Fan Rant: Wrong Soundtrack for the Wrong Trailer
Filed under: Drama, Universal, Fandom, Movie Marketing, Trailers and Clips

Hollywood, please. Leave The Fountain's soundtrack alone!
Somehow, in the course of my writing, I neglected to ever watch the Frost/Nixon trailer, something now rectified thanks to it being attached to Australia. I was into it right up until a familiar theme started playing ... and then I just felt an inexplicable disgust. I wondered what, exactly, Ron Howard (or whoever at Universal put together the trailer) was thinking. Why on earth would you use The Fountain for that movie? What about the music is appropriate for the mood and story you're trying to convey? (A similar problem plagues Mansell's Lux Aeterna piece from Requiem for a Dream -- for every trailer that uses it beautifully, like The Two Towers, there's one that just cheeses it up, like Babylon A.D.)
I confess, I have a weird, protective feeling towards this soundtrack. It's one of my favorite films and scores, one I listen to constantly. I'm convinced that even if you didn't see the film, or hated it, Clint Mansell's score is music enough to stand on its own -- something few soundtracks really are. Honestly, if you don't own it, put it on your Christmas list -- you won't regret it.
Somehow, in the course of my writing, I neglected to ever watch the Frost/Nixon trailer, something now rectified thanks to it being attached to Australia. I was into it right up until a familiar theme started playing ... and then I just felt an inexplicable disgust. I wondered what, exactly, Ron Howard (or whoever at Universal put together the trailer) was thinking. Why on earth would you use The Fountain for that movie? What about the music is appropriate for the mood and story you're trying to convey? (A similar problem plagues Mansell's Lux Aeterna piece from Requiem for a Dream -- for every trailer that uses it beautifully, like The Two Towers, there's one that just cheeses it up, like Babylon A.D.)
I confess, I have a weird, protective feeling towards this soundtrack. It's one of my favorite films and scores, one I listen to constantly. I'm convinced that even if you didn't see the film, or hated it, Clint Mansell's score is music enough to stand on its own -- something few soundtracks really are. Honestly, if you don't own it, put it on your Christmas list -- you won't regret it.
Now, despite my over-attachment to it, it doesn't bother me to hear The Fountain on a trailer -- too few people saw the movie, and if hearing the music gets people to check the film or Mansell's score out, that's fine by me. But it has to be used well. Blade Runner: The Final Cut used it beautifully, for example, and it was an eerily appropriate choice, thematically. But Frost/Nixon? Come on. I'd give it a pass if they used one of the quieter pieces, which would be wholly appropriate to the trailer. But they use the full blown, romantic, "Death is the road to awe / together we will live forever" theme, which doesn't evoke anything about David Frost, Richard Nixon, journalism, or Watergate. It's quite jarring, and I imagine it is even to those unfamiliar with the music, particularly since it drowns out the dialogue -- something you don't want to do with a film like this.
And that's just it -- so much hinges on a film's trailer, and the music you choose is just as important as the clips you put together. If you picked a piece just because you liked it, and slapped it on regardless of whether it's suitable, that looks sloppy to this audience member. Surely, I'm not the only one?










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-29-2008 @ 1:44PM
Kurt Munro said...
Seems to fit perfectly to me.
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 4:26PM
viewdrix said...
And as someone who didn't know the music was from The Fountain, it worked perfectly when I watched the trailer months ago, and still does now.
Would you be making this post about the music being supposedly too loud even if it wasn't from a soundtrack you self-admittedly are protective over?
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 1:47PM
RufiOh said...
I hold this soundtrack as sacred and near and dear to my heart as well, I totally agree with you.
Just a poor choice, they'll pay for it.
Mansell still gets his paycheck at the end of the day, which he deserves, although I wonder how he feels about the context in which it was used.. so ill advised.
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 4:25PM
jmg_nx21 said...
My bro knows your feeling... I am fighting it though.
WTH, are they doing using Koyaanisqatsi for the newest Watchmen trailer? HUH?
