Cinematical Seven: Children's Books That Need To Be Filmed Immediately
Filed under: Classics, Family Films, Cinematical Seven, Lists

Long before I was a Cinematical blogger, before I even went to college, I worked in the children's department of Barnes and Noble. It was a daily adventure, filled with germs, the beginning of the Harry Potter craze, impossible shelving arrangements, and fuzzy character suits (of which I was the inevitable wearer of). But I developed a real fondness for children's literature – or rather, rediscovered it, as I came across every book that had made me who I am today. And thanks to Harry Potter, not only are children's books doing bigger business than ever before, the trend has thankfully been towards literary adaptations on the big screen. So in honor of April's Nim's Island, May's Prince Caspian, and the eventual Where the Wild Things Are, here are the seven children's books that need to be put into production tomorrow. To my surprise, a few of these have already been made, but were either forgotten, badly made, or in need of a remake. (My opinion only -- and I apologize in advance if, say, 1969's version of My Side of the Mountain is one of your childhood favorites, you think it should remain untouched.)
I have to say, though, choosing only seven was incredibly difficult. It was a tough call between The Trumpet of the Swan and The Mouse and the Motorcycle, Jackaroo and The Black Cauldron. As I was writing it, friends and family kept throwing in even more selections. So I hope this reawakens the memories of your childhood favorites -- and I can't wait to hear about the ones you'd like to see onscreen too!
I have to say, though, choosing only seven was incredibly difficult. It was a tough call between The Trumpet of the Swan and The Mouse and the Motorcycle, Jackaroo and The Black Cauldron. As I was writing it, friends and family kept throwing in even more selections. So I hope this reawakens the memories of your childhood favorites -- and I can't wait to hear about the ones you'd like to see onscreen too!
1. Bunnicula by Deborah and James Howe
One of the cutest horror spoofs ever – and I don't know a single child that dislikes it. It's the story of Harold the sheepdog, Chester the cat, and the mysterious Bunnicula, a baby rabbit discovered by the Monroe family at a nighttime showing of Dracula. The bunny has cape-like markings, two little fangs, and is only awake at night. Harold thinks he is just a bunny, but Chester is convinced they have a rabbit vampire – and his suspicions are confirmed by the house's vegetables being drained of juice. It's hilarious, and with today's CGI, there's no reason it can't be done. Bonus points if it could be as cute as the illustrations, which were so fuzzy you could practically pet them.
2. King of the Wind by Marguerite Henry
The most heartbreaking animal story ever. It's a fictional account of the real-life Godolphin Arabian, ancestor to Man O'War and Seabiscuit. The story begins in 18th century Morocco, where the Arabian is nearly killed at birth for bearing an ill-luck omen – until the mute boy saves him by discovering the horse has the marks of good fortune too. The horse is sent as a gift to King Louis XV of France, who thinks him ugly and condemns him to living as a cart-horse on the streets of Paris. The boy and his horse encounter no end of misery and degradation before finally ending up at the English estate of the Earl of Godolphin. The story rivals Black Beauty, and won the Newberry Medal. To my amazement, it has been done with none other than the late Sir Richard Harris – but I think it is high time this story of love and redemption is rediscovered.
3. Ghosts I Have Been by Richard Peck
The first in a series set around 1914, the books follow the titular Blossom Culp, a poor half-gypsy girl who literally lives on the wrong side of the tracks. She suffers all manner of psychic visions and ghostly encounters, which inevitably leave her to solving some kind of gruesome mystery. It's like Medium for the younger set. Culp is the coolest heroine I had the fortune to read as a young girl, as she is incredibly smart, feisty, and sarcastic –traits which serve her well in the snooty town of Bluff City. Her visions in this one deal with the Titanic, the story that will always send shivers down preteen spines. Incidentally, Ghosts I Have Been was largely responsible for me insisting on visiting Madame Tussaud's while in London – but to my bitter disappointment, the Chamber of Horrors described therein no longer exists.
