Is 'Hari Puttar' Too Close to 'Harry Potter'? Warner Bros. Thinks So
Filed under: Warner Brothers, Celebrities and Controversy, Movie Marketing
Movie studios are big on protecting their intellectual property, which is certainly understandable -- but sometimes they come down too hard. Take this new case. Warner Bros. is suing to stop the Indian release of a domestic film called Hari Puttar: A Comedy of Terrors. Why? Because Hari Puttar is close to Harry Potter, obviously, and Warners damn well owns the film rights to Harry Potter. Sounds fair enough -- except that the movie has nothing to do with Harry Potter, and doesn't even appear to be an attempt to capitalize on the Potter brand name. As best I can determine, "Hari Puttar" is the endearing nickname of a 10 year-old character named Hari Prasad Dhoonda. The movie itself appears to be an action-adventure fantasy, about a resourceful kid who saves his dad's top secret computer chip from some burglars -- sort of like a modern, Indian Home Alone. The title references Harry Potter, but there's no theft here; the closest parallel is Son of Rambow, which managed to avoid a lawsuit (reportedly by adding the "w" to the end of "Rambo").
Warners, of course, has to fight this battle in Indian courts, so it's hard to predict what's going to happen. But Harry Potter is such a prominent part of the zeitgeist all over the world, that the company may have a lot of battles on its hands if it chooses to go after every incident such as this.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-24-2008 @ 3:30AM
tina said...
I can't believe this! Term Harri Puttar is very popular in India. Hari is a popular pet name and Puttar (which means son) is used in the same way people use honey, buddy, sweety etc. in the United States. Infact, every Hindi-speaking household uses Puttar to endearingly address the children (both young and grownup). I doubt any judge will side with the Warners. You can almost bet that the judge probably know a couple of Hari Puttars himself. lol.
Reply
8-24-2008 @ 4:20AM
Mark H Wilkinson said...
I wish journalists would learn to tell the difference between copyright and trademark law.
Reply
8-25-2008 @ 12:38AM
smartsingh said...
if Warner Bros. is really looking for a lawsuit they should check Abra Ka Dabra. Good god, that was an entire rip off of HP. Very little in Bollywood is original, there's copying everywhere, and it's been established since the early days, when they would groom their stars to look exactly like hollywood stars. All that ever happens is that they add in some singing, really bad camera work, and double a movie's length.
Reply
8-25-2008 @ 4:42AM
Shemp DeYoung said...
After watching the trailer to this movie on YouTube, I'm thinking that the inspiration was much more "Home Alone" than anything having to do with our favorite wizard in the little round glasses.
Reply
9-01-2008 @ 5:03AM
akshay said...
WB are gonna lose this case. Its stupid and greedy of them to sue this film. Besides atleast this little film got publicity!
Reply