Review: Star Wars: The Clone Wars
Filed under: Action, Animation, New Releases, Theatrical Reviews, Fandom, George Lucas, Remakes and Sequels
.jpg)
If Star Wars: The Clone Wars were a simple board game stacked up in a toy store aisle, the side of the box would read: "Ages 7 through Check Your Star Wars Ego at the Door." While the recent onslaught of superhero movies have brought us darker, more complex (and adult) storylines, one of our most beloved franchises has decided to travel in the opposite direction. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing; it's actually somewhat comforting to find a film with the word 'Wars' mentioned twice in the title alone and know that it's suitable for all ages. When I first watched a Star Wars film on the big screen, my feet could barely touch the sticky theater floor -- and so if a fun-filled, action-packed animated adventure story helps usher in a whole new legion of fans -- subsequently turning younger kids on to three live-action movies that came out, like, a billion years ago -- then right friggin' on!
Almost immediately we're clued into the fact that this big-screen Star Wars flick was gift-wrapped by another department store. That classic, drum-hoppin' 20th Century Fox intro is replaced with a much more subdued Warner Bros. logo, and the film's title swings into frame accompanied by different music. In replace of the classic story scroll, we get a newsreel-esque voiceover bringing us up to date on the main characters and their current mission. No one's trying to trick us here -- this is Star Wars for the need-it-now generation, and whereas previous films seemed to spend too much time rolling around in political-speak, Clone Wars is all about the action, the battles and the cheesy one-liners.
Following the battle of Geonosis at the end of Attack of the Clones, the Jedi (and their army of clone warriors) are engaged in a full on galaxy-wide battle against the Separatists (and their massive droid army), lead by the evil Count Dooku (Christopher Lee reprising his role from the prequels). Anakin Skywalker's (Matt Lanter) been asked to take on a young Padawan learner named Ahsoka Tana to mentor and train, while he and Obi-Wan Kenobi (James Arnold Taylor) continue to assist the clone army. Our story picks up when Jabba the Hutt's infant son is kidnapped, forcing Chancellor Palpatine (Ian Abercrombie), Yoda and Mace Windu (Samuel L. Jackson reprising his role from the prequels) to step in and help the seedy, slimy crime lord in order to obtain a safe passage through Jabba's territory moving forward.
Thus, Anakin and Ahsoka are sent to find the smelly baby slug to maintain good relations with the fat fella, while Obi-Wan goes off to fight more droids. Ah, but problems arise when Dooku and his fiery bald mistress/assistant Asajj Ventress show up to mislead Jabba and make him think the Jedi stole his baby with plans to kill it. Can Anakin and Ahsoka find the little bugger and return him safely before Dooku and Asajj can tarnish their name forever?
With Jabba the Hutt using language like "punky muffin" (everyone has a nickname in this flick), a kinda sorta girlfriend for R2D2 and the introduction of Jabba's Truman Capote-sounding, pimped-out purple feather-wearing uncle Ziro the Hutt, it's fairly obvious the film's creators are looking to have some PG-rated fun. This is the Saturday Morning Cartoon version of Star Wars, and longtime fans looking for more rain clouds and strong, revealing monologues are not going to find it here. But what director Dave Filoni and his crew bring to this film are some highly enjoyable action sequences, with battles taking place on the side of a mountain, through the darkened, disheveled streets of a fallen city and on the familiar desert sand of the planet Tattooine.
Sure, you've got lots of lasers going back and forth, however Filoni intercuts the traditional wide-angle fighting with some nice POV and OTS shots, giving the audience a chance to see what it feels like to run into battle with a group of clones. That said, when the characters aren't jumping, flipping or swinging through the air, they do come off as somewhat stiff, fake and unnatural. This was especially the case early on with scenes featuring Obi-Wan. That's not to say they don't look good; for example, Padmé Amidala looked exactly like Natalie Portman, even though her character was underused. (Good news is there's no mushy romantic subplot between Anakin and Padmé here at all.)
