The Exhibitionist: Five Worst Theatrical Experiences of 2007
Filed under: Fandom, Exhibition

It's only been three months since I began this column on theater exhibition and movie going, but already I've covered all kinds of experiences, both good and bad. And now I'd like to recap the year, concentrating on that quarter year in which The Exhibitionist existed, in order to present you with the best and the worst theatrical experiences I had in 2007. However, while this may seem like a cheap way to link back to previous writings and make an easy article out of that, I assure you that it's only a coincidence that some of my favorite and least favorite moments in exhibition happened since October. Anyway, there are plenty of moments I cite that were never mentioned in The Exhibitionist, so regular or new reader, read on:
Theatrical Experiences of 2007 Part I: The Worst
Pan's Labyrinth at Cobble Hill Cinemas, Brooklyn, NY, 01/16/07
I came away from watching Guillermo del Toro's "masterpiece" underwhelmed, thanks primarily to my inability to appreciate the Oscar-winning cinematography of Guillermo Navarro. How so? Well, the projection of the film where and when I saw it was terribly underlit. At least, I'm guessing it was. I've only seen the film partially since then, on DVD, and at that time it looked much brighter than I remembered.
At the time I saw the film theatrically, though, I just assumed the film was really that dark. Well, actually I thought it could be faulty projection, but I didn't want to get into the issue with the management. Most theaters are quite defensive when it comes to the subject of whether or not they dim the projector bulbs, and whether or not it matters. Even before I became a projectionist I knew thanks to Roger Ebert's Answer Man columns about the stupidity and annoyance of turning down the power on projector bulbs, but unfortunately not everyone else seems to know.
No Country for Old Men at Cobble Hill Cinemas, Brooklyn, NY, 11/23/07
I hate to use Cobble Hill for two bad examples back to back, and I assure you that neither of these complaints is exclusive to this often-satisfactory, independently run cinema. It just happens to be my local theater, and I happened to have two bad experiences there this year. Both problems have actually been experienced more often in previous years when I lived elsewhere and had different local theaters.
Anyway, you may have read about this experience, which did not ruin the movie for me as much as Pan's Labyrinth was ruined for me, but was still annoying and distracting. I've always been conscious of the problem, because I worked as an usher and/or concessionist in so many theaters that had bad soundproofing. And I always tried to be quiet enough when working around doors that weren't well soundproofed. In the end, though, it's impossible to both do your job and appease the customers inside the auditorium. It comes down to a problem of construction, of ownership and the cheapness of both.
Juno at Regal Union Square Stadium 14, New York, NY, 12/11/07
There was nothing wrong with the film, nothing wrong with the projection. But there was a problem with the pre-show entertainment. Now, normally I don't mind the pre-show commercials. Yet I do find one type of commercial that is more difficult to ignore than others: the military recruitment ads, which typically make me angry, though that's besides the point in this situation. No recruitment ad has ever been as awful as the new overlong National Guard commercial that features a full-length music video from 3 Doors Down, a band that performs a hypocritical tune, which makes me despise them also more than I had prior. Fortunately, there was some good to come out of it (see the best of list).
Across the Universe at Tribeca Cinemas, New York, NY, 09/07/07 (no ticket saved)
One of the perks of living in New York City is having access to all the special screenings that feature post-film discussions with filmmakers, film historians and other related experts. Unfortunately, at times those Q&A sessions can really leave you with a bad aftertaste, as that director or whoever you've gone to see is not quite as enjoyable as you had hoped. In fact, sometimes they're downright disagreeable. This year alone, I've been turned off by many people, most of whom I'd consider myself a fan. Nobody was as frustrating in 2007, though, than Across the Universe director Julie Taymor. Of course, it didn't help that I had just sat through her film and despised almost every second of it. I won't go into detail with what she said, because my disappointment in her was highly subjective. I'm simply acknowledging that it's a hard thing to face when a person you put on a pedestal doesn't live up to your expectations of him or her.
Beowulf in IMAX 3D at AMC Loews Lincoln Square 13, New York, NY, 11/19/07
This is another disappointing experience, which I've previously written about. I'll let that post speak for itself, though I wanted to point out the lasting effects of what that experience has done to me. Despite my claims that I am willing to give both IMAX 3D another shot, I realize that I can't imagine traveling the distance and spending the added costs just to hope that I'll have a better next time. Already I have been torn about whether or not I should try out the non-3D, blockbuster movie IMAX experience with I Am Legend. I came very close this past week, yet factors such as it selling out every show and my not having a lot of free time or cash this time of year ultimately kept me away. Now, I may never end up seeing the movie in that format, because it's pretty much old news. And as for IMAX 3D experiences, well, they are far from being old news. In fact, they'll continue being big news throughout the next year. I guess I've got another twelve months to force myself in front of that giant screen while wearing those uncomfortable glasses. Maybe next year, some IMAX 3D experience will make it on the best of list. Let's hope so.
