The Geek Beat: Remake, Reboot, Revision
Filed under: Fandom, Comic/Superhero/Geek, Remakes and Sequels, The Geek Beat

There are so many familiar faces returning to the big screen -- Indiana Jones and Marion Ravenwood, Mulder and Scully, Batman, the crew of the USS Enterprise, John Connor, the Hulk. They're following hard on the heels of Rambo, Rocky and John McClane. Naturally, Indy and two FBI Agents seem to be causing the greatest stir of late. The continuous refrain on the Internet is "Oh wow, this summer is the greatest ever – a fourth Indy and a second X-Files movie, it is everything I could have wanted!"
It is with great shame that I confess that I don't feel the same way. I feel like a character in Invasion of the Body Snatchers because everyone but me is so excited – though undoubtedly most of you think I'm the pod person – and I wish I could join in. I can't really understand why I'm not more excited. Indiana Jones made me the girl I am (a subject for another Geek Beat) and my bookshelf held my X-Files guides until only recently.
No doubt some of my feeling is born of cynicism. I remember the last time I was excited for a familiar mythology, Jar Jar Binks drove a stake through my heart (I think there is a prophecy somewhere in Paisley Abbey that says my heart will beat again in 2010). But I think with me, it has simply been a matter of time. It's been too long. I have moved on. I look around at some of my friends, who are wetting their pants in anticipation, and I wonder why they haven't. Why did I? A girl who displays an official Indy fedora on her bookshelf (I should photograph my decor. It's very classy), and who still keeps her Scully suit lovingly wrapped in plastic in the basement. Why did I move on to other things, while everyone else was willing to wait for the return of David Duchovny?
Now, before you flame my ass, let me say that I don't think such excitement is a bad thing. I think this spate of sequels, remakes, and reboots speaks to something much deeper in our society. Times are pretty rough. We're at war, our economy is going down the toilet, the wider world hates us, and it is an election year. Elections are stirring, but hardly relaxing. So what better comfort is there than to sit in a dark theatre, and watch Indiana Jones crack his bullwhip? John Connor can save mankind, even if our presidents and prime ministers cannot. It is the equivalent of going home after flunking the math test or being picked last for dodge ball, and having your mum make you chocolate chip cookies. Movies are the comfort food of the millennium.
So, why not me? I'm pretty stressed about the election, and I lack health care. Why am I not racing to be comforted by the familiar? Maybe it is because my mom still makes me kickass chocolate chip cookies if I'm crying. Maybe I am a bad and disloyal geek. Or maybe I am drowning my fears and sorrows in the thrill of novelty. Because it isn't as though I'm unmoved by upcoming releases. I can't wait for Nim's Island (Gerard Butler probably has something to do with it), Iron Man, Wall ·E, The Dark Knight. I'm cautiously optimistic about Watchmen, The Spirit, Prince Caspian, Wolverine and Star Trek. And yes, one could say that The Dark Knight, Star Trek, and Wolverine fall into retread category, but they are also fresh takes on classic stories and characters, and thus not entirely nostalgic. (Time will tell on Star Trek. That's why I said cautiously!) And I'm not into just the geekier stuff – I'm also eagerly awaiting The Road and Public Enemies.
That's where it is for me. When I sit down in the movie theatre, I want to see something entirely new. Last year, 300 was where it was at for me. (The first person to say it was fascist right wing propaganda will be kicked into a well!) It may have been overblown, I may have hated the guy with saws for arms, but it was visually stunning (and I'm not just talking about the loincloths and muscles). It was ancient epic set to guitar riffs. It was glorious fun, and never apologized for it. That's what I'm wanting this year, and I know there's a film that's up to the challenge.
In the end, I don't need to see Indy ride again, because I can happily pop in Raiders of the Lost Ark any time I want to. He's always there for me, as good as ever, no matter what movies come and go. So, let us give the big screen over to fresh stories and new adventures. I'd love to see Connie Willis' Doomsday Book or Passage on the big screen. We3 or Ender's Game -- both optioned but languishing in pre production. The Lay of Beren and Luthien. Anything by Ray Bradbury. Dean Koontz's Watchers (done a million times, but never correctly) or Winter Moon. A costume piece that doesn't involve the Tudors. There are so many possibilities, so many stories just begging to be told with a big budget, that I hate to see old ground retread. Not when I already have it on DVD.









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-01-2008 @ 1:41PM
brian said...
Alright, ms. Rappe....two things.
Original movies like those you've mentioned are made...every week they come out and every week most fail. 300 didn't fail.
Movies like the ones we love having back again and again are the ones that allow more of the same to be made.
People take chances on new movies and new ideas all the time...(that is why it would be nice to see the poor mystique surrounding direct-to-video disappear...there are so many awesome ideas that would make a lot of money if released just to dvd. Maybe blu-ray will help facilitate that)
Secondly-are you married? Would you like to be? This post was like one long reason you would make an awesome girlfriend.
Love original movies? Check.
Indy fedora on your mantle? Check.
Scully outfit in plastic? Check.
And on and on...
Anyway...good on you for not drinking the Kool-Aid so much. I mean, really...the kid's name is MUTT?
Wow...
Reply
4-01-2008 @ 11:28PM
Gregory Rubinstein said...
I think that guy's hitting on you on your own blog. Haha... Oh, and I hate to say it, but I hated 300. I thought it was one of the worst movies of last year. That was probably because I hated the story. I will say that it was visually stunning when it came to graphics, but I thought the dialogue was campy and repetitive.
Reply