Let's Stop Using Cell Phones During Movies!
Filed under: Exhibition
Hurray! At least one smaller movie theater chain (AmStar Cinemas / Grand Theatres nationwide) has banned cell phone usage and other theaters are considering it (Burlington, North Carolina). Maybe you know of others. What can we do to get all exhibitors to do likewise?Perhaps cell phone / text message movie interrupters need to imagine the following scenario: You're watching a movie at home, you're in the dark all by yourself, you're in the narrative groove, you're caught up with the characters -- and then someone taps you on the shoulder and shines a flashlight in your face. When you motion to the stranger in your house to get the light out of your face, the stranger shrugs his shoulders as if to say, "What? I'm not doing anything wrong."
That's the rough equivalent. Complete strangers routinely and rudely disturb others by pulling out their cell phones, lighting up their equipment, and checking that all-important message. Then they take another few moments to type a response. Sometimes it's a phone call, and the stranger answers it right at their seat. Sometimes they proceed to check other messages, or keep the phone out to wait for a response to their text. Occasionally they think they're being "polite" by angling the phone away from others, which never entirely hides the bright, shining light. Texters know no age boundaries -- I've seen everyone from teens to well-dressed professionals to folks old enough to be my grandparents lighting up and talking or texting away. I've experienced it at public screenings, press screenings, and film festivals. Why do they do it? What can the rest of us do about it?
As to the why, I can understand why parents or physicians might be anxious to check their phone immediately. If it's a life or death situation, yes, I think we can cut those people some slack. Everyone else -- no way. Even if you feel it's an important, though not life-threatening call or text, it's only important to you, not to your fellow moviegoers.
It's so simple: if you're expecting a call that's important to you, and your phone vibrates during a movie, all you have to do is excuse yourself, leave the auditorium, and deal with it. Talk as loud as you want, text all you want, check your messages all you want -- outside the auditorium. "But I don't want to miss the movie!" some might wail. That's too bad; you're the one that has the "important" call or text.
As to the what, as in what can we do about it, I was all set to call for a ban on texting during movies. But that would involve laws and legal bodies and, really, that's not going to happen. We can talk about the coarsening of the public culture and the general increase in rude, inconsiderate behavior, and we can let off some steam, but that won't stop it. We can glare and stare, or ask politely, and texters will keep texting. It's in their insecure nature to think primarily of themselves, after all. From all apparent evidence, they'd rather text friends and bother strangers than run the risk of ignoring their buddies for the length of a movie. Really, they deserve more pity than scorn.
I avoid confrontations whenever I can, especially with strangers. That's my nature, which is certainly open to criticism. Once, during a movie in an auditorium that was mostly empty, a couple in the row behind me conversed with each other during the movie, not whispering or sharing an occasional aside, but a conversation at near-full voice. Slowly building up anger, I eventually decided to get up and sit next to them. I didn't say anything, I just sat next to the woman. Both she and the man she was with stopped talking and looked over at me. I stared straight ahead. Within a few minutes they got up and left the theater.
With texters, I've thought about snapping open my phone and pointing it at the offender a few minutes after he or she finishes their texting session. I know that will disturb still others, though, and I haven't worked up the nerve to do it yet. I have glared and stared and asked politely, and occasionally that works.
What have you done to deal with the problem? How can we encourage more exhibitors to ban cell phone usage?










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
10-18-2009 @ 5:40PM
martisco said...
Can't they just install cell signal jammers inside theaters? That would stop phone usage right quick.
Reply
10-18-2009 @ 6:01PM
Shaun said...
I hope your doctor isn't watching a movie if something happens to you (God Forbid)
10-18-2009 @ 8:32PM
Michael said...
@Shaun - What is this, 1850? Why should "my" doctor be the one to treat me if something happens? I think I'll be going to a hospital, and I'm pretty sure the on-call doctors aren't going to be watching movies.
10-18-2009 @ 6:00PM
dreamrot said...
If you want that perfect movie watching experience with no interruptions and nothing to disturb you, watch it at home when it hits DVD or cable or whatever.
The simple fact is, that if you're going to go watch a movie in public, you have to deal with the public. People will talk through movies. People will be on their phones. People will text. People will do what they're going to do because, like you, they want to enjoy themselves. And some of them like talking during a movie, or texting their friends, or whatever else.
