Geek Daily: Who's Not Playing Whom
by Elisabeth Rappe Sep 17th 2008 // 4:03PM

It's a quiet day on the news front -- mostly casting rumors shot down before I even had a chance to hear them. Now I get to do the same to you, readers!
- Will Smith is, for the last time, not playing Captain America. Rumors of Smith playing Cap were everywhere (including here) and it wasn't as crazy as it seemed. The first Captain America was African-American, after all, and the clunky title The First Avenger: Captain America could suggest they would honor that mythology. But they're not -- not only did Ain't It Cool News debunk it earlier this month, but Smith has confirmed it. In fact, he told MTV he hadn't even heard the rumor.
- David Boreanaz is not the Green Lantern. Rumors flew that he was in consideration, as his face was used in the concept art, but as Hal Jordan is 27 and Boreanaz is in his late 30's, he's believed to be too old. (So that happens to actors as well as actresses? Good to know.) Latino Review has a script review up -- I'll refrain from posting anything here as it's kind of spoilerish but in short, they love it. For those avoiding the spoilers of LR, I'll leave you with a quote from The Pulse's chat with the film's writer Marc Guggenheim. He was fresh off the rewrite, and promises that it's "an incredibly faithful rendition of the character."
- Brett Ratner says he was once part of the J.J. Abrams Superman -- and tells MTV that he'd like a crack at the Warner Bros reboot, especially if they are really going for a dark and edgy take. Will the film unexpectedly switch from day to night halfway through to illustrate this darkness?
- A Paramount preview in London let fans peek at GI Joe and Star Trek. The former was iffy, with the action being stylized, typical of Stephen Sommers, and complaints of the character development being "terrible." What was seen of Trek suggested "immense fun." I am chomping at the bit to see some footage of that flick -- and despite having once worn a Star Trek: The Next Generation uniform, I am the furthest thing you can find from a Trekkie.
Sparse offerings indeed, readers. What will we talk about? How about arguing whether or not Boreanaz has enough of a baby face to play Hal Jordan? Or how you knew G.I. Joe wouldn't be very good? Fire away!
Tags: Brett Ratner, BrettRatner, Captain America, CaptainAmerica, david boreanaz, DavidBoreanaz, featured, G.I. Joe, G.i.Joe, Green Lantern, GreenLantern, Mark Guggenheim, MarkGuggenheim, Star Trek, StarTrek, Will Smith, WillSmith
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-17-2008 @ 4:49PM
Cincinnati Mike said...
Speaking of Trek, any geeks know when WE will get a chance to see that preview?
Reply
9-17-2008 @ 6:20PM
Elisabeth said...
I heard rumors of a trailer in December -- but I have no idea if they will come true. The secrecy is driving me nuts.
9-17-2008 @ 6:49PM
carg0 said...
i read that a new trailer for Star Trek was being cut to screen before 'The Day the Earth Stood Still' when it's released this Dec.
9-17-2008 @ 5:28PM
Cannen said...
Elisabeth,
I'm not really a follower of the Marvel universe, although I did watch all the cartoons when I was a kid and do enjoy the movies. But, when the post talking about the possible casting of Will Smith as Captain American came out, I went to Marvel's website and looked him up. It seems that the first Captain America wasn't black at all.
Read the linked page. The important stuff starts in the 5th paragraph.
http://www.marvel.com/universe/Bradley,_Isaiah
Reply
9-17-2008 @ 6:20PM
Elisabeth said...
And last week, we had everyone screaming the first Cap WAS Isaiah -- and I thought they were right, that was what I remembered from that series...gotta give Marvel props, there's one character they did manage to keep the continuity on!
My bad...
9-17-2008 @ 5:33PM
Kurt said...
Subtle X-3 jab there duly noted. Day to night, indeed. Someone needs to punch that man in the jewels.
Reply
9-17-2008 @ 5:54PM
joits said...
if warner bros thinks ratner can do a better job than singer for the reboot of superman, they just have to look at xmen 3, it made a ton of money but pretty much sucked. ratner doing the next superman would be the worst thing the franchise could do.
Reply
9-17-2008 @ 7:15PM
Mostskillz said...
Please don't let Bret Ratner touch Superman...Please! Please! Please! We don't need another X-men: The Last Stand. Let's make that the ONLY comic franchise Ratner F's up.
Reply
9-17-2008 @ 7:08PM
Cincinnati Mike said...
Thanks for the update, guys.
Day the Earth Stood Still had my phaser set to "meh." But that five minute preview the other night was...not terrible.
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 11:43AM
Jennifer said...
Showing my intense nerdiness, if you wore a TNG (and on) costume b/c u were a fan you're a Trekker, not a Trekkie. There is a difference. Trust me.
Brett Ratner can fall off the face of the Earth as far as I'm concerned, but being as what he had to work with from the previous FUBARed Singer XMen movies, I'd say he didn't do half bad, especially killing Cyclops. That was TOTALLY AWESOME!!!!
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 8:29PM
Hughman Bein said...
I love how the pain of xmen 3 has still not left us and through bare mention dominates these comments. Singer was way better and I will always lament that I didn't get the chance to see Sigourney Weaver blonde and in white negligee. I only needed one thing to make even Ratner's version great and that was absolute destruction because of a giant firebird and I never got it. G.I. Joe will probably be Street Fighter 2! Borneaz would be fine with me and would lend some comedy to an otherwise boring dc icon.
Reply