I tried to argue my point of some parallel between Reggio / Koya / and the Watchmen... but then I realized I became on apologist... what could even come close to the mastery of the soundtrack and that movie's masterpiece?
The Watchmen?
THe Graphic Novel is multi-layered and complex... I can only hope the movie is but a percentage of that...
BTW, Mansell's music is beautiful... get the CD's... but even better go see the Kronos quartet perform the suites of the soundtracks... WOW... wow...
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 4:16PM
Jon said...
Elisabeth,
I'm glad this is one of your favorite movies, as it's near and dear to my heart as well. It seems like maybe only people who've experienced the death of a very close loved one can truly appreciate the spirit of The Fountain...that said, at least they didn't use Clint's beautiful score for Four Christmases! (or whatever that Reese Witherspoon dreck is called!)...
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 4:50PM
Jason H said...
Nothing new for Clint Mansell's stuff. Requiem for a Dream's score was used in all sorts of other films (Requiem for the Two Towers, anyone?)
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 5:08PM
Andrew said...
I saw the movie once when it came out, after being impressed with Aronofsky's other films. I thought it was good, far from great. But one thing I remember distinctly hating about the Fountain was the music playing during the film, this coming from someone who owns the RfaD soundtrack. Now I don't actually own the soundtrack, so maybe I'm completely off on this one and I need to listen again. But I'm not trying to troll or anything. I specifically told people that the movie was ok, but the music was horrible.
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 5:56PM
Michael Byng said...
I didnt like The Fountain....I loved the score...and I love the Frost/Nixon trailer.
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 9:37PM
Rufus said...
THANK YOU!
I noticed this too. I watched the trailer with my wife via Apple and the first thing I said was how weird it sounded that they had The Fountain OST playing over it.
I forgot all about that, but it's good to see someone else thought that too. I'm sure they did The Fountain on another trailer too, maybe with Will Smith.
- and the amount of times I've heard The Matrix playing over something, eh.
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 9:45PM
William Goss said...
I've heard the same sample on the trailer for The Spirit. Ick.
Reply
11-29-2008 @ 10:43PM
Christopher said...
What's the big deal?
I like THE FOUNTAIN as well, although I found the Clint Mansell's score a little underwhelming...on the whole. Nothing to get all up in arms about. There are lots of trailers that do much much worse.
I think it works well enough in the trailer and once you see the film and hear Hans Zimmer's score in it, you might find some very general commonalities between the two.
Reply
11-30-2008 @ 8:18AM
The Mutt said...
I know I've heard the main theme from Stripes in at least a dozen trailers.
Reply
11-30-2008 @ 1:28AM
monstermac said...
I dunno. It's still ' Frost/Nixon'.
Reply
11-30-2008 @ 1:37AM
shadowracer said...
You guys are going to flame me. Best use of Lux Aeterna goes to Lil' Jon and the Eastside boys.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nI1NeMwiSfo
It doesn't sound bad with that digital snare thrown in.
Reply
11-30-2008 @ 6:18AM
glyn said...
hmmm. This whole protectiveness of the sound track i kind of understand.
However i am still adapting to the fact that Clint Mansell, lead singer of one of my favourite bands whilst growing up. PWEI or Pop Will Eat Itself has some how gone and got him a grown up job.
Now i know how all those Oingo Boing fans felt when they had to share Danny Elfman... ;-)
11-30-2008 @ 6:31AM
glyn said...
oh, and having seen Frost/Nixon at the LFF - you really should see it, regardless of who is doing the music in the trailer...
Reply
11-30-2008 @ 2:12PM
Chuck said...
The damn thing happen to one of my favorite films Terrence Malicks "The Thin Red Line" with the Michael Bay's "Pearl Harbor". They used the same Han Zimmer soundtrack on Pearl Harbor. . It was the main real reason I skipped the seeing it.
Reply
12-01-2008 @ 8:14AM
Chromey said...
So there are people here that won't see a movie because they like the trailer music too much? That's lame.
Reply