But that's another great aspect -- The Clone Wars, this movie, is simply a launching pad for an entire television series. So characters and storylines that could use a little more development will get their chance when the series debuts later this fall on Cartoon Network and TNT. With that in mind, Filoni was allowed to play it loose and have some fun without having to tie up every this and that. The Clone Wars is nothing but an introduction to a storybook full of those in-between-episodes characters, and if you keep the cynical, jaded, "Lucas screwed up everything!" Star Wars fanatic part of your personality away from this particular piece of entertainment, you might find some real enjoyment out of playing in this comfortable galactic sandbox with some new faces and a lot of imagination.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-15-2008 @ 1:26AM
V.M.L. said...
I knew that this movie was actually a TV pilot. I'm worried that most people don't know that and think its an actual movie.
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 3:50AM
eugene said...
Thanks for clarifying that this is a tv pilot, i was one of those people who thought it was a stand alone movie... I'll wait for it to come to TV.
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 6:32AM
ron said...
well this is a TV pilot, doesnt MEAN it will be shown on the TV! its goona be out of DVD and stuff, this is the theatrical first part of the TV series, so it can come out with a bang!
8-15-2008 @ 8:41AM
Peter Hall said...
"..it's actually somewhat comforting to find a film with the word 'Wars' mentioned twice in the title alone and know that it's suitable for all ages."
I haven't seen Clone Wars, so I can't speak as to the handling of the consequences of war within. However, it is an odd prospect to me given the current global climate, that one can or should take comfort in a film that makes War suitable for all ages. War should not be suitable for all ages. Never should, unless the story is a clear, heartfelt parable between a fantasy universe and its tangible counterpoint in reality.
I'm probably coming off quite pretentious here, but in a time when soldiers are dying on two US war fronts, when Russia is invading a neighboring country, when genocide is still underway in Darfur, why cheapen the implications of a word as strong as War by making it 'suitable'? And why take comfort in that?
I'm not trying to say kids should be glued to episodes of Generation Kill over episodes of Star Wars. Let the new brood have their intergalactic eye candy imaginations fed like we all had as children (I wouldn't have it any other way). I just find it odd that an adult would specifically point out a comfort found in a kids movie softening War.
Reply
10-25-2009 @ 1:13AM
Kevin said...
I totally agree...you do sound pretentious. The movie is about a galaxy far far away, you really think kids are going to look at it and think thats what the war in Iraq is? And if they do, whats the big deal? If they're not old enough to understand the distinction than they aren't old enough for that lack of understanding to have any negative consequences. Its called science Fiction for a reason. Why can't kids, or adults for that matter, enjoy action packed sequences that show war in a less realistic, more entertaining fashion? We go to the movies to be distracted from the outside world, but I think most people are mature enough to realize that its merely that; a distraction, not a reflection. However, if some kid sees this movie and goes on to attack City Hall with his lightsaber and and gigantic st bernard named Chewbacca because he thinks he's going after the Empire than I will totally agree with you that these movies are disgusting.
8-15-2008 @ 10:04AM
Peter Hall said...
Man, it must be nice to agree with me on things I never said, like this movie being disgusting or that kids shouldn't enjoy an intergalactic space adventure.
I took odds with Erik's word choice that its comforting to see what is essentially a kids movie sport a title twice touting War. I just don't see what the comfort there is.
I'm also not a person who turns to movies as a distraction from the outside world. I like the outside world. I like it quite a bit. And I like going to the movies to see what the artists who live in that very world do with their time in it. Maybe I'm weird like that.
8-15-2008 @ 10:24AM
Erik Davis said...
Peter, I meant it in the context that some of our more beloved franchises are all being re-imagined lately with adult themes, characters and language, so it's comforting to see Star Wars doing the opposite in order to appeal to a whole new generation.
8-15-2008 @ 10:39AM
Peter Hall said...
Thanks, Erick, now I look like a dick. :P
8-15-2008 @ 10:42AM
Erik Davis said...
No way dude, I totally "got" what you were saying and perhaps I just didn't word it right. Thanks.
8-15-2008 @ 11:10AM
Peter Hall said...
Damn typos. Weblogs Inc. ever going to allow us peons to edit our comments?
8-15-2008 @ 11:24AM
Logan5 said...