Stay tuned next week for Part II of my year-end summary of theatrical experiences, in which I will present the best of 2007.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-23-2007 @ 10:16AM
mainfr4me said...
I agree with your hate of the pre-movie commercials (not the trailers, the trailers are half the reason for going), but I don't agree with your dislike of the National Guard ads. They're doing their best to promote something just like anyone else. I'd rather knock the repeated to sickness Pepsi Max ads. At least with a music video you have some musical entertainment value.
Reply
12-23-2007 @ 10:27AM
MCW said...
Totally agree on 3 Doors Down crap. "Join The Marines today" - "Get a free coffin just for enrollment!". I don't need to see that stuff right before a movie. Especially not an entire music video. I wanted to throw up when I saw that junk come on.
I also had a terrible "Regal Theaters" experience recently, mostly due to weak customer service and unsanitary conditions at the snack bar area. I emailed Regal about it, they don't respond to emails though, surprise surprise. Can't wait to see your best experiences... that'll be hard to decide on won't it?
Reply
12-23-2007 @ 10:51AM
Mike said...
You need to cut them some slack about the soundproofing. I agree that it is annoying, but you're battling physics here. I've built a few recording studios in the past years and I can attest it's an expensive and difficult process. Blocking high frequencies is the "easy" part. Blocking low frequencies is nearly impossible without separating each theater with 10' thick walls with several walls built inside, which all would easily be compromised as soon as someone opens the door. Even the BEST soundproofing available today can't do much better than a 70-75db reduction (the one's I built came in at about 60db reduction and cost millions). But you're talking blocking bass signals that are often over 120db in strength. The difference is equivalent to normal conversation levels. Usually this is masked when the film you're watching is 3 times louder, but not in the case of relatively quiet films. The price to block that left-over 45db down to an acceptable 20-25db, would increase the construction of each theater by at least $200k. At least. Cut them some slack.
Reply
12-23-2007 @ 11:54AM
The Addict said...
So, you never really got into bothering you about any of these. Not really, anyway. You just scraped the surface of what was wrong. "Pan's Labyrinth looked dim" was about the closest you came to really digging deep. I'd love to read a column like this, but actually know the details of what went wrong.
Reply
12-23-2007 @ 2:23PM
Christopher Campbell said...
Mike: I'll try to give the theaters some slack. But it will still be something I'm annoyed with, and at least with Cobble Hill, I realize that it's not much the theater owner's fault.
TheAddict: Good point, and I'm sorry I didn't have enough time/room to be specific or technical about some of my complaints, especially the Pan's Labyrinth situation, of which I've never written on before. I shall try to devote a full column to the problem of dim bulbs after the new year.
Reply
12-23-2007 @ 5:52PM
Nate said...
Did you get stoned before going to Beowulf in 3-D?
If not, I don't think you got the "full" experience.
Reply
12-23-2007 @ 6:13PM
The Addict said...
Thank you. Didn't mean to sound like a dick, being like "mreh this is stupid" or something, but rather was hoping to provide some constructive criticism based on my views. I hope it was taken that way and not the former.
Reply
12-24-2007 @ 6:38PM
NukeAssault said...
I Am Legend in imax wasent that great of an experience. The film didint seem like it was truly meant for imax. The formatting seemed wrong. Its possible it was just my seating position (slightly above the middle) .Other that i really enjoyed the movie.
Reply
12-25-2007 @ 10:59PM
Scott Diedrick said...
Thank God I live in Austin and can go to the Alamo Drafthouse theaters
Reply
12-26-2007 @ 11:29AM
Christopher said...
My Worst Experience this year for a film was:
- Harkins Camelview 5 in Scottsdale, Arizona!
Since this was the "Only" theater in the Phoenix Metro area "No Country for Old Men"that was playing "No Country For Old Men" opening weekend, I went to the 1st showing on Sunday morning (Opening weekend)! Big mistake! 1st what was bad they placed the film in what had to be the smallest movie theater in the world. I'm not kidding! There was iterally no leg room (I'm 5'9) & it was uncomfortable! On top of that theater was almost sold out & the only seats that were available were the last 2 rows from the front of the screen. Now what would have been a good idea which never happend was the box office should have placed a sign up to indicate this! So after spedning up to 20 minuites in line, & then you get to the box office where a bored teenager gives you this info! I thought "What the Hell, I want to see this film"!
Big mistake! I was seated to the far left side of the theater where I had to keep my head almost tilted back through out the entire film, while people on my right & left and behind me would nudge and kick me several times through out! Not fun!
The 2nd worse thing, all the back talking and chatter through out! ""No Country for Old Men" is a quite film
This is true! There are moments you have to just watch and listen! Not only is there little dialogue, there's little anything on the soundtrack for the majority of two hours. Well I had people saying things like "What Happend?", "Is the kiler behind the door?," etc..etc..! I mean you be would sitting there in almost stone cold silence, when some person out of the blue would just break the mood &/or tone of the film & then you would be taken out of the story!!
