Cinematical Seven: Non-Horror Movies that Scared the Crap Out of Me As a Kid
Filed under: Horror, Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Family Films, Home Entertainment, Cinematical Seven, Lists

As I pointed out in my Poltergeist review, I didn't watch much horror as a boy. That's probably a good thing, as even the non-horror flicks I enjoyed often scared the bejesus out of me. You kids today don't know how lucky you have it with your wussy Shreks and your lamewad Pikachus! Children of the 1980s are still in therapy over what Hollywood deemed "family films" back then. The following non-horror mind-screws should prove my point.
Return to Oz (1985)
In high school, I brought Return to Oz to a Halloween movie marathon. I hadn't seen it since I was a kid. Everyone scoffed. "A Wizard of Oz sequel? That's supposed to scare us?" I didn't hear a lot of mockery after the movie started. In fact, nobody said a word until about halfway through, when a friend of mine whispered "Can we please turn this off?" I'm not sure who thought this movie was appropriate for children. It gave me nightmares for nearly a decade.
Dorothy finds a key with an Oz symbol on it, shows it to Auntie Em and Uncle Henry as proof that Oz exists, and is sent to an insane asylum! An evil insane asylum where they give our young heroine electro-shock therapy! That's how this "childrens' film" starts! Once Dorothy gets to Oz, it's a speeding night train of horrors. How about that Nome King? Good LORD! Winged monkeys aren't scary enough anymore, let's give the kids The Wheelers -- sadistic shrieking psychopaths with roller skates instead of hands and feet! Kids today won't be satisfied with just a standard wicked witch, let's really ramp that up too, and ruin their lives! The sequence with the witch's cabinets full of human heads easily rivals anything in the Nightmare on Elm Street series for sheer terror. "Dorothy Gaaaaaale!!!!"
Even the heroes are horrifying! Jack Pumpkinhead? A hybrid stick n' pumpkin creature who calls Dorothy "Mother"? That's your good guy? Not cool, Return to Oz. Not cool.
The Neverending Story (1984)
Along the same lines as Return to Oz, The Neverending Story feels way too dark, weird, and just...wrong to be a kids' movie. I feel my eyes welling up now remembering Atreyu's horse slowly sinking into quicksand and dying. I can't even talk about the Gmork, that big wolfy vampire thing. And a storm called "The Nothing?" Sweet fancy Moses! Also, again, the heroes should not be scarier than the villains! The racing snail? The Rockbiter? That bat-dude? And Falkor? A big flying dog/dragon mutation with disgusting scaly eggs on his skin? We were supposed to root for this hellacious beast?
Another scream-inducing aspect -- one of the worst theme songs in all of 80's film. And that's saying a whole lot!
Pee-Wee's Big Adventure (1985)As I mentioned the other day, Poltergeist and Stephen King's It gave me a massive fear of clowns. Also contributing to that fear -- Tim Burton's Pee-Wee's Big Adventure, still one of my favorite comedies of all time. When Pee-Wee (Paul Reubens) imagines a worst-case scenario for what has happened to his missing bicycle, we're shown several demonic clowns in hospital smocks performing surgery on his bike. Bone-chilling.
And don't get me started on Large Marge and her morphing face, which now seems charming and quaint, but at the time was no laughing matter.
Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory (1971)
Hey, this is fun! These kids get to enjoy all this delicious candy and have adventures! And this Willy Wonka seems like a heck of a nice guy! Yessir! Just a heck of a nice guy! Oh. Oh, he's steering them into that tunnel. Hm. OK, it's pretty dark in there. Um...what in God's name are these nightmarish images flashing on the walls? Was that a bug eating a-- What's happening? Willy, why are you singing like a man possessed?
There's no earthly way of knowing which direction we are going. There's no knowing where we're rowing, or which way the river's flowing. Is it raining, is it snowing, is a hurricane-a-blowin? Not a speck of light is showing, so the danger must be growing. Are the fires of Hell a-glowing? Is the grisly reaper mowing? Yes, the danger must be growing! For the rowers keep on rowing! And they're certainly not showing! Any signs that they are slowing!
