The Geek Beat: It's a Cruel, Cruel Summer
Filed under: The Geek Beat

So this is how May ends -- not with a bang, but a whimper.
It's a tough week to write the Beat. If you're very attentive to my publishing schedule (and I forgive you if you aren't), you might have noticed that last week came and went without an installment. The day you normally find me slaving over a computer for your reading pleasure found me instead avoiding snakes, spiders, and other such swampy critters on the set of Jonah Hex. Of course, I can't say anything more about that. But now you can thank the Powers That Be that nothing poisonous bit me (and oh, how it was a possibility -- if you follow my Twitter, you know exactly what I'm talking about) so that you can hear about it someday.
I mention all that not to brag, but because it's connected to the only two things I can really write about this week. For the first time in my short career, I now find myself in the awkward position that lies between fandom and professionalism. When you read my rantings about Star Trek, Wolverine, comic conventions, Marvel movies, and collectibles, they come purely from my heart. (How mushy!) I still pay to get into every movie I write about. I buy my own action figures, posters and comic books. I receive no swag. No perks. Just some beer money from Cinematical and the comments of my readers. But it's difficult to convince people of that. For one, I'm already in a weird and privileged position of being paid for doing what others happily do for free, and that immediately makes the playing ground uneven and awkward. But now I'm moving into a whole new territory of access. I know that it makes me immediately suspect -- I know this because I immediately suspect anyone who has enjoyed free access, perks and junkets. It's a painful thing to realize that people might stop believing or trusting in me because I'm given a nebulous access.
It's a tough week to write the Beat. If you're very attentive to my publishing schedule (and I forgive you if you aren't), you might have noticed that last week came and went without an installment. The day you normally find me slaving over a computer for your reading pleasure found me instead avoiding snakes, spiders, and other such swampy critters on the set of Jonah Hex. Of course, I can't say anything more about that. But now you can thank the Powers That Be that nothing poisonous bit me (and oh, how it was a possibility -- if you follow my Twitter, you know exactly what I'm talking about) so that you can hear about it someday.
I mention all that not to brag, but because it's connected to the only two things I can really write about this week. For the first time in my short career, I now find myself in the awkward position that lies between fandom and professionalism. When you read my rantings about Star Trek, Wolverine, comic conventions, Marvel movies, and collectibles, they come purely from my heart. (How mushy!) I still pay to get into every movie I write about. I buy my own action figures, posters and comic books. I receive no swag. No perks. Just some beer money from Cinematical and the comments of my readers. But it's difficult to convince people of that. For one, I'm already in a weird and privileged position of being paid for doing what others happily do for free, and that immediately makes the playing ground uneven and awkward. But now I'm moving into a whole new territory of access. I know that it makes me immediately suspect -- I know this because I immediately suspect anyone who has enjoyed free access, perks and junkets. It's a painful thing to realize that people might stop believing or trusting in me because I'm given a nebulous access.
I also wonder how one seperates personal fandom from professional neutrality. I geek out about, well, everything. If you read enough of my posts here, you can usually figure out who or what I'm currently obsessing over, as I seem to have no filter between the public and the private. So when faced with writing about something I've been given a chance to see or hear about, how the heck do I stop geeking out about it? How do you step away from the fandom and look at it from a critical angle? It's a tricky thing and while it's getting easier, it's a tough thing to balance, particularly since the fun of this job is writing as a fan, and being a representative for a wider community.
But enthusiasm! Let's talk about that now. How do you keep geeking out about stuff? Not only is there a level of marketing saturation that becomes mind-numbing but oh, how the disappointments rack up! Here we are, battered by a blockbuster of May, and I can feel the malaise setting in -- and it's not even June. We've been pretty disappointed, haven't we? How can you keep talking about that? You and I have spent a year writing and reading about these movies, and just like that, it's over ... and even when you live and breathe cinema as you and I do, don't you wish you could just borrow the Terminator time machine and send yourself back to the year when Jurassic Park (or whatever its equivalent was for you) blew your mind? Why do we keep having to settle?
Not only does the lingering disappointment leave me nothing to write about (I mean, really, how many times can I rant about Wolverine?), but when I scan the trades and newswire for inspiration, what do I see? Remakes and reboots. The stuff that made me who I am, and who you are is being reheated and served up to the next generation. While I have this weird hope that it'll act as cloning, and 20 years will see a younger, fresher Elisabeth Rappe writing The Return of the Geek Beat ... what if it doesn't? What if fandom ends with you and I because no one thought, hey, there should be other things to pick from than multiple versions of Flight of the Navigator? Sure, the old stuff will be around, but what do you give a kid after they've watched Star Wars or Buffy the Vampire Slayer? The reboot of said properties? I dug Star Trek like everyone else, but what hath it wrought if everything is going to split into an Ultimates sort of universe?
But listen to me go on like Walt Kowalski. I know, deep down, that this is just a really bad week for fandom and for moviegoers. You can't appreciate good movies unless you have the bad. In a few short days we'll have Up, from a studio that just seems to have a bottomless bag of magic tricks. We'll return to Hogwarts. We'll meet the Basterds. We'll find out just what Avatar is. Sherlock Holmes will solve a Guy Ritchie mystery. We'll meet the Grene Lantern and Captain America. The Avengers will assemble. I know we've got good things coming ...
