Cinematical Seven: Tasty Celebrity Turkeys
Filed under: Casting, Celebrities and Controversy, Box Office, Cinematical Seven, Lists

While they might be all sorts of succulent and tasty, poultry gets the crappy end of the slang stick. The chicken is the coward, and instead of a platter signifying all things delectable, turkeys are considered the foolish and often useless. To top that off -- when turkeys hit the celebrity realm, well, they're usually also box office bombs. In honor of our never-ending love of celebrity gossip, train-wrecks, and disaster stories, I present you with seven tasty turkeys in honor of our upcoming turkey day. Many are just a gross waste of potential, and some, I'm sure you'll agree, don't even have half the potential that studios give them credit for. Whatever the reason, they're all riding the stinker train.
Gobble, gobble!
Paris Hilton
She's mocked by many, loved by few, but Paris Hilton seems to be able to outlast even the little train that could. Prison didn't stop her, and neither do crappy movies. Working backwards: Pledge This! was so very bad that it's pretty much off the radar; the same goes for Bottoms Up; House of Wax did alright, but doesn't hold the moviegoer love; and, which Hillz? Yet somehow, somewhere, she got cast in Repo! The Genetic Opera!, which let her loose on the streets of Toronto to gripe over sex tape woes. We keep waiting for her to fall, or go away, but I'm starting to think that this super-skinny turkey is here to stay. She's like one of those inflatable boxing stand-ups that somehow swings its way upright each and every time.
Jamie Kennedy
There was a time when Jamie Kennedy made my mouth break out into a huge smile and my hands clap with glee. In 1996 he was the best scary movie geek to ever hit the big screen -- Randy Meeks in Scream. He had the humor, the delivery, and the sexy geek charm. For a while after that, he moved along decently, racking up a resume that includes As Good as It Gets and Three Kings. Well, he must've gone crazy after that. These days, what have we gotten? Malibu's Most Wanted. Son of the Mask. Kickin' It Old School. Do I even need to mention box office numbers? The movies went from dumb money-makers into dumb money-losers. The last remnants of Randy seem to be gone, and now he's mainlining crappy movies with the passion of a heroin addict. It's a damned shame.
Jessica Simpson
Ah, the wonderful contradiction that is Jessica Simpson. She presents herself as an utter bimbo, but her mom says she has an IQ of 160! (Maybe she didn't realize that IQ meme's don't count.) So really, she's not so much a contradiction as she doesn't seem interested in exemplifying her so-called smarts. Nevertheless, she's been trucking her way through an acting career. The torture device that was Dukes of Hazzard started things off, which I think everyone went to see out of nostalgia (and who then mourned the death of said nostalgia). Then Employee of the Month came along, which did alright but still. Alas, there's been nothing for us to see since. Her Blonde Ambition flopped before it got a chance, like Jim Levenstein's penis in American Pie. And then there's Major Movie Star, which needs the title because, let's face it -- Jessica Simpson will never be one.
Jude Law
I don't necessarily like including Jude Law in this list, but how can I not? I can't count the number of times I have heard people complain about Law and his movie choices lately. He's just not raking in the money, or even breaking even in many cases. Sleuth hasn't even hit a million dollar worldwide gross; if it wasn't for the worldwide box office, The Holiday would've fallen way short of its budget; All the King's Men pulled in a domestic gross under $8 million, when its production budget was $55 million... And so on, and so forth. The man has had some great roles, and I'll be ever-grateful for his stint in I Heart Huckabees, but it's amazing just how many stinkers this man is getting involved in, and how it has yet to affect his career. Hopefully My Blueberry Nights or Repossession Mambo help, because the dude is plummeting -- fast.
M. Night Shyamalan
After throwing out two movies that many people don't even know existed, M. Night Shyamalan hit it beyond 15 ballparks with The Sixth Sense. That sucker was gold. But since then, it's just been slowly fading away. I must admit: I liked both Signs and The Village, although many people have knocked them (especially the latter). While nothing compared to seeing dead people, his films were only suffering a gentle decline -- until that slow drop-off hit a cliff. Instead of making tons of money like his previous blockbusters, Lady in the Water barely made its money back, and became the big proof of Shyamalan's directorial demise. Can he make it come back with The Happening? Will it even matter if it's good? How many people still have faith in the guy? I'd like to see the man do well, but eesh, he's got to come up with some new material -- stat!
Lindsay Lohan
LiLo, oh, LiLo. We're still waiting to see if she keeps her place on the Thanksgiving platter post-rehab, but until she proves otherwise, she's probably one of the biggest wastes to hit the air in a long time. It's not just bad choices, but a lifestyle that spiraled out of control, ripping her from her red roots and throwing her into a garish, bleached, drug-addled lifestyle of trauma, drama, and driving trouble. It's hard to believe that she's only been in 11 movies so far. After getting high marks for Mean Girls, she plummeted. Herbie got her money but hurt her cred, A Prairie Home Companion was to be her big switch, but that didn't happen. Unfortunately, none of her recent movies have budgets up on Box Office Mojo, but there wasn't much mojo to be had with Just My Luck, Georgia Rule, or I Know Who Killed Me.