Yeah, Erik, eat Pete's dick.
Wait a sec.
What are we discussing again?
Stupid comment board blindness?
What is really annoying is why in any galaxy, far away or not, does Lucas Arts perpetually explore stories about characters whose futures are already determined?
Talk about anti-climatic.
Who gives two shakes about a fancy light saber duel between Dooku and Anakin when we know the outcome has already been determined in a completely different movie made years earlier. There's zero dramatic tension to drive it so basically it'll be like watching a couple of rave kids on ecstasy swinging glow sticks at one another.
WOW. Pretty. AND. Stupid.
Not getting my 8 bucks.
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 3:22PM
LiqwidZero said...
This is actually a re-make of the original TV series that Gendy Tartovsky first made, which was excellent. LucasFilm best not let me down with their re-interpretation of the series.
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 4:34PM
MatthewRex said...
Erik Davis, thank you. Thank you for writing the most sound review of this movie so far. Critics and bloggers are bashing it left and right, and you have written my EXACT feelings.
I think people are overlooking what this movie actually IS.
I for one, enjoyed it. I think people are forgetting that this is three episodes of the television series stitched together. Yes- it has pacing issues, but that's because it wasn't developed as a feature.
The animation is a little rough around the edges, yes. But who here remembers The Simpsons season 1? Or South Park season 1? If you remember correctly, in time, both shows evolved and looked much better a few seasons down the line. The Clone Wars will be exactly like that. I think people are forgetting that this is essentially a "pilot" for the series. A pilot for SEASON ONE of a television show that will have a healthy life and grow & evolve like all other television shows.
Give it time, give it some room to breathe. This film convinced me that there's a LOT of potential and a LOT of promise for a weekly show. A LOT.
And yes, some character choices are annoying, but that's just Lucas. I doubt they'll be as annoying when they're presented in 30min weekly chunks.
Asoka has a lot of potential to be a fun character. And I can't wait to find out down the line that Anakin cuts her down in the Temple raid in EPIII. :-)
Thanks for writing a great revew Erik!
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 8:17PM
Cray said...
I don't care for the stylized animation, I would've preferred that they made the character designs more life-like. Much like FINAL FANTASY characters were designed. This would've given this movie more credibility to casual Star Wars fans as well as regular film buffs.
Yes, I get that its aimed at kids, but STAR WARS has never had to make itself cutesy to appeal the younger generation. There's a universal appeal to STAR WARS much like Disney movies.
I'll probably rent this when it comes to DVD.
Reply
8-16-2008 @ 3:44AM
Dewb said...
It's so-so!!
Reply
8-17-2008 @ 2:45AM
The Couch Critic said...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e1-f08kXn6c
This commentary cloakes as a "Star Wars" crawl says it all.
Star Wars and George Lucas have (long ago) gone to the DARK SIDE. Darth Lucas and his films are MORE MACHINE than MAN. Now, completely digital, the franchise itself has fulfilled its own prophetic warning: do not fall prey to ego, arrogance, self-centered-ness, or GREED.. Behold, the Star Wars Marketing Empire. "All Hope is Los
Reply
8-17-2008 @ 9:35AM
lainix said...
i took my 2 nephews to go see this on friday afternoon. i was extremely disappointed. wether it was a stepping stone for a tv series, they coul dhave done mor ewith it. i was struggling to stay awake during the movie. the boys liked it, so i guess they are leaving the old schoolers behind to drain th eallowances of the younger people. i guess the studios forgot who their real paychecks come from..
Reply
8-18-2008 @ 7:31AM
CinemaMad said...
Lucas does seem to have lost his way. There is none of the originality of the middle trilogy. He's got disctracted from telling a good story by all the special effects and technology which was the case with episodes 1 through 3 as well. Still, it's more Star Wars and I still went and watched it.
-------
This post has been shared on http://www.CinemaMad.com
Reply
8-19-2008 @ 8:05PM
Valerie Atherton said...
Hey Star Wars fans,
I just wrote my second review EVER and wrote it about the Clone Wars cartoon. Hope you can check it out!
V
http://valeriewriter.wordpress.com/
Reply