The Geek Beat: Dressing Up In Film Love
Filed under: Fandom, The Geek Beat

By now you're thinking "cosplayer weirdos!" and let me stop you there. First, there are two categories of people who do this – there are costumers, and there are cosplayers. Both categories have their share of the insane, but also many who are pretty cool. Like anything else, there is definitely a line with this hobby, and way too many people who have crossed it. Chances are, if you've visited a convention, Renaissance Faire, Hollywood Blvd., or watched Trekkies, you've encountered a few of them. Hopefully though, you've also encountered a few of the cooler ones and know that we are not all fruit loops.
My sister and I are costumers. Yes, that it us pictured up top. I'm Queen Gorgo, and Sarah is Selene. In the middle is her boyfriend, Michael Sheridan, the professional Jack Sparrow. The three of us seem to have stumbled into this hobby accidentally. Sarah and I grew up attending the Colorado Renaissance Festival, and spent our springs searching out authentic brocades and wools for our bodices and skirts. Our family has always been history obsessed and it just never struck us as a particularly odd interest – especially as friends and relatives were forever calling us up to borrow pieces of our faire garb.
As Sarah and I became too old to trick or treat, but old enough to party, we began expanding our costuming to Halloween. I think my first foray was the infamous Agent Scully costume, which was something I thought would be a lark for Halloween. I was already sporting her haircut (what geek girl wasn't?), and found a near replica of her Fight the Future suit at a department store. Wham! It was a hit and before I knew it, I had been recruited by a David Duchovny lookalike to attend the local sci-fi convention with him.
Only when I found myself discussing how painful high heels were with a Klingon in drag, as an Obi-Wan and Darth Maul chanted "Scully put the F in FBI!" did I realize that I was in a whole new realm, one far odder than the Renaissance Faire. It just spiraled from there. And after a Halloween where Sarah and I spent hours on Selene and Lara Croft, we just looked at each other and said "We've spent all this money, let's just wear our costumes to ComicCon." We accepted the inevitable, and became costumers.
Costumers generally come into the hobby via the Renaissance Faire, or Jedi robes. We strive for authentic recreation. Last year, I spent hours trying to track down Spartan fabric, determined if I couldn't achieve film accuracy, I would stick to historic. Weeks later, I was in possession of yards of unbleached hemp, purchased from the company who had actually supplied 300. I argued with jewelry makers all over the Internet trying to get someone to hammer me her bronze bracelet.
Sarah's obsession was trying to replicate Kate Beckinsale's magnetic gun holsters in Underworld. Michael hand-carved the molds of his belt buckles after studying Jack Sparrow frame by frame. And that was this year – in the past my mother and sister spent hours with Sculpey and tweezers making Lothlorian leaves for LOTR costumes. Not all the dressed-up geeks one encounters at conventions stress about historic Sparta or belt buckles, though. Many are just about the playing, and they probably have way more fun than we costumers do. I realized this when I encountered other Queen Gorgos, who had been quite content to use whatever white fabric they could, and safety pin the leather straps together. (If only they knew how much Carlos, my tailor, and I had agonized over Grecian drapery and how to hide the fastenings!)
Again, you are probably reading this going "I'm sorry, all of you people are nuts." But we're not! This just isn't as unusual as it used to be. The Internet has really made costuming and cosplaying mainstream. If you doubt it, you only have to look at companies like NECA and Master Replicas. Back in 1990, a fantasy movie like Highlander could garner a sword replica. Now, any costume movie automatically gets a plethora of prop replicas -- you can buy an entire King Leonidas costume from NECA if you so desire. No longer do costumers have to make do, wait a few months and you can buy Sweeney Todd's razor. Costuming has become big business. It also helps that so many movies that costumers latch on to have been so wildly popular. Pirates of the Caribbean sealed what Lord of the Rings had begun – suddenly, men who were unwilling to join the 501st were caving in to their desire to wear eyeliner and accessorize. It is another facet of the geek chic trend.
The thing is, most costumers are just expressing a love of film. We're like film students who study lighting and shot techniques, and try to replicate them. Costume fans are also seeking the how. We're endlessly fascinated with the construction and the color, how they are made with lighting and make-up in mind, the symbolism that is often worked in, the stories of the actors in them. One of my favorite examples is Rachel Weisz's Spanish dress in The Fountain – if you look carefully, the Tree of Life is embroidered on the back of the skirt. Another favorite of mine is Lara's red seduction dress in Doctor Zhivago – Julie Christie hated the dress and refused to wear it, until they stressed to her that she was supposed to feel miserable in it. It wasn't intended to be sexy, it was intended to be demeaning. Two sites really exemplify and normalize this kind of fandom – my favorite is The Costumer's Guide to Movie Costumes, the other is Alley Cat Scratch. Both sites arose out of a love of analyzing film costumes – one purely from Lord of the Rings, the other from post-Merchant and Ivory costume dramas.
