The Geek Beat: Maybe Superheroes Can Break Glass Ceilings
Filed under: Fandom, Comic/Superhero/Geek, The Geek Beat

With the DNC (three cheers for my hosting hometown, by the way!), holiday weekends, and hurricanes, there's not much to spin a column out of this week. I spent my holiday overdosing on back issues of Wolverine and Warren Ellis' Astonishing X-Men because oh happy day, I have a comic slot again! My supply line has been cut off for the last year, and as I refuse to pay anyone (even independent publishers) $6.00 to ship a single issue, I've lived in a drought.
In the midst of all this overdosing, I stumbled across this charming article by Brad Meltzer about why he loves Superman. Immediately I thought about what I would answer if posed a similar question by USA Weekend, and realized to my horror that I lacked such a lifelong bond. Everyone knows my favorite hero is the one with the admantium skeleton, but I can't pretend that he's been a lifelong love affair. Why, I never really had a superhero in my childhood. Why not?
In the midst of all this overdosing, I stumbled across this charming article by Brad Meltzer about why he loves Superman. Immediately I thought about what I would answer if posed a similar question by USA Weekend, and realized to my horror that I lacked such a lifelong bond. Everyone knows my favorite hero is the one with the admantium skeleton, but I can't pretend that he's been a lifelong love affair. Why, I never really had a superhero in my childhood. Why not?
I blame all this talk of Vice Presidents, political conventions, and glass ceilings because I immediately thought, why, it's because I was a girl! I wasn't encouraged to read comics! But, that's not entirely true. I was clueless about the world of comics, yes. My contact with the characters was via cartoons and movies – and while I vaguely knew that there were comics associated with those properties, it never occurred to me to look for them. (Oh, you lucky kids that are growing up with the Internet, Wikipedia, and eBay.) Also, my lack of a childhood hero stems from being a fickle lass, who was fixated on Batman, Catwoman, Storm, and Gambit in turn. The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and Star Wars took their turn as well – actually, I was obsessing about Star Wars when no one on my street even remembered who Luke Skywalker was. I was so uncool. Would I have been cooler if I had been reading Wolverine's Madripoor adventures at 11? Maybe. Would I have been derided for possessing them? Most certainly.
Because there's no doubt that girls aren't encouraged to read comic books or see comic book movies. It's why I spill a lot of ink discussing geek girls and superheroines, and why I will spill much more, because someone has to. I want a little girl to get so into Superman that she chooses a comic book over a life-saving Yoo-Hoo, as Meltzer did. I know there's a few out there already (Meltzer's infant daughter is being raised wearing the same Superman cape as his son was), but there needs to be more. We shouldn't be the feature of sniggering editorials or shocked surprise when we're in line for The Dark Knight. For that matter, my fellow women shouldn't be looking down their nose at this genre – if you don't like comics, that's fine, but don't sneer at the discussion of it and its movies as "unfeminine" or "fanboy oriented."
And don't say it's all a load of sexism, either. I continue to be of the opinion that Hollywood and the popular media lags behind the comic book industry, who may indulge in tight uniforms and huge breasts, but is writing more girl-friendly material than Hollywood is. (And yes, that is a rather sad thought.) I was very surprised and touched when I read one of this week's impulse buys -- #6 of Wolverine: First Class. This series needs to be given freely to young girls! Not only is it co-starring Kitty Pryde, the most refreshingly normal X-Girls ever put to paper, but it's cute and funny, without skimping on toughness and SNIKT action. It's also way more empowering than any girl-oriented movie, television show, magazine, or book that I've seen in ages. I never thought I would see the day when Wolverine was more sensitive to self-esteem issues than Teen Cosmo. (Actually, it's more of a surprise that Wolverine knows what self-esteem is than Teen Cosmo sucks – everyone knows chick magazines are just peddling misogyny, but who knew Weapon X was so sensitive?)
I don't believe girls need to be pandered to – I don't think anything you write or film for them has to be about crushes on boys, make-overs, and parties. I firmly believe that the same essential things that appeal and entertain a young boy appeals to a young girl, but girls still are coddled into a Victorian mindset that action and adventure aren't appropriate and feminine. That's why you aren't going to see Wolverine: First Class waved at any girls, even if the only thing separating it from The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants is the mutant gene. (I'm very curious what its male readers make of it – because if they are digging this series, it further proves my point.)
