Who Are the Actors and Actresses You Had to Warm Up To?
Filed under: Fandom

Like most of you Cinematical readers, I'll watch just about any movie. I try not to hold cinematic grudges, and I try to separate the art from the artist. But it's human nature to have some kind of bias, and I often find that there are actors and actresses that I'll hold very unfair grudges against.
One of these is Liev Schreiber. He's on my "must-watch" list because he rarely turns in a bad performance, even though he's been in some real clunkers. But liking him has been some kind of gradual and snotty process that I can trace back to having first encountered his ugly side in Scream and Ransom. I had him pigeonholed as a nasty ass thug for a long time. It wasn't until A Walk on the Moon that I started to come around, but even then I was rooting for Diane Lane to leave him for Viggo Mortensen. Viggo was Aragorn! Schreiber was Cotton Weary! He wasn't to be trusted. (He's even vaguely nasty in the otherwise fluffy Kate and Leopold. Meg Ryan is pretty unpleasant in that, but did she really need him to remark "Those were your best [years]?")
But somewhere in there, he converted me to fandom that found me moving Defiance to the top of the Netflix queue when I might have let it linger until gosh knows when. If Brian DePalma ever gets around to making that Untouchables prequel, he should look no further for his Al Capone.
One of these is Liev Schreiber. He's on my "must-watch" list because he rarely turns in a bad performance, even though he's been in some real clunkers. But liking him has been some kind of gradual and snotty process that I can trace back to having first encountered his ugly side in Scream and Ransom. I had him pigeonholed as a nasty ass thug for a long time. It wasn't until A Walk on the Moon that I started to come around, but even then I was rooting for Diane Lane to leave him for Viggo Mortensen. Viggo was Aragorn! Schreiber was Cotton Weary! He wasn't to be trusted. (He's even vaguely nasty in the otherwise fluffy Kate and Leopold. Meg Ryan is pretty unpleasant in that, but did she really need him to remark "Those were your best [years]?")
But somewhere in there, he converted me to fandom that found me moving Defiance to the top of the Netflix queue when I might have let it linger until gosh knows when. If Brian DePalma ever gets around to making that Untouchables prequel, he should look no further for his Al Capone.
Of course, Schreiber is just one of many I've had to warm up to. I've fallen in and out of enjoyment and admiration for Nicole Kidman, Christian Bale, Ed Harris, Angelina Jolie, Leonardo DiCaprio, and others I've forgotten for the moment. Sometimes it's dependent entirely on what characters they've played, other times it's based purely on a vague notion that they've ripped me off for a few bad movies.
But more often than not, it's the former, and I hold performances against them for ages, as I did with Schreiber. It took me several movies to forgive Laura Linney for destroying Gillian Anderson in The House of Mirth. Lest you think I'm too imaginative, sometimes it's based on the sheer amount of drips or thugs someone plays. I'm never sure if they're typecast, or if that's the only thing they can play. (Exhibit A: Maria Bello, who had a lot of buzz, but seems to have grown very fond of playing a wife and mother whose perfect life is falling apart.)
On this slow news day, I'll throw the topic out to you commenting wolves. Do you find yourself cherishing the same prejudices? Or are you far more forgiving than I am?
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
6-18-2009 @ 5:26PM
Mark Rooster said...
Ryan Reynolds. I couldn't stand him in any comedic role, and pretty much wrote him off, until I saw his excellent performances in "The Amityville Horror" and "Adventureland." Now I kinda like him, though I still would prefer to see him in dramas rather than comedies.
Like most people, I can generally ignore what negative things I hear about an actor's personal life, but sometimes it can be tough. I can no longer watch anything starring Martin Lawrence (not that I'd want to, with the dogshit he puts out anymore), because every time I see him on screen, all I can think, Man, what an asshole.
Reply
6-18-2009 @ 5:44PM
Mike said...
DiCaprio is someone who I had to warm up to after Titanic. That movie turned him into the Zac Efron of his time, big with the teeny boppers but not so big with the fellas. To his credit, he's chosen a good path and put in some solid work since.
I still don't want to see him as Sinatra, though.
Reply
6-18-2009 @ 5:53PM
Walt said...
Philip Seymour Hoffman. Still hate him for how oily he was in "Scent of a Woman".
Reply
6-18-2009 @ 5:56PM
Kurt said...
Wow. I'm totally enamored with Liev Schrieber (not to get too off-topic). C/O Wolverine I've had to learn to be disappointed in him.
Reply
6-18-2009 @ 8:04PM
vegimorph said...
Actually I found him great in Wolverine. the story wasn't that good but the actors were top notch and Schriber brought a real weight of threat to the role. plus he kind of left me unsettled with some other roles.
6-18-2009 @ 8:52PM
Andy said...
Yeah, I totally agree...he was the best thing about 'Wolverine', hands down. I was shocked at how menacing he was. Fantastic.
6-18-2009 @ 6:18PM
Alex said...
Haha, not to many "Nasty Ass Thugs" come out of the Yale School of Drama. I actually met him about a year ago and he's a real no-bullshit guy.
I would say I've grown to love Colin Farrell. He also has been in some less than impressive movies, but he's come to be one of those actors that makes a film better simply by his presence.
Reply
6-18-2009 @ 7:50PM
Chelsea said...
I had to warm to Michelle Williams and Aaron Eckhart. Eckhart came to popularity as Neil BigBootay's actor of choice, and I'd written Eckhart off as just another smug asshole. While I won't go out of my way to see him in anything, some of his performances have been surprisingly solid, if not fun: his performance as Harvey Dent was compelling, and I have a soft spot for his portrayal of Julia Roberts's biker boyfriend in ERIN BROCKOVICH.
With Michelle Williams, I had assumed she was just another cute girl from the WB. She showed some depth in ME WITHOUT YOU and has been making some good choices that haven't made me think of DAWSON'S CREEK. In particular, WENDY AND LUCY was brilliant, and she really held her own.
Reply
6-18-2009 @ 10:52PM
Jay said...
I didn't used to feel this way, but now I'll see ANYTHING with Ben Stiller in it. Although I don't know if it's just him or the cast he can often pull together.
Reply
6-19-2009 @ 7:44PM
Laurie Mann said...
I'm not normally a Ben Stiller fan, but he was wonderful in The Royal Tennenbaums.
I'd seen Viggo Mortensen in several movies, but he never made an impression on me until Lord of the Rings. I saw Walk on the Moon and 28 Days later; and, of course, he's been great since then.
I think the first Liev Schreiber movie I saw was where he played Orson Wells and I was extremely impressed.
I guess the actor I'm still waiting to be impressed by is Ryan Reynolds. I've been underwhelmed by everything I've seen him in, especially when Abigail Breslin acted circles around him in Definitely, Maybe.
Reply
6-20-2009 @ 6:22AM
Tania said...
Aaron Eckhart, Clive Owen, Cillian Murphy, Leonardo DiCaprio, just to name a few
Reply