Stop the damn boat! I want to get off!
Labyrinth (1986)
Watching it now, the only thing that truly disturbs me about this movie is the juxtaposition of adorable Muppets and David Bowie's enormous package squeezed into tights. But back then, Bowie genuinely scared the crap out of me (and I'm sure had a legion of youngsters questioning their sexuality at far too young an age). Goblins stealing a baby, talking hands and worms, the utterly terrifying trash lady, I could go on, but I'm getting uncomfortable. See also: The Dark Crystal.
The Garbage Pail Kids Movie (1987)
I am not prepared to deal with my memories of this film. But just do an image search for stills from the movie and you'll understand why I have Vietnamesque flashbacks about the Garbage Pail Kids to this day.
The Peanut Butter Solution (1985)
I don't expect you to know what this movie is. No one does. I get nothing but blank stares when I bring it up. In fact, until doing an internet search just now, I was convinced that the film was some horrible dream of my youth. And all of the people online who remember the film speak of it in the same way -- as though they survived some horrible, scarring experience they're not even sure actually happened.
A boy gets scared and loses all of his hair. He mixes peanut butter with flies and other gross items to make "the peanut butter solution," which grows hair back. There are children in cages. There is a man harvesting childrens' hair for paint brushes. There are ghosts. There are paintings that come to life. I think. There is a scene involving pubic hair. That is all I can remember, or care to remember. But this is one so disturbing I couldn't even walk past it in the video store without shaking. Does anyone out there know this film? Please help me.
Please, please help me.









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
10-13-2007 @ 12:14AM
Sugarmag9 said...
I am right there with you on 'The Peanut Butter Solution'. Everyone thought I was nuts when I described the scene where the art teacher who kidnapped the school's children could walk into the paintings with the 'magic' hair.
People thought I was describing some weird acid flashback. I bought the movie on VHS through Ebay and proceeded to scar all of my friends who doubted this movie existed.
I would add to the list the 'Hugga Bunch' movie where the stuffed animals came to life and could walk through mirrors (that movie haunted me for years). And of course, 'The Lady in White' with Lucas Haas and Mona from 'Who's the Boss'. I think my parents should have banned me from watching the Disney channel in the 80's.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 1:00AM
James Hudnall said...
I love Return to Oz, but I was in my 20s when it came out. It definitely isn't a kid's film unless you're a kid into scary stuff.
The problem with the movie is it is too dour and, of course, people were expecting songs and there were none. But Nicol Williamson as the Gnome King/Doctor is awesome.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 1:29AM
Philpott said...
The Grandparent characters in 'Cloak & Dagger' scared the bejesus out of me and made me afraid of people that were my grandparents age or close to it.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 1:44AM
Ellory said...
I agree with Labyrinth The Neverending Story and Return to Oz... also the Dark Crystal honorable mention. I must say though that one I can really remember getting freaked out by aside from these is 'The Witches' starring Angelica Huston as the Grand High Witch... That movie caused me massive nightmares as a child. A beautiful woman turning into that ugly thing with that nose, turning a kid into a mouse with chocolates, and then the soup scene where the green gas is escaping from the witches mouths. Then Rowan Atkinson with his cleaver chopping up the rats. Man I still get freaked out thinking about that.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 1:52AM
John said...
Oh Cm' On! The winner is Pinocchio. When Monstro the Whale attacks and the ocean turns into a maelstrom of fury, that's just terrifying. It has left me afraid of deep water since.
Incredibly, that's not even the worse part for some people. You got the kidnapping by that nasty puppeteer, Stromboli, that threatens to burn Pinocchio, and the horrible transformation of kids into donkeys. That's just not cool in a so-called "kids movie".
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 2:09AM
Philpott said...
John -
I'm with you on the whole kids into donkeys thing in Pinocchio - WTF? So horrifying!
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 2:22AM
Strike Man said...
HO-LY-CRAP.
