Oprah Gets Taken By Another Phony Memoir -- Feature Film Plans Scrapped?

The story might be wonderful, but if you call it TRUE and you're lying, then that's really tacky.

Exponentially so if it's a story about concentration camps.

Reply

We already suffered through Life is Beautiful. Did we really need another whimsical feel-good love story about the Holocaust? It's like watching Alain Resnais' Night and Fog scored with Celine Dion's My Heart Will Go On.

Reply

Hi, good post.

If you care to blog about this press release, following, below, please do, pro or con. It is online now at ijcm101.blogspot,com

RE:

Asking Oprah to invite Herman Rosenblat on her show one more time to apologize for his literary fabrication, explain why he did it, ask forgiveness

I am creating a national write-in campaign here with a grassroots effort to ask Oprah to invite Herman on her show in future to apologzie, ask forgiveness, explain why he did and how and ... to move on with his life quietly and out of the spotlight.

I have already been in touch with Oprah's producers and there is a good chance this might happen. Oprah will not attack Herman on air the way she did with James Frey after his deceptions were uncovered. In this case, she will allow Herman to answer to the public, explain himself, apologize and ask forgiveness, from Oprah and the public, for his literary faux pas.

PLEASE leave your comments below. You may frame them as a letter to Oprah, which her producers in Chicago will read online here, and you can make your voice heard about asking Oprah to invite Herman on her show one last time to explain himself, to apologize to Oprah and the public, to ask forgiveness and to move on with this life from the point onward. We believe that he is a good man, and that he just made a wrong decision by sticking with his made-up story for so long. Now that the fabrication has been exposed by the media and his book cancelled, it is time for Oprah to invite him on her show and let him explain himself to her and to the public. I think there will be a teaching moment here for everyone, for Oprah too, for Herman, too, and for the viewing public.

I am in touch with Oprah's producers by email and phone now, and am waiting word on what they will do with this suggestion. There is no group sponsoring this write in campaign, just one lone blogger following his heart.

Reply

that link for the Oprah campaign re Herman is corrected here

http://ijcm101.blogspot.com

If time or space or inclination, do blog on this pro or con, and if need more info, email, you know where to find me: danbloom in the gmail section

Reply

I don't know very much about this story specifically, so I'll answer your question in a more general fashion. I think that a stories truth doesn't necessarily affect whether or not it can be turned into a good movie. However, there are some stories that are so preposterous that the only way I'm going to be able to stomach the plot twists is if they actually happen to be true. Given what you said about this story, I'm not sure if I could buy the whole "saved my sanity as a child in a concentration camp, then randomly had dinner with you later" plot device. If it actually were true than I would be amazed and find it to be a fantastic turn of events, but if its not then it seems like a pretty unbelievable plot contrivance that is just being used so manipulate the audiences emotional response. Its kinda the feeling I had with another, similar holocaust movie earlier this year; boy with the striped pajamas. I won't say anything about the ending other than if it had happened in real life than it would have been tragic, but since it was used by the filmmakers to drive home a point I found it absurd and over the top. Thats just my 2 cents.

Reply

You mean to tell me that Oprah is not a human lie detector? Shocking, how could she be fooled in such a way? Couldn't she just have used her wealth to build a time machine and send one of her lackeys back to check the story out?

C'mon Jessica, what is your own talent level with regards to spotting literary scams? I suppose you knew all along.

Reply

The first scam that went undetected by Oprah was James Frey, am I right? I actually liked his books, so the entire Oprah-being-miffed-at-James business left me cold.

You have to admit that lying about the Holocaust is a ballsy thing to do in the face on an entire nation. So kudos for that, at least.

And on a side note: I fear Oprah. The demi-god status she seems to have acquired in the US over the years is terribly frightening to me. It is unhealthy for a nation to put that much faith in a tv personality. I suppose I will never understand the entire Oprah-phenomenon.

Reply

Oh! Are we going to suffer through another anti-German tear-jerker?

Stop lying, period.

Reply