The Summer of Boycotts
Filed under: Celebrities and Controversy, Fandom, Newsstand, Summer Movies
When you hear the word boycott, your mind probably goes to big moments in history like the Montgomery Bus Boycott in 1955 or President Carter boycotting the Olympics back in 1980; what you probably don't think about are summer blockbusters. Over at The New York Times, Michael Cieply looks at a rare summer season that saw almost all of the big studio releases experience a fan boycott. So even though there are the obvious targets like Angels and Demons; it didn't stop there. Practically all of the big summer releases have earned a spot on a list that included: Terminator (thanks to a very unpopular PG-13 rating), Star Trek (in hopes of a little fund-raising for space exploration), and even Wolverine (and no, not because of the amnesia bullets; instead it was due to the political leanings of one of the film's consultants, Richard Donner).You almost have to wonder why anyone would go to so much trouble? Even though I totally get how a film can inspire protests because of content that a group may find offensive or inappropriate; to me it seems a little extreme to organize online petitions and custom-design logos just because you might have to wait a little longer for the next installment of Harry Potter. But the voice of experience in this debate is New Line's President, Rolf Mittweg, who told the Times, "If you have a group that might speak out against the movie, and they're large enough to affect the box office, you have to do something about it," Mr. Mittweg knows better than anyone the effect a boycott can have on a film's bottom line, having dealt with the backlash for The Golden Compass; saying, the film could have "done 50 percent better in the United States had there been no organized opposition."
After the jump; why movie studios still aren't losing sleep over fan boycotts.
Instead, what most studios are still counting on is that no matter how their angry fans get, they won't be able to keep themselves away come release time. I know I wasn't thrilled when I found out that McG was in charge of a Terminator reboot, but that doesn't mean I won't be there on opening weekend. Think back to 2008 when fans were crying for blood over the delay of Harry Potter and The Half-Blood Prince; a complaint that has lost some heat and Emerson Spartz, the founder of the mugglenet.com, even says that the boycott has, "...completely tapered off," One thing is for sure; I am awfully curious to see how many of the fans who participated in these boycotts stick to their word and stay far away come opening weekend.
Sound off below and tell us if you think movie boycotts really work; and would you be willing to give up the chance to see one of this summer's big releases to make a point?
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
5-09-2009 @ 8:05PM
A.J said...
I can understand most of the boycotts but the Harry Potter one is just too stupid. Don't see a film until much later than you can because you didn't get to see it earlier?
Reply
5-09-2009 @ 11:27PM
MCW said...
The Harry Potter boycott was much more relevant... I guess it was last year it came about? Anyway, I was simply angered that WB, one of the richest corporations in the entire USA, would dare to push back their movie for no other reason than financial.
Now, I understand as much as anyone else that movies are business ventures, but with Harry Potter, you already have a fan base that has followed and grew from one movie to the next. To suddenly say, 'hmm, Twilight's catching steam... I guess we better push back a little bit... maybe a year or two' is disgusting, and lame.
Typing about it brings back some of the vitriol, so I better stop while I'm ahead. I'll just say that I'll never be able to forget what they did (And will likely do again) with the HP franchise by a seemingly small move of pushing a date back. Maybe next time they'll actually bother to read the petitions, and respond in a better way than that Open Letter they did (That further infuriated everyone).
5-10-2009 @ 11:28PM
Tanner said...
Doesn't anybody realize that internet petitions never really work?
Reply
5-11-2009 @ 10:07AM
Kevin said...
Yeah, for the most part these boycotts and petitions are incredibly stupid. MCW, your point about HP is exactly what I'm talking about. The movie industry IS a business. Saying you understand that isn't the same as actually understanding that. WB pumped a hundred million dollars into making HP, they need to release it at a time that will maximize profits. They should've taken a huge risk and released it at a time that could've cost them hundreds of millions of dollars just because you, the fan, wanted to see it as soon as possible? Its a ridiculous notion. The basic laws of economics dictate how movies are made and when they are released, and thats the way it should be. Each tent pole movie is a huge investment, and if it fails than you jeopardize the possible success of even the worlds largest companies. GM is a testament to what happens when successful companies make mistakes and take things for granted. Now, if you have a moral issue with a movie than I can understand it. However, I have yet to hear of a movie being released with a worthy moral explanation for not seeing it (if the star was a pedophile, or wife beater, then okay, I can understand not paying for a ticket). I was disheartened to hear McG was making TS too, but I'm not going to boycott a movie because I think it has the potential to suck, just like I'm not going to go out and buy 100 tickets to a movie because I think it has the potential to be great.
Reply
5-11-2009 @ 1:03PM
ML said...
The HP move wasn't about Twilight, it was about moving profits out of an FY where they already had huge gains into an FY where they had much more risk.
Reply
5-27-2009 @ 1:51PM
Scorpio said...
Internet protests only working if the company you are protesting too actually gives a shit about what people think. Warner Bros only care about money. So we should speak in there language.
Fuck you Warner Bros. I`m not seeing any of your films ever again except maybe Transformers. Boycott HP6 WB Are fags.
Reply