4. My Side of the Mountain by Jean Craighead George
I was not an outdoorsy girl, but this book made me want to give up my suburban existence and live in a tree, eating nothing but roots, berries and acorns. I wanted a tame hawk, a weasel, and to play with raccoons. Shades of Into the Wild abound, but Sam's life in the wilderness boasts a happy ending. It was made into a movie in 1969, but I think it too deserves to be remade, especially as so many children are (allegedly) clueless about nature. Plus, now they could make a trilogy, as the third part of the story, Frightful's Song, was only just published in 2001.
5. A Cricket in Times Square by George Selden
My sister loved this book (it was second only to The Little Fur Family), and even named her hamster Tucker in honor of its resourceful mouse. She was always annoyed if I borrowed it or any of the sequels. Chester the cricket finds himself stranded in the New York City subway after smuggling inside a picnic basket. He's rescued by a boy named Mario, who works in his family's newsstand. Desperate for a pet, he convinces his mother to let him keep the cricket. A cricket's effect on a New York subway is, frankly, enchanting, and something the animated version just couldn't capture.
6. The Mouse and the Motorcycle by Beverly Cleary
This book kept me awake as a kid, because I was desperate to have a mouse who could actually ride a motorcycle, wear a golf ball helmet, and understand me. It was made into a television movie in 1986, but I remember being bitterly disappointed by it for reasons I can't quite remember. My cousin loved it, so maybe I'm mixing it up with something else. Anyway, no time like the CGI present to do it again – and there's a franchise here, as the book had two sequels.
7. Jackaroo by Cynthia Voight
Because young girls need a chick who brandishes a sword onscreen every year or so, and as Keira Knightley is hanging up her tricorn, a new girl must take her place. Gwyn is a young girl in the Kingdom (a vaguely named medieval land), who finds a disguise in her family's inn that she believes to have once belonged to Jackaroo, the local Robin Hood figure. She dons it herself to, surprise, rob the rich and assist the poor. I remember the costume being extremely cool, and that many swords were involved. Perhaps I'll pick it up someday and realize I added the action scenes myself.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
4-29-2008 @ 10:15PM
MCW said...
I've only read The Mouse and the Motorcycle by Beverly Cleary, and I agree that it should definitely be a film series. Stuart Little was successful, but I seem to remember "Mouse and the Motorcycle" having a lot of awesome illustrations in it (didn't it?), that really inspired me :) I love any Mouse movies, especially MOUSEHUNT. So, I'm all for that one. Good call!
Reply
5-02-2008 @ 3:57AM
Pam said...
I would also add another of Cynthia Voight's books, "On Fortune's Wheel," which is actually the first book in the Jackaroo series-this is such a great series for young adults! Also, I'd love to see Beverly Cleary's Ramona series put into movie form as well.
5-08-2008 @ 4:27PM
Courtney said...
Actually, to Pam, 'On Fortune's Wheel' is not the first in the series-it was 'Jackaroo', 'On Fortune's Wheel', and 'Elske' just like it was published. You see...not sure if it's much of a spoiler, but the nobleman's son from 'Jackaroo' is actually the old Duke in 'On Fortune's Wheel'-the girl in that book is also a descendant of Gwyn. The same sort of goes for 'Elske' in the way of descendants...
4-29-2008 @ 10:18PM
mike green said...
you forgot artemis fowl, that's a very filmable book and a great one at that
Reply
4-29-2008 @ 10:48PM
Mary said...
I can't believe someone hasn't made a movie from "Mouse and the Motorcycle". It was my all-time favorite. I don't exactly know why because I don't really like mice. I still have my copy tucked away with special momentos.
I've loved reading probably longer than I can actually remember. My niece is now the same way. I'm sharing all of my childhood favorites with her. I'm also researching with her new finds. We found a wonderful book that reminds me of "Nancy Drew", which I loved as well. The book is called "Bitter Tastes" by Author V.B. Rosendahl. It's a good old fashioned mystery with some wonderful new twists. Like Nancy Drew, main character Kathy is a gutsy girl-hero who isn't afraid to do what she thinks is right. We are recommending it to you all.
Again, I vote for the mouse!
Reply
4-29-2008 @ 11:12PM
rachelTVgirl said...
The Phantom Tollbooth! Criminally overlooked. Chuck Jones did an animated version (which isn't even on DVD) -- but a live action / CGI version would be great~
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 12:00AM
dan said...