Of course, costumers eventually end up duplicating whatever they've analyzed. No one sets out to be a costumer – it is an accidental process. After you've studied the construction of Arwen's dress, you want to try to make it. When you succeed, you might as well wear it somewhere. That's what's happened to us, anyway. Naturally, there's a love of the character too, the same as when you chose a Halloween costume. I love Lara Croft, and I love being her for a day or two. But I loved hunting down the authentic boots just as much. (Not so much the gun rig. Man, was that a pain in the ass.)
So, this spring finds us doing it all again. And if you're rolling your eyes, take a bit of perspective. Some people go to spring training to watch their baseball team, others spend hundreds on golf equipment or mountain bikes. This is what we do instead. This year, our efforts are a bit more subdued. Sarah is deep in the process of making a Sweeney Todd costume for Halloween. It's not for Sheridan the Depp lookalike – but for herself. She's a cosmetology student and the chance to cut hair as the Demon Barber of Fleet Street is just too good to pass up. I'm too poor this year, so my costuming is largely external as I spend my afternoons doing stomach crunches to be in Lara Croft shape for ComicCon. But given our circle, there's no telling what could happen. I may find myself being fitted for that Dark Phoenix suit I swore I'd never do – and wondering how I get myself into these things.












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-15-2008 @ 1:48PM
BondsBabe said...
I went to Colorado Renaissance Fairs! :) I haven't done much costuming, though I like seeing people in really good ones. You see some fun costumes at American Doctor Who conventions, lots of scarves and multi-colored long coats. My first good costume was a British Naval 'Midshipman Hornblower' costume for my sister one year. Much to the delight of my boyfriend, I made horror comic-book heroine Vampirella's skimpy costume that would be illegal in so many ways for me to be seen in public wearing! ;D
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 1:49PM
gaffer said...
Queen Gorgo is teh hott!!!
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 1:52PM
Moo said...
haha, i'm not a costumer myself, but I do enjoy it when folks show creativity and attention to detail. The pictures above are great!
I'm looking forward to finally hitting comic con this year so I can check out some of the wilder outfits in person...
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 4:51PM
Is a Monkey said...
People in costumes rock. I wish I could go to Comic con...
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 7:51PM
Moo said...
I wish you could too!
4-15-2008 @ 7:07PM
kaitlin Hess said...
I wish i had the money and resources to cosplay.....it looks so fun!
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 7:17PM
Tigerlily said...
The stress, the painstaking attention to detail, the thrill of success, and the glow of pleasure when the work is done and recognized. Yeah, I think it's worth it.
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 9:58PM
Gustavo Brunetti said...
With all due respect, Ms Rappe, you're really hot!
Reply
4-16-2008 @ 1:42PM
Maggie said...
I enjoyed your article - thanks so much for saying nice things about my site!
Maggie
costumersguide
Reply
4-16-2008 @ 3:34PM
xocc said...
Please tell me you're single!
Reply
4-17-2008 @ 5:50AM
Elisabeth said...
LOL! Yes, I am single.
And thanks, Gustavo.
4-18-2008 @ 3:11PM
Pipsi said...
I've been cosplaying for years, but I've just recently realized my painstaking attention to detail and yearning for utter perfection has made me more cut out for "costuming" rather than "cosplaying" (yes, there is definitely a difference!). It truly is a thrill to be able to achieve a certain look after hours (and hours, and hours...) of research and hard work. I think your article summed up the pleasures and pains of this obsession quite nicely :)
Reply
4-18-2008 @ 3:12PM
Elisabeth said...
Thank you. :D I originally had a discussion of how cosplaying and costuming differed, but the article was already too long...and I didn't want to be raided by angry cosplayers. :P
4-18-2008 @ 4:00PM
CostumeCon 27 said...
Thank you so much for your article. After spending years making replica costumes and working on costuming conventions like CostumeCon, it's nice to see that our world is growing.
Reply
4-18-2008 @ 4:21PM
variety of misanthropy said...
Join us LARPers, we're the real geeks ;)
Reply
4-21-2008 @ 10:26AM
Iggy said...
