Fantastic Fest Review: Ninja Assassin
Filed under: Action, Thrillers, Warner Brothers, Fantastic Fest

One can't ask too much of a film called Ninja Assassin -- that's a given -- but James McTeigue's proper directorial follow-up to V for Vendetta does its damnedest to take that insta-pulp title and weave around it a worn-out tale of forbidden love, family betrayal, and government conspiracy. Complete with some hard-to-see fight scenes and some harder-to-hear dialogue, all delivered with a poker-straight face and capped off with some super-splattery kills, it's like a graphic novel adaptation with comic book punctuation, a film so flagrant in its fakery that it almost forgets to have any fun.
Raizo (Korean pop star Rain, of Speed Racer and "Colbert Report" fame) was once an orphan, raised by a secretive clan to, um, assassinate as, well, a ninja would. One forbidden fling and one shamed father later, and our pariah protagonist is off to Berlin in order to save Europol* agent Mika Coretti (Naomie Harris) from the grisly fate that her criminal investigations have inevitably drawn.
To its credit, Assassin doesn't skimp on its action sequences, but what's there is a flurry of fury at best, cluttered with the exaggerated motions of swinging swords and throwing star after throwing star, and then cut up to undermine the genuine physical efforts of its lead and countless stuntmen at every turn. Two night fights early on are near indecipherable in execution, while a mid-point slo-mo slice-and-dice shot seems lifted wholesale from Warner Brothers' own 300. Worse yet, each kill is then accompanied by a garish burst of computer-generated bloodshed, a novelty that wears out its welcome from the prologue on and renders each subsequent death scene as unremarkable and unexciting as the last.
And each video game has its share of cut-scenes, we're treated to the cheesiest dialogue uttered by a uniformly wooden ensemble in between melees. As the eponymous soldier of stealth, Rain only fares best because he has less to say than this review does and is often shirtless demonstrates a viable physicality that goes otherwise obscured during the chopped-up, blur-happy battles. Harris plays panicked on cue, and McTeigue vet Ben Miles (Racer, Vendetta) plays her boss/boyfriend with a perfectly adequate sense of skepticism. None, though, can manage to make the plodding plotting seem particularly urgent or critical in the greater scheme of things, and none can justify the handy mysticism that creeps in enough to make literal shadows out of assailants and heal any wound at any time.
All of the back story in the world can't make us care about what made a ninja assassin just that, though, similar to how all of the whooshing sounds can't help us grasp just who is sparring with who when the chit-chat does subside, and all of those flying fluids can't disguise the fact that Ninja Assassin is a thoroughly bloodless experience.
*That's right, it's not even Interpol. Hell, the film should just take place in Schmerlin.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
10-01-2009 @ 11:18AM
warbringerdoom said...
Thank you for confirming my worst fears!!!! I wanted it to be cheese, good cheese, and a new way to look at old school martial arts flicks!!.... The training vids. should be there own movie, that shit was cool!!
Reply
10-01-2009 @ 11:18AM
kate said...
I am not a film critic, just viewers.
but I know, no dispute is uninteresting film. different audiences obtained a different content in the same movie.
Reply
10-01-2009 @ 12:13PM
Maverick Saturn (Igor) said...
Darn, thought this would be good :( Ah well, there's always Jennifer's B....nope, I'm not going to say it, cos that was trash too.
Reply
10-02-2009 @ 8:00AM
C.A. said...
I'm just going to try to act like I didn't read this and then be sorry when you're right.
Reply
10-02-2009 @ 5:02PM
akatsuki said...
Disappointing, especially since those videos of Rain training so assiduously made me hope they could go for clearer action shots.
Reply
10-06-2009 @ 5:04PM
tewkewl said...
This movie is 2 months from theaters fellas.
They could redo a lot of the fight cuts to make things clearer in that time you know...
Reply
11-25-2009 @ 7:39AM
m said...
Eloquent review however...
Have you ever stopped to think that martial arts movies (in all their cheese glory) appealed to us while in a certain age group? Then we grow up and expect intense intellectual stimulation and poetic inspiration from films meant for dreamy, wide eyed teenagers....like we use to be.
Are you trying to fit into your old prom tux 30 years after the fact and writing that it just doesn't deliver anymore?
Please be fair to this genre and admit, like most of us should...that we are now out of the intended demographic. The 20-something droves that grew up on Grand Theft and similar mind blowingly pointless violence will still dream about being bad ass scary as hell ninjas after watching this glorification gore.
This is a martial arts action film not a political symposium or literary presentation.
So we agree that it delivers cool, brand new martial arts action. It is not meant to deliver anything else...
We fuddy duddies need to find our shuffle boards and walk away shaking our heads, mumbling..."kids today" Instead of publicly damning talented film innovators like the W brothers...always pushing the envelope on CGI possibilities.
Reply