There's also already an animated Bunnicula series (my little brother was obsessed with them on VHS) and an animated, pretty big-budget version of the Black Cauldron.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 2:25AM
Elisabeth said...
Everyone hated the Black Cauldron though -- and a live action version would be mind blowing.
Again, IMDB didn't bring up Bunnicula. I searched them all out, even via Google, and listed the ones I found. It must have a different title. But I mentioned the ones that DID have movies -- does no one actually read before tossing in their corrections? ;)
4-30-2008 @ 9:26AM
ML said...
Yes, Disney's Black Cauldron only bore a passing resemblance to the source material. A very poor adaptation indeed. I was extremely disappointed, to say the least.
4-30-2008 @ 12:39AM
Robert Frenay said...
The Giver.
The Giver, The Giver, The Giver.
The Giver.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 1:17PM
zombiekitty said...
Yes. You could make a really good movie off of that. They could work Jonas' slowly developing ability to distinguish color really well. But I'm not so sure it would be very well adapted into a kid's movie, but it could make an excellent grown up film in a similarish vein to Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (that's how I envision it anyways).
4-30-2008 @ 12:56AM
Christopher said...
"Bunnicula" was already made into a 1979 animated TV special ..."My Side of the Mountain" was loosely adapted into a movie in 1969......."The Mouse and the Motorcycle" was an ABC Weekend Special back in 1986....In 1973, Chuck Jones wrote and directed a short animated version of "The Cricket In Times Square" with Mel Blanc cast as the voice of Tucker Mouse......someone needs to do there research...!!!
"Stuart Little" was the worse...THE WORSE adadaptation of a book to screen!! I put it at the top of my "Worst Films of 1999" list!
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 2:25AM
Elisabeth said...
And someone needs to brush up on their reading comprehension. I mentioned the ones that had been made into movies in the *opening paragraph* (as well as throughout the post!) and suggested they be *remade* for the new generation.
Bunnicula did not come up on IMDB, but now that I know it was an ABC Special (and inaccurate to the book) my point still stands.
4-30-2008 @ 1:31AM
CG Jung said...
I was a rampant Beverly Cleary fan as a kid. I loved the Mouse and the Motorcylce as well as its sequels, Runaway Ralph and Ralph S. Mouse to death. I'm more fond of her henry and Ribsy series though, as nothing is as touching as a boy and his dog.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 2:20AM
Brian Jacks said...
I'm really surprised The Boxcar Children hasn't gotten the theatrical treatment. If it has and I don't know about it, then I'd still wonder why it hasn't gotten a reboot.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 7:22AM
Chelsea said...
There was a Boxcar Children movie made in the 1960s, with Jenny Agutter as the lead character, as well as a more recent film. A while ago, Allison Anders was rumored to be adapting the books, but nothing came of it...
4-30-2008 @ 6:50AM
DarkAgair said...
Tails of a Forth Grade Nothing, Superfudge, and Fudgeamania would make a great triliogy for the kids
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 9:55AM
Ian said...
I'd love to see the Mouse and the Motorcycle redone properly. It completely captivated me as a kid.
Also, No Coins, Please (although would a story about 6 kids in a van with 2 teenage counsellors really fly in today's society?), and any of the Bugs Potter, or Macdonald Hall series. Ok, anything by Gordon Korman really.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 11:38AM
Claire said...
oh God the boxcar children. i read them all. my favorite was violet, i tried to play violin because of her. it would be great turned into a movie but it would have to be updated a bit. gender roles have changed after all.
i agree with the black cauldron as well. it could be just like harry potter, which is good or bad depending on your view of the craze.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 11:40AM
Max Elliot Anderson said...
Hi. I've been contacted by a film production company to possibly make one of my books into a dramatic, theatrical film.
I grew up as a reluctant reader. Now I write action-adventures & mysteries, especially for boys 8 and up, that kids hate to put down. My web site is at http://www.maxbooks.9k.com and my Books for Boys blog is at http://booksandboys.blogspot.com
Ranked by Accelerated Reader
Max Elliot Anderson
Reply