... I just hope you'll continue to trust me whenever I tell you all about it.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
5-26-2009 @ 9:37PM
paul said...
I'll trust you. I think we all will and I say go for it. Kick open the door. But I think it pays to keep in mind that the more you as a critic and an observer of pop media become more influential and widely read the more likely "they'll" glom onto you. If you're not careful, it's possible to end up like Mr. Incredible! *cough* cut to 3:31
http://tinyurl.com/ojzp4a
Reply
5-26-2009 @ 9:41PM
snowballa said...
Agreed. Not a fan of many of the summer releases for a while. Maybe Public Enemies but besides that I'll wait until Oscar season.
Reply
5-26-2009 @ 11:47PM
Ian said...
*stands up* I'm Spartucus!....oh...I mean...I'll trust you.
And you can rant about Wolverine as many times as you want, I always love reading a good Wolverine rant. (eg would you rather a direct adaption from a comic for a Wolverine movie like 300 and Watchmen...or a more original screenplay? lol)
Reply
5-27-2009 @ 12:45AM
Ken said...
I used to do what you're doing now. There is a fine line between being a toady for the publicists and writing a glowing and enthusiastic piece. Just continue to call them as you see them, use the goodies and perks to get more information for your readers, and don't be too timid about kissing publicist ass. Being on their good side gives you access to the folks you want to talk to, but everybody has a line they won't cross. Be professional and they won't care if your writing is supportive of their project. In fact, they may even respect you for your honesty. What I want as a regular reader is to hear how you processed whatever it is: a movie, an event, an interview. It's ok to geek out because your readers like your enthusiasm. Too many film writers actually don't like movies. I want to hear from a writer who loves movies. It's good that you're thinking about these things, but don't worry about whether your readers trust you just because you had a croissant and a cuppa coffee paid for by Sony. We know you were really doing undercover work for your loyal following.
Keep da geek
Reply
5-27-2009 @ 2:59AM
Dorv said...
ER, you are easily one of my favorite reads on the internet (and pretty much the only reason I still check out Cinematical), and I get the malaise that you're talking about. You've seen one of your favorite properties strike out, and we've also seen a just average Terminator movie.
The good news is that you don't have to be positive all the time (I'd like to take this moment to tell the rest of the Internet that you don't have to be negative all the time, either). A good balance that's based on honest opinion is refreshing.
That being said, there's a lot to look forward to this summer. I can't wait for HP, nor can I wait to be utterly disappointed in GI Joe ;)
Reply
5-27-2009 @ 3:51AM
rekres said...
WHAT?!?
I have to wonder if I'm suddenly stuck in an alternate universe. Did any of you watch the same movies this past month that I did?
Wolverine, Star Trek, and Terminator! The only low point was Angels and Demons which I refused to watch. Other than that it has been a great month with some truly rocking blockbusters.
Reply
5-27-2009 @ 10:00AM
mdk said...
Eh. This summer just reminds me of the summer of 1998, movie-wise... another dreaded "Summer of Crap". I think we were spoiled last year with Iron Man and The Dark Knight and it just makes this year's lackluster slate seem even worse than it actually is. Even so, it's still pretty bad.
Reply
5-27-2009 @ 11:28AM
georgia49th said...
I'd have to say the best movie so far has been Star Trek
There's movies that I like to call Dvd waiters movies that I wouldn't want to go to the theater to see.
there are catagories in which the movies are placed on my Dvd list
1. Must have movie, seen it theaters.want the Dvd
2.didn't have time to catch it in theaters
3. didn't want to spend the money to see it in theaters
(it's also possible that i would wait for the dvd to drop in price)
movies that I must see.
1.Jonah Hex (April 2010)
2.Harry Potter
3. Transformers II
4' Ironman II
Reply
5-27-2009 @ 2:50PM
blake said...
What a fantastic lead in. CQ is probably the best unknown science fantasy movie I know of. Touché Elizabeth.
Reply
5-27-2009 @ 3:46PM
jessejames said...
it seems like its the month of prequels: wolverine, star trek, angels and demons, kind of terminator: salvation
Reply
5-27-2009 @ 4:19PM
Dan said...
Well, shit, Elisabeth, it sounds like you're worrying yourself over nothing. Count me among the readers that will continue to trust and look forward to hearing from you. And that's whether we agree or don't--though by and large, I'm usually with you, especially today.
I feel everybody's pain, because this HAS been a really lackluster summer so far, especially considering how excited to see a few of these I was. Though Star Trek was still absolutely fantastic, Wolverine and Terminator disappointed, and Angels and Demons (predictably) kinda sucked. I'm going to catch Drag Me To Hell tomorrow night, and Up on friday, so here's to things (hopefully) loooking up.
But to come full circle, I'm with you Elisabeth, as long as you keep doing you. Quit thinking so much about it, because we're all behind you, and just do your thing!
P.S. Nice Gran Torino reference.
Reply