The Dirty Truth About 'Fanboys'
Filed under: Comedy, RumorMonger, Celebrities and Controversy, Fandom, The Weinstein Co., DIY/Filmmaking, Comic/Superhero/Geek
.jpg)
Here's the Fanboys synopsis currently up on IMDb: "Star Wars" fans travel to Skywalker Ranch to steal an early copy of "Episode I: The Phantom Menace" for their dying friend."
Problem is, that's not the movie everyone will see when it eventually hits theaters. There's been a ton of talk surrounding the Fanboy re-cuts; how the cancer storyline was taken out, how Kyle Newman was replaced as director, and how the Weinsteins have pretty much turned Fanboys into a completely different film from what was originally intended. Yesterday, fans wrote into AICN claiming to have donated props for the film, and were upset over all these changes. So upset they were starting a campaign against The Weinstein Co., hoping to get Newman's original cut released instead of this new one.
Thanks to a well-placed, super delegate secret spy source, Cinematical was able to get the real skinny on what was going on with Fanboys. Some of this info is new, some old, but I have confirmed all of it to be true. First off, Kyle Newman definitely was replaced as director for the re-shoots by Steve Brill (Without a Paddle). The "dying of cancer" storyline was completely dumped, and, instead, the fanboys are now trying to sneak a copy of Phantom Menace simply because they're fans and want to see it. According to my source, the story is now "disjointed, nonsensical and lacking any heart."
Oh, there's more ...
Here's where it gets messy: Apparently, both versions were screened for test audiences -- and the new version only tested two points higher than the old version. My super delegate source also claims plants may have been in the audience -- there to pursuade moviegoers to vote against the original version -- but this has not been proven. In two days, after the old version was screened, Brill re-cut the film and they tested it again -- this time it was tighter, dirtier and contained nudity, lots of F-bombs, the whole works. And even with all that, it still only tested two points higher than the old version. But since Weinstein had to justify the fact that they spent an extra $2 million on the re-shoots, they went with the newer, flashier, Without a Paddle-esque version of Fanboys.
This new version, I've been told, is funny, but nowhere close to what it was supposed to be. It was supposed to be for fans who grew up with Star Wars -- it was supposed to be a love letter to George Lucas -- and now it's, well, Without a Paddle 2. The real problem here, I feel, is not so much the fact that the movie was re-shot and re-cut, but that the studio may have been using plants in a test audience to try to get moviegoers to sway their opinion. What the f*ck is the purpose of a test audience then?
There's some more that I can't get into, but there you have it. There's still no word on when the film will arrive in theaters (if at all), but I'll be checking out a cut of Fanboys soon and will report back on how it is.









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
2-21-2008 @ 2:11PM
Eli Burnside said...
they should just stuck with the original copy and left it at that.
Reply
2-21-2008 @ 2:13PM
Akbar Fazil said...
wow. I had high hopes for an enjoyable film in this. But taking out the cancer plot was just dumb. Removing that removed any humanity to what they were doing. Now they are just fans who will break the law to be super fans. No thank you.
Reply
2-21-2008 @ 2:15PM
Akbar Fazil said...
I doubt it will happen, but maybe we will get the original cut on dvd?
Reply
2-21-2008 @ 2:31PM
Scott Weinberg said...
I find it sad and hilarious that they thought the guy who directed Without a Paddle, Mr. Deeds, and Little Nicky could actually FIX a troubled project.
Reply
2-21-2008 @ 2:54PM
Matthew said...
Maybe the Weinsteins are hoping the re-cut will be able to turn into a franchise... it's not like they couldn't use a series of hits.
Reply
2-21-2008 @ 3:16PM
Alex said...
Call me heartless but the "dying of cancer" subplot sounded just awful. Some kid has a terminal disease and the last movie he's likely to see is The Phantom Menace?! That's soul-crushing on too many levels for me to enjoy.
I'm more likely to see this now but I'm interested in seeing the original cut just to see if I'm wrong. Hopefully they do put it out on DVD.
Reply
2-21-2008 @ 4:44PM
Yorick said...
I still don´t get why they need a test audience, if they already had their preference on the second cut (which doesn´t look good).
It´s like they have to fool themselves...
By the way...nudity? Kristen Bell?
Reply
2-21-2008 @ 4:54PM
Fuzzyfreaker said...
Idiots.
This is the problem with comedies today, they take all the heart out of it. Recutting Fanboys just to make it more like everything else is pathetic. The movie had heart to it, was supposed to be an homage to Star Wars fans, now it's just a blantant stereotype.
I don't see why the Weinsteins have to do this! Why not leave it as the director intended? Not every comedy have to be the same, it worked for Juno...
But I hope somebody comes to their senses and fixes this. I want to see the real Fanboys, not whatever they've done to it.
Reply
2-21-2008 @ 7:05PM
Travis Tidmore said...
So now the only way to make a movie funny is to add f-bombs and copious amounts of nudity? that's ridiculous. I saw the footage (45min worth) that was screened at Celebration back in May and it was hilarious without making it filthy.
I guess the Weinstiens thing you can't make a funny movie unless it's rated R?
An no KB will not be nude.
Reply
2-21-2008 @ 7:49PM
Irondude said...
The Weinsteins have been making movies for decades and know what they are doing. The cancer idea was a terrible subplot, I'm glad it's gone.
I too didn't undersand why the characters couldn't just break in to view the movie in advance out of pure Star Wars fanaticism.
Reply
2-22-2008 @ 10:30PM
Stop Darth Weinstein said...
This movie has been in the works for ten years, and the storyline was reported in Newsweek and the Village Voice as far back as 1999.
The saga continues! Steve Brill, the asshat who is butchering Fanboys, has just emailed the fans trying to save the movie. See what this moron had to say at:
http://committed.to/stopdarthweinstein
Reply