Nope, I fell into it that way, too. (Also doesn't help my Uncle's a Lord in the SCA :P) Ever since I was a kid I'd loved Halloween and wanted to have the most realistic costume because I thought that was the point of a costume-- to be something else (in my case usually something scary). After working in haunted houses and doing costume contests I got more into it, and despite being a tomboy against makeup I found myself becoming obsessed with any costume I could practice prosthetics and stage makeup with. Now my art business I began to get under way a couple years back has migrated into what will probably end up being a masquerade/cosplay shop. Who knew? Its a great hobby, I agree. One thing is the next step is cosplaying....even if you're not a cosplayer you end up accidentally getting into character if you get into a good enough mood and become that proud of it. ;)
Reply
4-21-2008 @ 4:07PM
Aichan said...
my fancy for costuming and cosplay stems from my grandmother's tanlent and love for making costumes and halloween.
Every year in my grandmothers neighborhood they'd hold a halloween costume contest, and for years my family reigned supreme, none of the other kids could compare to the Lance family's detailed costumes.
Halloween had always been my favorite time of year even moreso than christmas, simply because i got to wear an awesome costume my mother made for me that i desired.
but my first real dive into cosplay as a hobby came whan my friends invited me to my first Anime con. Oh my Gawd did i get hooked!
Now with my new group of cosplay buddies, be plan all year long what our next costumes will be.
I've come to appriciate how much hard work it takes to make a single costume, the time money and love that goes into it. and tyhe sheer Talent it takes simply to recreate a costume from single screenshots if thats all thats available!
this article truly sums up what it is to be a costumer ^_^
Reply
4-25-2008 @ 8:50PM
xocc said...
Hey, Elisabeth, good to hear you're single, lol...but you're not in LA, are you?? Anyway, I was also interested in hearing more about this cosplay vs. costumer thing. Are you on myspace or anything??
See you at SDCC!
Reply
5-13-2008 @ 6:21PM
Katrina said...
I've been costuming since I was ten (twelve years now), and I only got into cosplay about four years ago.
I still find it amazing how many more people are in costume at anime conventions than sf&f conventions. I really think it's less that there are huge differences between cosplay and costuming than differences in the ages and, I hate to say this, looks of the two groups.
What I mean is this... You've picked some beautiful people to show off in your pictures, but the majority of "famous" costumers in sf&f fandom are not those skinny, perfect people. Some of the International Costumers Guild members with the most awards, like the Pettingers or Animal X, are older and not the perfectly-proportioned people you're showing off. This is a group of people serious about costuming and not future super models, people who are role models for socially awkward people (like me) who want to get into making costumes. A lot of young people (especially women) just coming into cosplay find that the most famous and well-liked cosplayers are the most beautiful cosplayers. There is an insane number of websites out there picking on "improperly proportioned" cosplayers. Some of that cosplay snobbery is drifting to sf&f costuming. I could go on and on, but I've taken up too much space already.
Just remember, everyone, that you can dress as your favorite character even if you don't look like the freaks of nature that you see popping up everywhere as examples of good costumers.
Reply
5-13-2008 @ 8:08PM
Elisabeth said...
Wow, I think that is the first time in my life that I have been told I was too pretty and perfect to be a costumer. (You did realize that was one of the photos was me, right?) In fact, I am pretty sure that is the first time that Jack or Sarah have heard it either.
I'm a long, long way from being a supermodel, nor have I ever particularly aspired in that direction. I'm not really sure how to take any of that -- as a compliment or an insult...
So, I will just gently point out that your criticisms of us are no different than the people and websites who insult, as you put it, the less photogenic. I don't find myself particularly attractive ... frankly I think I am kind of weird looking, and hate my figure from the waist down. But that's beside the point. The real fact is, I resent the implication that my (or anyone's) costuming is less dedicated or serious because they are judged as attractive.
I mean really -- freaks of nature? That's a bit harsh, isn't it? The only people who can truly be serious and respected costumers are individuals who are older and "imperfect"? That's just as bad as those who insult costumers based on their weight. It is never ok to criticize someone's looks. Why can't it just be about the costumes?
I agree that costuming should be open to everyone. I wrote this article to encourage people to get into it, and to give an insider perspective. Most people have taken it in that spirit, but this is actually the second "you're not a real costumer" lecture I've gotten. I find it a bit perplexing and hurtful, really. It's this kind of exclusionism that leads people to mock anyone who engages in this kind of hobby. But I have often found that no one can be more vicious to a geek than another geek.