You're sitting in a theater with people who will let their kids run loose in a store. You're sitting in a theater with people who don't clean up after their dog when they walk them. You're sitting in a theater with people who won't get off the cell phone to place their order at Starbucks. And yet you expect them to suddenly be polite and care about YOUR enjoyment of a movie when they walk into THAT building. Sorry, but I don't see it happening.
Reply
10-18-2009 @ 6:07PM
Rick Bman said...
I came up with a solution to this problem awhile ago, not sure how much it would work though. My idea was to have theaters that were based on memberships. Instead of paying for each movie, you paid a monthly membership fee and you could come to the movies as much as you wants.
The first way this would help the problem is that this type of theater would only attract a clientele that were interested in seeing movies and not just using it as a place to kill a couple hours with friends. Secondly, since you have to have a membership to come to the movies, you would need to follow the rules of the theater in order to keep your membership. One of these rules would, of course, be that you could not use your phone during the movie... either for texting or calling.
I think it is a great idea, I am just not sure if it would work as a viable business. I guess it would depend on the area.
10-18-2009 @ 7:18PM
Jean-Denis said...
... deal with the public... That's just sad. Just because it's a public place doesn't mean that common courtesy has to go out the window. And just because some people do it doesn't mean that it's right. If they can't do it willingly, then you have to force them using cell phone bans, fines and jammers. If they don't like it, then THEY can stay at home and watch the DVD and talk and text and what not.
10-18-2009 @ 7:34PM
The KoT said...
Watching a movie on home on dvd/Blu-ray or some other form of home video is just DIFFERENT than experiencing actual film being projected onto a wall. It is an altogether different experience. I love, Love watching movies at home by myself, but seeing say, Avatar or The Dark Knight on my home TV is drastically different than seeing the same film in a theater, particularly Avatar, which just doesn't sound like it will "work" in its intended form with the home theater technology we have now. While some theaters use digital projection (lots of stuff I've seen in IMAX has been digitally projected) I still prefer seeing the scratches of film on the screen every time I go to the movies. Just because it's "public" doesn't mean people shouldn't follow some basic rules of common decency.
11-01-2009 @ 11:51PM
eyesweirdopen said...
Escalating series of responses to ill-mannered scum:
1) turn around and stare.
2) ask politely if the phoners/ chatters could desist
3) turn round and ask in loud but excessively polite voice, "excuse me, but I believe there's someone in the front row who cant quite hear you - would you kindly raise your voice/ increase the volume of your ring tone?" (delete as applicable)
4) call them inconsiderate twerps and moon at them.
5) swift punch in the teeth
10-18-2009 @ 6:16PM
Michael said...
Let's face it, there are some people who care about others and some people who don't. I often go to movies with friends, and inevitably my phone rings, but I never answer it. They, however, text to their heart's content. I try to get them to stop, but some people...
Then again, I'm the kind of person that doesn't want any disturbances in my theater, and I'll try to do my best not to disturb anyone. I bought tickets to the London Film Festival a few weeks ago and got a cold this past week. I still went to my films, but I felt bad every time I tried to stifle a cough.
Reply
10-18-2009 @ 6:29PM
Kev said...
Let's see if we can beat this dead horse some more.
Reply
10-18-2009 @ 10:57PM
nypinta said...
'm just wondering what kind of movie tgeatwrs every one is going to that is filled with such rude people? I go to the movies all the time and only once did I get distracted by someones cellphone light. And that person was just checking the time. And I don't get this attitude that rudeness should be accepted just because it happens so often.
At the theater I go to the most, if you have a membership card (that earns you points towards cheaper snacks) they'll ask if you would take in a remote and on it are three buttons: one for if something happens to the movie, another if someone is being disruptive by talking, and another if someone is disturbing others by talking on their phone. Everyone pays to be there, so no one has the right to ruin it for everyone else. Why spend the money if you aren't going to pay attention? Just give me your ten bucks and go hang out in the food court.
PS Any doctor can to what this article already said, get up and leave to take the call.
Reply
10-18-2009 @ 7:15PM
Adam said...
I though all theaters already banned cell phone use during movies...
The theater I work at sends ushers twice into each showing (at least if we're not slacking) to check for cell phone users and politely ask them to put it away.