I complained to managment after the film ended, & they did nothing like refund the ticket price etc, there attitude was "So what!". Theater managment told me I should have come to them during the film. (Yeah like was going to step over 15 people almost in the dark to go to managment, I'm not rude like others int he film). I even called the corporate office's to report the problems I had & to this date, 12/26/07 I haven't received a phone call back!!
Thank God "No Country for Old Men" came to other theaters in the weeks since, & I had a better experience else where when I saw the film a second time!!
Reply
12-26-2007 @ 11:38AM
Christopher said...
Also no theater in Phoenix, Az has yet to show "Revolver" Directed by Guy Ritchie!! I love AMC Theaters, but what amazes me is that for example we have the AMC Arizona Center 24 (the name says it all). They can put for example "Iam Legend" on 2 screens etc, but a "RARE" film like "Revolver" has yet to open!!! Well I guess i will catch it on DVD, I have already waited to 2 years to see it, what is another couple of months!?!!?
Reply
12-26-2007 @ 11:47AM
Christopher said...
I also totally agree on the 3 door down song "Citizen soldier" !! I see at least 3 films per week in theater, & every damn AMC Theater I go to play's this crappy PRO-Bush song!! It's loud, noisy & just plain bad! When the song comes on I just get up and leave the theater & sit in the lobby till the song ends!
& I agree too, I hate the pre-movie commercials!! If I wanted to watch a commercial about a car, or coke rewards I would have stayed at home!
I do really like that at AMC theaters they have a pre-show where they introduce a new film with cast and crew interviews!
Reply
12-27-2007 @ 12:13AM
Matthew Williams said...
I have a few bad moviegoing experiences of 2007, but the one that sticks out the most was "The Kingdom" (awful movie to boot) at AMC/Loews Cherry Hill 24 in the Philly area.
I enter the auditorium - one of the few bigger ones there - and get my seat, about 15 minutes or so before start time. The cleanup crew (which I saw laughing in the hallways) didn't get there - so the auditorium is completely filthy. Empty soda cups, popcorn bags, nacho boxes, outside food - it's strewn all over the place. People begin to filter in and take their seats - trying to find the few that doesn't have crap in them.
As the Screenvision preshow finishes up, who walks in? You guessed it, the cleanup crew. They proceed to clean up the trash - in rushed fashion - as the trailers roll. So the staffers could see, the lights are kept at "preshow level" through the trailers. Unfortunately, someone forgot to reset them, so the lights were on - at "trailer" level - through the movie. Which of course meant that when the end credits rolled, the lights dimmed completely.
This isn't the only bad experience I've had there, but it's probably the most egregious. It's been better the last few times I've been there - "better" as in "somewhat adequate", as it's still an awful theatre - but still. You don't have the cleanup crew walk in during the trailers.
Agreed on everything else, especially the beyond awful National Guard ad which I have to endure every time I go to a Regal or AMC. I don't mind the pre-show ads, but this is borderline offensive due to the shameless/shameful use of 9/11 imagery to get people to join.
Reply
12-27-2007 @ 3:27PM
Jen said...
I, too, agree with the National Guard recruitment ad complaint. I saw the same movie at the same theater, and just about barfed.
Reply
12-28-2007 @ 10:27PM
Toobusyforyourignorantthoughts said...
I'm glad to see that I'm not the only one who hates that military ad/video! I saw it before I watched Sweeney Todd!! I don't want to see that crap before I'm entertained.
Reply
12-30-2007 @ 2:37PM
Christopher Campbell said...
Matthew: I have had and unfortunately been a part of that experience too often. Usually it's a problem of poor planning of showtimes combined with an unusually busy weekend. Either way, there's not much excuse for it. Still, I think customers need to bus their own trash more. I never leave anything behind when I leave my seat.
Reply
1-08-2008 @ 4:55PM
Kelly said...
I am really hurt by the response to the National Guard ad in the pre screening. My husband is a army veteran and now active duty National Guard. If you have a problem with the song, that is fine. However, if you have a problem with the military then thats not right. They are doing there jobs and should not be looked down on for that. They have courage that many us would never find. It is sad that so many of you have no kind words to say about the very people that have given you the right to say those unkind words without being persecuted. 3 Doors down does a lot for the military USO tour to help motivate and entertain the troops on deployment and to offer free concerts for those who are here. A portion of the proceeds from the sale of the song in the ad will go to a fund to help family members of Guardsmen that were killed in the war. You all should really think before you speak and put yourself in someone else's shoes for once.
Reply
1-09-2008 @ 1:38AM
syms covington said...
We have the same problems in Australia, however the exhibitors have an even stronger stranglehold here:
http://symscovington.blogspot.com/2008/01/hes-lost-control_07.html
Reply