Dear Hasbro: Enough Already
Filed under: Comic/Superhero/Geek, Fan Rant

In an interview over on Collider, Frosty spoke with Hasbro CEO Brian Goldner at a G.I. Joe screening and he covered the movies that the company has in development. In many ways it mirrored what our own Jessica Barnes wrote about back in March. Hasbro clearly isn't content to sit back and dive into the coffers filled with money from the Transformers movies, which will likely swell even further when G.I. Joe is released this weekend. They aren't just licensing their toys for film development (Stretch Armstrong is slated to be a movie in 2011), it now looks like they'll be tossing their entire board game range into the mix.
You've probably heard that Ridley Scott is developing Monopoly into a movie, as hard as that is to believe, but according to Goldner that will be joined by Candy Land and Battleship. Battleship!? Really? A movie based around Battleship? As much as I strained my brain to try and figure out how Ridley Scott could make Monopoly into a compelling film, Battleship just makes my grey matter give up abandon ship. You might as well make Connect Four into a movie. Everyone would be on the edge of their seats waiting for the "Pretty sneaky, sis." line.
If they're going to continue down this road, I wish they'd license things like NERF into a film. There's probably a good movie that could come out of that. What about Play-Doh: The Movie? Spirograph: The Series? Tinkertoys vs. Transformers? At what point do you draw a line over the strip-mining of childhood and imagination? Just because something is a successful game doesn't mean it will translate to the screen. 1985's Clue proved that fairly well.
One look at Hasbro's holdings makes you wonder why the government isn't looking at them as an actual monopoly on the game market. Since 1984, Hasbro has acquired rival companies like Milton Bradley, Parker Brothers, and Avalon Hill. They expanded to pick up Wizards of the Coast, makers of the ultra-popular collectible card game Magic: The Gathering, and the Cranium brand. Chances are if you've ever played a board game in your life, Hasbro now owns the rights to it.
And that's just scratching the surface. They'd be the largest toy and game company in the world if not for Mattel's runaway Barbie brand. Will everything you played with as a kid or even as an adult eventually become a movie? If Hasbro has their way, it looks like the answer is yes. If we can't stop the inevitable march forward, then maybe they'll consider some of the board game movie ideas I wrote about on Spout last year. I still think that Fireball Island (which Hasbro now owns) would make a good movie, if I do say so myself.
But, NO! I'm drawing the line. Hollywood needs more original ideas, and we need to stop cramming popcorn in our mouths while toys come to life in horribly written stories onscreen. That is, unless the Tonka movie manages to cross boundaries and make grown men and women cry.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-09-2009 @ 10:00PM
Brian Kirchhoff said...
I am actually looking forward to Ang Lee's "Ants in the Pants"...
Reply
8-09-2009 @ 9:47PM
tony said...
You sir have no imagination It's not like movies based on video games where there is a history of failure. There has only been one board game based movie and that was a near masterpiece in the comedy/mystery genre. There are some creative makers of film attached to these projects and there is little content attached to the games so there is bound to be some originality. Reserve your judgment for the final product
Reply
8-09-2009 @ 11:02PM
charlesv said...
What about jumanji?
8-10-2009 @ 1:33AM
Bubbameister33 said...
Jumanji was based off of the book not a board game.
8-09-2009 @ 9:49PM
Luke said...
Why is Battleship such a hard concept to understand? It's basically a game of cat and mouse at sea not unlike "Master and Commander" was. They're just using the familiar names of the Monopoly and Battleship games to take advantage of a bunch of built-in name-recognition. To think of the actual board games rather than their themes is to think rather too small and much too literally. Did you think Transformers was going to be a movie about kids playing with toy robots? Battleship is just going to be a nautical war movie.
Reply
8-10-2009 @ 1:39AM
Kevin Kelly said...
Transformers I can understand because even the toys had a plot: good vs. bad. Autobots vs. Decepticons. They came to Earth from a distant planet. Blah blah blah.
But Battleship? Boring. Why not just make a Checkers movie? Or Chess? One of the oldest and most popular games in the world? WHERE IS CHESS, THE MOVIE? "This sumer: Get Castled. Chess: The Movie."
8-09-2009 @ 11:41PM
Flowers said...
Yes I agree. It's annoying that board games are being turned into films. I'm sorry but there are better stories out there and I find these Toy companies shameless. Anything for a buck.
Lets hope that some of these silly titles fade off into obscurity.
The last thing we need are dull films promoting less than entertaining board games.
--
Reply
8-10-2009 @ 1:10AM
Jen said...
Is there any way to announce our surrender? Just pay these guys some large sum of money to go away and leave our movie theaters alone?
Reply
8-10-2009 @ 2:58AM
So 5 minutes ago said...
It's so funny because I was just saying the other day that Battleship would be a good movie if they did it kind of like War Games, where the kids didn't know they had actually tapped into the naval defense system and were playing for real instead of playing some high tech video game.
I'm using this as proof when the studios steal this idea.
Reply
8-10-2009 @ 3:00AM
Jaded said...
It's so funny because I was just saying the other day that Battleship would be a good movie if they did it kind of like War Games, where the kids didn't know they had actually tapped into the naval defense system and were playing for real instead of playing some high tech video game.
I'm using this as proof when the studios steal this idea.
Reply
8-10-2009 @ 8:07AM
j said...
Uno. There can be only one.
Reply
8-10-2009 @ 12:04PM
Monika said...
Here, here!
Although I would love to see Hungry, Hungry Hippos turn into a horror movie.
Reply
8-11-2009 @ 4:43AM
joits said...
hopefully they do make battlefield and hopefully it goes the way of some of the recent eddie murphy movies... which is a studio paying $100 million to make a movie and it only grosses $10 or so. it will hopefully teach them that they can't turn every 80s toy into a movie and be successful.
then i guess we can wait and see what hollywood will turn their attention to after this well dries up.
Reply