Zach Braff
While the women of the list have been pretty easy to throw up, it's been hard to pick a few of these guys. All of them have the potential, but something just isn't clicking -- and Zach Braff is no exception. After popping up in The Baby-Sitters Club way back in 1993, Braff worked himself up to a starring role in Scrubs, the excellent voice of Paul Revere on Clone High, and the fun and lovable indie romance, Garden State. It looked like he was heading for all sorts of wonder. But Scrubs has been waffling for a while now, and beyond Chicken Little, what does Braff have? The Last Kiss couldn't even make its $20 million budget back. Then came The Ex, which couldn't even bring in $5 mill -- that's right, it only brought in $4,168,762 worldwide! The guy hasn't even been in enough good films to balance the crap, so unless things turn around with Open Hearts, he might find himself trying to cry into a paper cup once again.
For more turkey-related coolness, check out Moviefone's list of the 25 Biggest Box-Office Bombs Ever.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-14-2007 @ 9:21PM
Gina said...
Nooo, not M. Night! I still have faith in him!
Reply
11-14-2007 @ 10:04PM
Paul said...
Amen Gina
I think Lady In the Water ranks among his best work. And no, I'm not kidding.
Reply
11-14-2007 @ 10:19PM
MCW said...
Lady in the Water was such a mind explosion, I have no idea what was going on.
I want M. Night to succeed as much as anyone, but you cannot make a movie like that and expect big box office results. Still, I will see all of his movies, no matter what, because he has something different.
I agree with the Turkeys though, the sad one for me is Jamie Kennedy. "Kickin' it old school" was kind of funny, but it just didn't hit on much for me. He's trying too hard to pick bad movies.
Jessica Simpson was actually really good in the otherwise mediocre "Employee of the Month". I still hold out hope for her, but I don't know if she should go back to singing or what anymore.
Braff. I just don't know. Maybe you're right, I haven't watched many of his movies, I'm trying to support Scrubs in its final days :(
Reply
11-15-2007 @ 9:21AM
Cincinnati Mike said...
Seems like you're talking about two different animals here: ones we never should have bothered with, and ones that showed promise but ultimately disappointed. Let me suggest for the second category Wesley Snipes. Early 90's, he was the MAN! Now he's a direct-to-video pothead who pouts in his trailer and doesn't pay his taxes (ALLEGEDLY!)
Reply
11-15-2007 @ 2:47PM
Sam said...
yeah well.. M.Night has had a share of setbacks
From his breakout Sixth Sense to The Village, things were looking ok
(alright, The Village is debatable, but I thought it was good)
He needs another breakout hit, which he will probably get, but how many bombs is it going to take?
Lohan- she's a total mess. Yeah, your right, Mean Girls was a damn good teen comedy and she has pretty much left the building after that one. I think the problem is her damaging personal lifestyle. You could say that its the product of her family being a total screwup and also too much fame coming too fast. Who knows where Lohan goes next, but there's a large portion of America that wants to see her sans clothes.
Braff- He needs another Garden State. 'nuff said.
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 5:17AM
gike said...
yessss !!!! LADY IN THE WATER is indeed a GREAT movie... the fading succes of M. NIGHT could be just because people always expect a new Sixth Sense kinda movie, but I still think he is just a Big Director making Big Films - it's a pity he's included in this list...
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 4:59PM
sheryl said...
M. Night is alright...I haven't seen Lady in the Water yet, but I did not like The Village. I really like Signs and Sixth Sense, though.
Kate Winslet was in ATKM and The Holiday with Jude Law...turkey? Oh, and I agree with you about Huckabees...love that movie!
I also agree with one of the posters who said there are two different categories on this list...some of them belonging to the "should have never been" category...you all can pick who belongs.
Reply
11-18-2007 @ 12:15AM
uforeader said...
Seeing all the above Night love is great. Including Shyamalan on this list is ridiculous. The man is a master behind the camera, and can PERFECTLY construct a story. I know a lot of people didn't like Lady in the Water - and it's my least favorite of his films - but each movie has that Shyamalan feel, and always delivers something unexpected and unique.
I, for one, cannot wait for The Happening.
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 11:54PM
uforeader said...
Seeing all the above Night love is great. Including Shyamalan on this list is ridiculous. The man is a master behind the camera, and can PERFECTLY construct a story. I know a lot of people didn't like Lady in the Water - and it's my least favorite of his films - but each movie has that Shyamalan feel, and always delivers something unexpected and unique.
I, for one, cannot wait for The Happening.
Reply
11-18-2007 @ 9:49PM
Jiselle said...
I must admit I did like Lohan when she was younger and less of a crack whore.. what a waste. As for Hilton.. she was always a sket and Simpson was always an empty-headed bimbo. I can't believe people continue to be entertained by these pathetic excuses for actors/singers/whatever. It's a bit disgusting.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 5:07AM
Linual Harless said...
You think M. Knight is okay? And you also think "Lady In The Water" wasn't an absolute waste of film? What's wrong with you???
Reply
11-24-2007 @ 9:48AM
Mana said...
I agree with the people defending Lady In the Water.
I personally thought it was a great movie. It kept me entertained and it was different.
Reply
12-26-2007 @ 9:27PM
no one said...
i'm surprised rob synder isn't on here
Reply