So, buy your daughters (and sons) an issue of Wolverine: First Class, and while they're reading it, go clamor on the Internet. Demand less Hannah Montana and more Kitty Pryde in your movies. (Incidentally, my new impossible wish is for Hugh Jackman and Ellen Page to do an X-movie together.) Because if we really want to shatter that glass ceiling, it isn't going to be entirely through political conventions -- it has to be a revolution in our very pop culture. We have to give girls heroes that will stick with them for life, be their shoulder to lean on, the imaginary bodyguard who silently helps them survive. And we don't have to reinvent the wheel – these heroes have existed for decades. There's nothing wrong with believing a man can fly – girls just have to know there's nothing stopping them from flying right there with him.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-02-2008 @ 1:24PM
Julie said...
YES! Shatter that glass ceiling, or at least give it some good cracks. Now that I've read Watchman, We 3, and have The Stand being put into your comic slot for me, am I forgiven for not taken you to comic book stores as often as I did the library? -mom
Reply
9-02-2008 @ 1:38PM
BondsBabe said...
I grew up reading my male cousin's old back issues of G.I. Joe and collecting my own Star Trek comic books before graduating to rock and roll comics and underground stuff. I got so fed up with not seeing something I enjoyed throughly ( only Love and Rockets came close to satisfying the comic book itch.) I drew my own stuff.
A fellow artist is doing his own book and he asked me for input as a gal/artist and comic book fan. He wants to appeal to all of sort so fans especially the girls who he feels don't get much to read. So he asked me what sort of costumes to design and things like that.
Reply
9-02-2008 @ 11:16PM
Hughman Bein said...
I might pick one up. Logan is an awesome "Dad" role in comics. He's the "Lone Wolf" to many cubs. There is still a bunch of work to be done in pop entertainment, but I'm glad that you note the comics field is definitely helping inspire kids in aspects they don't normally see done in other genres like Disney or Teen Cosmo. I was definitely attached to comics early on because there is a sense of morality to them that is nicely interwoven in adventure and imagination. They are surely the new mythology for our new populus.
Reply
9-02-2008 @ 4:16PM
Moo said...
No kids for me yet,. but rest assured I am already paving the way for my niece!! She's almost 2, so I am not sure if she gets me yet when I explain the Marvel Civil War storyline to her (can you blame her, really?) but I'm working on it!!
Reply
9-02-2008 @ 5:23PM
mezzanine said...
I think it's getting harder for kids in general to get into comics, all they have are the movies. I can't even tell you where my closest comic store is, I have to wait for everything to be collected in a graphic novel and order by Amazon. Video games seem to be taking over. The only reason I love Batman so much is from the 90s Batman films.
Reply
9-03-2008 @ 2:27AM
V.M.L. said...
*gives a standing ovation*
I stopped reading TEEN COSMO and every other girly magazine because I could no longer relate to them. In fact, I never had!
I love my action, adventure, violence, WATCHMEN, and Robert Downey Jr. as Iron Man. I hate how Hollywood ignores the fact that there's girls who like "man flicks." Hell, I want to make adventure movies! I'm a student filmmaker!
Reply
9-03-2008 @ 11:09AM
Petro1734 said...
Mama Petro always said the hardest thing to be in this world is a woman with OTHER ideas.
Good fucking column.
Reply
11-20-2008 @ 10:05AM
Sara said...
I know I am a bit late here but this article is so fucking awesome that I HAD to express my appreciation for the writer. I whole-heartedly agree about young girls being encouraged to prefer Barbie/cutesy chick-flicks about make-overs and pursuing cute boys and the like even though action/adventure/independance naturally appeals to them(most of them anyway) as much as it does to young boys. And I especially agree about true revolution coming in the form of the powerful tool that is pop-culture. I am proud to have been a kid growing up in the 90s' because I had cool heroines like Buffy and Xena to look up to. Plus, women and little girls were more feminist-inclined in the 90s' with every kindergartener's dream of becoming the first woman President. I don't know what happened to that trend in the Bush years. It diminshed to a great extent. Not that the extensive media coverage of the Idiot Trinity(Britney, Paris, Lindsay) and their ilk helped in providing role models for little girls in this decade.
Reply