"The Peanut Butter Solution"
I have done some random web searches for this strange movie (without knowing the title, of course) I had seen as a very young kid, and I was fairly convinced that, either it was some strange TV movie or I was just imagining things.
Now I'm almost scared to track down a copy and watch it again, some 20 years later.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 4:13AM
natedog said...
totally agree about pinocchio, but i was completely scarred after seeing time bandits. i was totally afraid that my microwave was going to explode and blow up my house.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 4:18AM
freemorpheme said...
I'm sorry, did none of you get taken to the 'family friendly' Black Cauldron in the mid eighties? The dead rise, man... rise right out of their frickin' graves...
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 8:30AM
Luke G. said...
This may be the best Cinematical Seven ever.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 10:21AM
keeks said...
The Peanut Butter Solution. I thought I dreamt that up. Glad to know it's real, not glad to know someone actually thought that would be a great children's movie and then other people agreed to make it.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 10:54AM
Adi B said...
The Black Hole? Anyone? Anyone?
Oh and Chitty Chitty Bang Bang was no vacation either.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 12:00PM
liya said...
Honey, I Shrunk the Kids: a tiny kid is holding on to a Cheerio for dear life as he screams at his dad not to eat him.
ditto The Dark Crystal and Labyrinth. And the boat ride in Willy Wonka--a chicken gets its head cut off!--though that didn't stop me from watching it a million times.
But the one that did the most damage was Charlotte's Web (the cartoon one). I remember Fern holding little Wilbur in front of her dad--who may have been holding an ax--and saying, "If I were small and helpless, would you do away with me too?"
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 12:01PM
Bracken said...
Quit complaining...these kids movies made us stronger...we survived...I am worred about the kids today, their kids movies are so weak that they all have to go watch the SAW series and like. THAT is just wrong...Hollywood better start making scary kids movies again or we are all doomed.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 12:25PM
ashley said...
hey I'm not that old so the movies that freaked me out are kinda recent.
Umm I don't know if Jurrasic Park was supposed to be a kids movie or a family film but all my friends had seen it. But that thing freaked me out for years. The Wizard of Oz gave me bad dreams about storms.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 12:26PM
Steve Vesolich said...
My friends and I had a movie marathon of films that scared us as children. The three movies were Return to Oz, Pee-Wee's Big Adventure, and the Never Ending Story. Great picks.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 12:27PM
Philpott said...
Flight of The Navigator. The thought of waking up one day and your family wonders where you've been for 20 years was just too much.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 1:29PM
JSizzle said...
For me, it always was and always will be Ferngully. Something about that menacing ooze.... It's like Al Gore's worst nightmare come to life.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 1:36PM
Wayne said...
Awesome list; I agree with Luke G. This is probably the best Cinematical Seven ever.
I've seen six of the seven movies. I never saw "The Garbage Pail Kids" movie. "The Neverending Story" is the only one of the six that didn't scare me. I don't know why. It probably should have. I guess it managed to keep me excited without stepping over the line.
"The Peanut Butter Solution" and "Return to Oz" have stuck with me for years, particularly the latter. I never forgot the title of the former, though, and knew it was weird and freaky for a kids movie. The friend who uses it to grow pubes that won't quit is just messed up.
"Return to Oz" is a movie that I waited roughly 20 years to watch again. I was 10 or younger when I saw it the first time as a rental sleeping over my Aunt and Uncle's house with my younger brother and sister. I rented it very recently and it still freaked me out. The asylum, the Wheelers, Jack, Tick-Tock, the Gnome King, the headless Witch, the desert that turns people into sand - it's a great dark and spooky movie if you're prepared for it.
Reply
10-13-2007 @ 2:17PM
Aronious said...
Yeah I loved just about every movie on the list. I think that the dark aspects were what intrigued me the most (and thus influenced me) and I think i am a better person for having seen them, even if they were very very disturbing to see as a child. However i also saw An American Wherewolf in London when i was 7 and loved it ....still get the shivers when i hear that Credence track.....
Reply