TIFF Review: Diary of the Dead
Filed under: Horror, Independent, Theatrical Reviews, Toronto International Film Festival, Cinematical Indie

Fear not, Romero junkies. The old guy still has it. Apparently more than energetic enough at an impressive 67 years of age, the creator of the zombie genre has popped back up with a new indie flick that's sure to entertain anyone who's followed the guy's career for the past 30-some years ... like me. After teaming up with a big studio to deliver the adequate-if-unspectacular Land of the Dead, George A. Romero returns to his grass-roots indie-style origins and comes up with Diary of the Dead -- which is easily his most entertaining horror film since 1985's Day of the Dead.
Just to be clear: Diary is not another chapter in the series that began with Night of the Living Dead and continued on with Dawn, Day and Land of the Dead. Instead it's a stand-alone and entirely fresh take on the inevitably impending zombie apocalypse, as seen through the eyes (and the camera lenses) of a bunch of film students who head off into the woods to make a horror flick ... and end up making the nastiest horror documentary ever imagined. So yeah, it's a zombie flick crossed with the visual approach of The Blair Witch Project. But it's also quite a bit more than that.
Ever since Night of the Living Dead hit the scene in 1968, film critics and horror lovers alike have been applauding George Romero for mixing grimly amusing gore, insightful social satire, and all sorts of juicy subtextual nuggets amidst all the high-end ultra-carnage. And that trend continues unabated in Diary of the Dead. This time around Mr. Romero seems most interested in the media, and the ways in which it shapes our reactions to life's unexpected tragedies. Icing on top: By using the 'fake movie within a movie' conceit, the zombie lord gives himself ample opportunity to poke fun at the "reality" of documentary filmmaking. And poke he does!
The veteran craftsman also seems entirely fascinated by the ways in which information is instantly disseminated over the internet, so there's plenty of geek-friendly cleverness to be found here. To those who simply want a good old-fashioned chomp-fest, rest assured that there's gore galore -- plus a very healthy dose of in-joke horror references that nerds like me always enjoy. And no, the funny stuff does not overwhelm the splat-tastic mayhem. As is often the case, the humor offsets the scary / gross moments and all the components congeal into a full-course genre treat.
The cast is a no-name (yet impressively competent) roster of newcomers ... even if most of the characters are 75% standard horror fodder. Leading lady Michelle Morgan makes a very strong impression, as do Shawn Roberts as a jerk who slowly turns heroic and Scott Wentworth as a boozy-yet-volatile film professor. Plus I can't locate the actor's name, but whoever plays "Samuel the Old Amish Guy" is destined to become a cult icon once Diary of the Dead hits the screens. Romero employs a lot of humor here (both broad and subtle stuff), but that Amish guy brought the house down at the screening I attended.
And very best of all -- after 40 years and five zombie fests -- George Romero still knows how to come up with some really creative ways to "re-kill" his undead cannibals. Obviously I'm not going to spoil any surprises, but if you were worried that Romero was getting complacent or 'soft' in his later years, well, you'll just have to check out Diary of the Dead before you make that call. Frankly I'm just thrilled to see the King of the Zombies chime back in (and on his own terms) with at least one more tale of the ravenous undead -- in gritty, low-budget fashion and stuffed with clever ideas. And when Romero decides to do another one (Blog of the Dead?), you know I'll be first in line.









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-10-2007 @ 1:47PM
dylanblair said...
Awesome news. I was a little iffy when I first heard about this movie but after that review, I can't wait to see it.
Reply
9-10-2007 @ 2:20PM
Pierre said...
I really can't wait to see how this is pulled off. Ever since Blair Witch I can't help but think every idea concerning this POV handycam style has been explored. How can this be any different or unique?
Reply
9-10-2007 @ 2:33PM
Tim P. said...
Oh how I wish this were half as good as Romero's earlier work or even Blair Witch. I was extremely disappointed.
Reply
9-10-2007 @ 7:05PM
Adam said...
I cant wait to see this! Especially since my boss plays a small role in it (his name is Brody or something... at least according to IMDB). I presume he gets killed/eaten/filleted. How exciting is that!?
I cant wait!
Reply
9-10-2007 @ 9:39PM
Evan said...
According to Romero's imdb page, he was born in 1940, making him 67, not 77.
In my grade school if we ever found a mistake in a book we got a piece of candy. How 'bout it Scott?
Reply
9-10-2007 @ 9:41PM
Scott Weinberg said...
Ack, now that's an embarrassing error on my part. Thanks for the correction. And here's your reward:
http://tinyurl.com/ee8qa
Reply
9-11-2007 @ 1:20AM
Evan said...
Should have said "Back in grade school...". Made it sound like I still am in grade school, but far from it. Anyway, thank you for the reeses.
Reply
10-17-2007 @ 4:46PM
Steve Biodrowski said...
DAIRY OF THE DEAD really has little to do with BLAIR WITCH. DIARY is not about being lost in the woods with nothing but a film camera; it's about the instant dissemination of information by amateurs who can use digital technology and the Internet to tell a story that the mainstream media refuses to tell. Also, there's even some editing and music in DIARY, as what we're seeing is not supposed to be raw, found footage but a completed work.
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 7:17AM
Frank said...
I've seen the film, it's great. It truely shows George's work as a director, Samuel is indeed a true icon of the film.
I'd also like to mention, I've met George and he is a really nice guy.
Can't wait until it's out on DVD.
Reply