better about tomorrow, and Knocked Up does that without trying to imitate the box office baddies that have come before it. We often feel like our hopes and dreams are over once a child enters the equation, but it's movies like this that help remind us it's only the beginning.









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
6-01-2007 @ 10:20AM
matty said...
Great review; I feel it should be mentioned that this premise is a direct rip-off from a book of the same name; written by Rebecca Eckler. The book was released and distributed in the USA 5 months before Judd pitched the idea to Universal. There was an article in Maclean's (http://www.macleans.ca/) magazine this week. Can't find it online though. Worth a read to see how little Universal and Apatow care about plagiarism.
-matt
link to the book:
http://www.amazon.ca/Knocked-Up-Confessions-Mother-Be/dp/0385660375/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/702-6358835-7259229?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1180707320&sr=8-1
Reply
6-01-2007 @ 10:56AM
Erik Davis said...
Not for nothing, but we're not talking some high concept premise here. The term 'Knocked Up' has been around longer than I have, and this situation has played itself out in a number of films and TV shows in the past. And the film (unlike the book) is about more than just the pregnancy -- it's also told from more than one perspective, and the main two characters are strangers; they're not already engaged.
I think plagiarism is way too strong of a word here; I'd call it a coincidence. I mean, it's not like both were called "Holy crap, I slept with a loser and now I'm pregnant." If that were the case, I'd say you have a point. Knocked Up wasn't a term Rebecca created, and this won't be the last time it's used in either a film, a book or on TV.
Reply
6-01-2007 @ 11:06AM
hermanae said...
I don't have access to the McClean's article, but according to the description of the book about the only things it and the movie have in common are the title and the comedy of pregnancy, which I doubt was just introduced in this book. The movie is about a one-night stand and the book is about a woman and her fiancee getting pregnant after they were already engaged. Again, not having seen the movie (yet) and just from the description of the book they don't even seem thematically similar. I'm curious to see where you think the plagiarism comes in.
Reply
6-01-2007 @ 11:07AM
sourbob said...
I feel it should be mentioned that this premise is a direct rip-off from a book of the same name; written by Rebecca Eckler.
Wait a minute: someone else wrote about an unplanned pregnancy!?!?! Next you'll tell me Apatow didn't invent the one-night stand.
I find it extraordinarily unlikely that Apatow ripped that book (or anyone else) off. Rather, he, like the author of this book, took a basic premise that has been done thousands times before and populated it with the types of people who would provide the most comedic interest when placed in this situation.
As Roger Ebert says, "A movie isn't about what it's about, it's about how it's about it."
And I honestly doubt--broad similarities in plot or stock characters aside--Apatow's story of a stoner stumbling into adulthood is going to end up much like Rebecca Eckler's "pregnancy journal" of a woman and her fiance... even if they did stumble onto the same title.
Reply
6-01-2007 @ 12:27PM
bgdc said...
Wow, people draw some tenuous connections. Right after 40 Year Old Virgin hit screens you can find quotes from Rogen and Apatow discussing this concept. It's not new or different - wasn't 9 Months the same basic concept too? The difference lies in apatow's humor and characters...
Reply
6-01-2007 @ 2:53PM
matty said...
It's more than the title that the two share; specific instances in the book happen in the film. The US cover for the book is a martini glass with a soother around it...the title-page of the script had the same image (altered somewhat). I'm not saying this is a unique idea, it's been done before and it'll be done again. It somewhat shocks me that people immediately side with the studio here, I am just citing what I read. Watch the movie, then read that book and draw your own conclusions. I'd do the same if I really cared much. If Universal / Apatow did rip her off; pay her what a going rate for 'story by' credits fetch. In any case, I'm sure the movie is much funnier, and would be far-more entertained by Apatow and his cast than any book.
Reply
6-01-2007 @ 4:03PM
Matt said...
It seems like I'll have the same issues with this film that I had with 40 year old virgin. Improv is funny live or on tv, when you make a film the dialog flows better if a majority of it is scripted. Just my opinion, but it was the reason I could only watch 40YOV once.
Reply
6-01-2007 @ 7:02PM
Paige said...
I've read Knocked Up by Eckler and seen the movie (press screening a few months ago).. and while I am a fan of both, I can say similarities between the two end in the title and concept of an unplanned pregnancy.
If the book was capable of becoming a feature length film, it would have been optioned back when it came out in 2004. A "lawsuit" right now seems like nothing more than a good press move, both for the film and Eckler's sequel Wiped!, no?
Reply
6-01-2007 @ 11:08PM
Kimberley said...
That is such crap, Matt -- or should I say, Rebecca?
A. Knocked Up had actually wrapped up production long before Eckler's book came out. Are you suggesting he was merely pitching the idea when Knocked Up came out in April? The movie had already been written, cast, and shot. Apatow wouldn't have ever heard of Eckler or any of her crap work, and even if he had, there are lot better writers to steal from.
B. There is nothing remotely similar about the plot except that the female protagonist gets knocked up while drunk. End of story.
She really is a nutbar.
Reply
6-02-2007 @ 5:39AM
Kimberley said...
I stand corrected -- I was thinking of Wiped, not Knocked Up, which came out a couple of years ago. But no matter ... there is absolutely no similarities other than a woman gets accidentally pregnant.
The trailer:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=IQlgjB1hXd8
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 9:21PM
andrea said...
How would you feel if this happened to you. It's too much of a coincidence. I'd be devasted if I were her.
Here's the link to the story:
http://www.macleans.ca/article.jsp?content=20070611_106143_106143
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 9:44PM
Laura said...
I read the article, I feel bad for her. Meanwhile I read another article on the same site she wrote about Lindsay Lohan's tutor that wrote a book also? StarSitter...they should make that into a movie too...maybe without stealing the idea :)
Reply
6-06-2007 @ 10:27AM
Goon said...
of course if you read HER side of the story you might feel sorry for her or believe her. but if you actually LEARN ANYTHING about her book vs. what Knocked Up the movie is actually about, you'd see the comparisons end at the basic premise. there is no comparing the two, Rogen is Jewish and Canadian and his characters are always Jewish and Canadian (Undeclared, 40 Year Old Virgin). She's full of crap, and I've been reading her other writing lately, and she's one self obsessed freak.
Reply
6-07-2007 @ 12:18PM
Emily said...
Talk about a spurious claim. In articles I've read, Eckler has implied she owns the copyright to everything from unplanned pregnancy to the term "knocked up" to Jews in Canada. Is she unaware that Seth Rogen is Jewish Canadian and the movie was written around and for him? It's like she set out to make herself a laughingstock. Except it's not funny when someone tries to take credit for another writer's successful (and in this case half improvisational) work.
Reply
8-29-2007 @ 5:47PM
Peter said...
Same name OR same cover picture OR same basic idea - these could be a coincidence.
But simple math and common sense tell me that ALL TOGETHER it's not.
It's not a theft too - just couple of little peeks into the book while writing a script.
Reply