The Supposed 'Lost in Translation' Spoiler
Filed under: Comedy, Drama, Celebrities and Controversy, Fandom, Tech Stuff
There's a piece of video being hosted over at Slashfilm that came from a Youtube guy who digitally messed around with the sound levels on Sofia Coppola's Lost in Translation, and claims to have uncorked the movie's biggest secret -- what is being said to Scarlett Johansson by Bill Murray in that famous final scene. I'm not going to give it away here, but I'm not even sure this spoiler is legit -- even amplified as best it can be, the words still require subtitles for you to follow along and it doesn't even seem like that's what Bill Murray is saying. The first part is especially a stretch I think, although I'd probably guess the last part is more or less accurate. And I will concede that it does seem like something that Murray's character would say and something that Coppola would write -- it's not, as some expected, Murray telling Johannson what he had for lunch or anything.
Lost in Translation was not my gateway film into Coppola -- for me, it was Marie Antoinette, so for me, this isn't some major cinematic mystery that I was dying to solve in the first place. I'm more concerned with the how and why Marie Antoinette got completely shafted at the Academy Awards and I look forward to the day when the Academy makes up for that huge mistake. Coppola will one day be recognized as a chip off the old block and hopefully, she'll also have more productive years and less time in the cinema wilderness than her pops. Check out the Lost in Translation video after the jump ...
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-14-2007 @ 12:03PM
Rufus said...
I think the problem is, who cares? It ruins the moment and the idea of what was or wasn't said to... know what or wasn't said.
Some things are best left alone. Can you imagine if Donnie Darko was explained to us with bells and whistles... wow. That one's better left up to us to decide too.
Also, I've always been under the assumption that the final scene (including the kiss) was totally unscripted. I don't believe is was written, unless it was put in as something to work with in the moment?
I like the thought of it being Bill and Scarlett just doing as they wish. It certainly makes it more powerful to think they felt something in that moment on, and off the screen.
Reply
12-14-2007 @ 12:06PM
E said...
I really don't think that's what he said and I don't really care. He probably told her he needed to go take a leak and she said ok.
Reply
12-14-2007 @ 12:34PM
Flit said...
He said "help me, i've lived this same day every day for 3 months, make it stop!"
Reply
12-14-2007 @ 4:55PM
Akbar Fazil said...
"Some things are best left alone. Can you imagine if Donnie Darko was explained to us with bells and whistles... wow. That one's better left up to us to decide too."
Oh you mean like the craptastic Directors Cut did?
Reply