I do keep mine on vibrate during a movie because I occasionally get an emergency call. When I do, I quietly leave the theater and take the call outside.
Reply
10-18-2009 @ 7:30PM
Reuben said...
Where I live, not a single theater has such a ban. I've never even heard of it before.
I do, however, support it.
10-18-2009 @ 8:34PM
Matt said...
@3: Wrong. It is not unreasonable to expect common courtesy in movie theaters, and I'm all for theater owners banning them and starting to routinely check usage. The DVD experience can be great, but there are some films where the theater experience can never be emulated and is absolutely necessary for maximum enjoyment. We should not have to hide in our homes and watch DVD's because of rude and ignorant people. Instead we need to start standing up to them, and getting theater-owners and ushers on our side to combat cell phone use (not to mention talking) under control.
Reply
10-18-2009 @ 10:52PM
Travis Tidmore said...
If you want to have the best movie experience there's two theaters that I've been to alot and can't recall having to deal with phones, talking, etc.
The Arclight in Hollywood, where most people just seem to want to enjoy the movie, and because it seems like an upper scale theater there's a classier, more respectful group of viewers. Because it's not in a shopping center there's almost no teens, and everyone just seems more courteous.
The other is The Alamo Drafthouse in Austin. Before the movie you get the "Shut your mouth or we'll take your ass out" warning. If someone complains about you (easy to do as you simply raise your card and a waiter comes to you) you get one warning, if you keep being loud or disruptive they kick you out without a refund.
Also, I think one of the biggest problems is parent seem to think the mall/shopping center, etc where a theater is locate along with other stores is a cheap babysitter, just drop your kid off with a few bucks and they'll hang out with their friend. This means there's more teens just at the movie to hang out and talk, thus disrupting your movie going experience. Maybe parents should hire a babysitter or find another place their kids can hang out that won't disrupt others. (Or they could just teach manners!)
And finally a true story, when in college a group of friends went to see Urban Legends 2: Electric Suck-aloo, and the teen girl and guy behind us were making out, then suddenly they were no longer making out and instead having sex. It was weird and awkward, made even more so by the fact that they had come in with a 3rd guy who was asleep next to them.
Reply
10-18-2009 @ 11:22PM
Corinne said...
When I saw Harry Potter I went to a theater that offers seating at an increased price for 21 and over (They also offer alcohol, free popcorn, love seats and is balcony seating). Even at the increased price the person next to me felt the need to text the entire movie. I nicely asked him to stop and from the glow of his phone I saw him roll his eyes and continue texting. Since it is a small area I could only sit in the seat my ticket specified so I was stuck the entire movie with the glow in my peripheral.
I support a cell phone ban or heck have specific auditoriums within one theater to be cellphone only and let them deal with their ilk.
Reply
10-18-2009 @ 11:39PM
sheepy said...
First of all, every theater "bans" cell phone use during a film, in the same way they "ban" talking and other unacceptable behaviour. Unfortunately, the staff cannot be in every theater for every minute of the film. If you all suffer in silence, there is nothing the staff can do to help you.
Second, I cannot afford a new big screen tv or a blue ray player. If I could, I doubt it would be fun to watch in my 500 sq. ft. apartment. But thanks for the advice to stay home and watch it on my fabulous home theater, you smug bastards.
Reply
10-19-2009 @ 12:29AM
sherri said...
I found this great video of what they should do to people who use cell phones.
http://joelvalliefilms.com/?p=233
Reply
10-19-2009 @ 12:39AM
The L.B. said...
HOLY SHIT! That was funny as hell. Love the end.
10-19-2009 @ 2:10AM
julian said...
all movie theaters need bans.
if not i am considering yelling, "put your fucking phone away" every time someone takes theirs out to do whatever with it.
i already had to do that two days ago when i saw Where the Wild Things Are.
i even yell at my dad when he takes his phone out during movies.
i always tell everyone in my group when i see a movie, make sure your phone is off because i can go off on them in a second.
I don't care who you are, a phone is for use outside of the movie theater, movie's are to get away from everything not to bring it to the movie and let everyone know about it.
ps. i'm 16 and if this continues for the rest of my life i'm going to kill myself, because the only reason i would stop seeing movies is if i were dead.
Reply