Discuss: How Important is Age Accuracy?
Filed under: Fandom
Let's face it -- Hollywood's view of age is skewed, at best. The industry might try to avoid fine lines and wrinkles like the plague, botoxing and facelifting all over the place, but it also likes to slip older actors and actresses into young roles ... not to mention making younger stars look older and more mature, and basically playing with age as the industry sees fit. And it's not only behind the scenes. From old-school 90210 to the big screen, age gets wiggled.For example, Online Education lists a bunch of films where older actors ignore their age to play college students -- some being in their 20's and a close jump to college life, and others being ridiculously over-aged for their work, like a 39-year-old Harland Williams popping up as a college student in Sorority Boys. But age also becomes a factor in book adaptations.
As Elisabeth noted last week, there's a rumor that Robert Downey Jr. is in talks to play the vampire Lestat in a new re-do of Anne Rice's The Vampire Chronicles. (Although no word on which books will be included, and how.) Big-screen treatments of Rice's work have always been my favorite examples of throwing age out the window. Where something like the Twilight series has been very particular about picking appropriate ages, casting peeps have a field day with Rice.
Like many vamp stories, the Chronicles are all about youth that lives on forever -- albeit with a more mature bend that doesn't include continuing lifetimes of high school. Lestat was roughly twenty when he was turned, and was subsequently played by an over-30 Tom Cruise and a late-20s Stuart Townsend. A decade might be a big jump, but it worked alright because Lestat was already a man when he was turned. But then you get Armand, described as a boy, turned at about 17 years, yet played by Antonio Banderas, in his 30s. And now -- the potential for a 40-something, greying-haired Robert Downey Jr. to play Lestat.
Obviously, age is but a number to Hollywood, but what do you think? Should Hollywood continue to have a heyday with age, or is it time to be at least a little more age-conscious with casting?










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-17-2009 @ 12:48PM
Christian M. Howell said...
Who wants to be old anyway? Not me.
Reply
8-17-2009 @ 12:52PM
techstar25 said...
One of the craziest examples of this (which was not listed at the link you posted) is "Fired Up". Released in Feb of 2009. it starred Eric Christian Olsen and Nicolas D'Agosto as a high school students. Olsen is 32 years old. D'Agosto is 29.
Reply
8-17-2009 @ 1:14PM
Stunbunny said...
I saw Trick 'r Treat this weekend in Chicago and after the screening, the director, Michael Dougherty, mentioned that Warner Bros. wanted him to cast older actors instead of the kids he finally went with.
The kids in the movie looked 12-14 years of age. The actual actors in some cases were 2 or more years older than that. Any older and it would have been absurd to believe that these "kids" were out trick-or-treating.
In cases like this, I'll take a talented unknown who's close to the character's age over a well-known star playing a teenager with crow's feet any day.
Reply
8-19-2009 @ 5:33PM
calindor said...
Perhaps they were referring to the lead actor who plays "Sam" , who is currently 10 years old.
8-17-2009 @ 1:18PM
Baxter said...
It definitely makes a huge difference in story credibility. It's difficult to lose yourself in a film when all you can think about it how old that high school student looks. I thought Lou Diamond Phillips did a great job but let's face it, "La Bamba" would have been a much more effective film if a teenager had played 16-year-old Richie Valens. As for vampires, well it completely undermines the character and, as you stated, the entire "be young forever" theme they carry with them. Robert Downey Jr is absolutely too old to play Lestat.
Reply
8-17-2009 @ 8:40PM
paul said...
So, do you think a seventeen year old boy could have smoked up the screen like Antonio Banderas? I don't think so.
Reply
8-19-2009 @ 6:30PM
Ange said...
Leave Rob alone! Hes gorgeous and has aged really well! Fab actor and i hope he keeps rocking on, whether that means vampire, detective or superhero! All genres!
Reply