The Top Five Reasons Not to See 'New Moon'
Filed under: Fan Rant

Fellow Cine-mite Peter Hall would have you believe that there are five good reasons to see New Moon. Don't believe the hype. You'll be doing yourself, and all of humanity, a huge favor by saving that money and channeling it into the economy in a far more beneficial way. Like buying an ice cream cone for a stranger or adopting a kitten. I'm going to give you five reasons why you need to steer clear of New Moon, and those pitchforks and torches that Peter was having you get ready might come in handy if you're a Twi-hard, because you aren't going to like this.
These Aren't Vampires. Or Werewolves, For That Matter
Creatures of the night. The undead. Nightwalkers. Nosferatu. Dracula. These are vampires, and they sure as hell don't sparkle in the sunlight. In fact, sunlight makes them burst into giant gouts of flame. They have fangs, an aversion to garlic and silver, no reflections, and they can't come into your house unless invited. Plus, you kill them by staking them through the heart or cutting their head off. They don't sit around looking emotional and pining for their loved ones. If mankind ever had a mortal enemy, it's a vampire. Not whatever Edward Cullen and his Flock of Seagulls haircut is.
And while I'm on the subject, werewolves are beasts who are slaves to the cycle of the moon. They can't control when they wolf out, and they don't sit around breakfast tables eating giant muffins. Plus you take them out with silver bullets, not by refusing to date them. Jacob is no werewolf, he's just a guy who loves running around without a shirt on and feeling angsty about Bella. We want our other creatures of the night back in style, not in denim jean shorts. Give a listen to Warren Zevon's "Werewolves of London," and wonder where the werewolf cool went in this movie.

You Don't Subscribe To Tiger Beat
Chances are you're not a 13-year-old girl reading this article right now. That demographic is probably out watching this movie while brazenly ignoring these five facts. They're also bringing with them the "squee" factor. Squee is a new word that means "a term to express cute overload," and if you were at Comic-Con this year or last year, you would have heard droves of teen and pre-teen girls squee-ing their hearts out whenever Robert Pattinson so much as flared a nostril.
That same noise also carries over into the theater, and it does not make for a pleasant movie-going experience. Mark my words, if you ignore these facts and see this movie anyhow, when Taylor Lautner strips his shirt off, you're going to hear so much shrieking that you'll think you're at a Beatles concert. Between the shrieks, squees, and awwwwwws, you'll be lucky to hear any of the dialogue. Which is actually only a shame during the pseudo-date, where they watch a movie called Face Punch, and it has terrific fake dialogue (this was the highlight of the movie for me... a scene that you hear, but don't see).

Bella Is A Spoiled Brat
The movie opens with Bella telling everyone not to fawn over her 18th birthday, while she collects cool gifts from Dad (sweet digital camera!) and the Cullen crew (sweet sound system for her truck!). Then shortly afterwards she becomes the poster child for depression after Edward leaves her. There are scenes of her staring depressed off into the distance (at school, at home, in the woods), scenes of her waking up screaming from nightmares about Edward, and they're usually accompanied by an extremely maudlin soundtrack.
Eventually you'll start feeling depressed yourself and wondering how you can reclaim these two hours and ten minutes of your life. When she's just about done feeling sorry for herself about Edward, she expertly manipulates Jacob into becoming a replacement Edward, while also agreeing to go date with Mike that leaves him feeling like a chump. This girl needs some disciplining.

Edward is Annoying
Edward's main skill doesn't seem to be slipping into the shadows or gliding through the night. No, he's much better at slow-motion strolls across the parking lot at high school, bouncing his "Hey, I just woke up and wow my hair looks this good" hairdo in the process. Like Derek Zoolander, the one look he seems to have mastered is "smoldering," while he struggles with the rest of his emotions. Constantly. It's painful to watch him attempt to smile or find anything else within his range. Vapid seems like it might be almost within his reach, but that wouldn't allow him to furrow his brow and stare daggers into things ... usually Bella.
The reason True Blood works so well as a story is because Vampire Bill is charismatic. You want to know the guy, hang out with him, and have him as a buddy. Edward seems like the hipster d-bag that just showed up at a local club thinking he'll instantly be hailed as the messiah among women. If this guy was even remotely charming, if would be a different story. It's just too bad he turned out to be someone who seems like an undertaker. Not a barrel of monkeys, this guy.

You Saw Twilight
If you saw Twilight, then that's the best reason I can give you to skip New Moon. Unless you're a fan of mopey girls, scowling posers, a soundtrack that should come with a bottle of Valium, wooden acting, and sparkling vampires (yes, there's more sparkle in this movie, despite what you've heard. In fact, it becomes one of the key plot points), then you need to abandon ship on this one. Even CGI faux-wolves and a bigger budget can't save it, and you're left with a movie that closely resembles the first one: emo teen semi-loner loves vampire and struggles with life. That's still what happens here.
When I saw the original Twilight at a press screening, there were audible groans from the audience at times, and laughter at moments that weren't meant to be funny. Remember when Bella walks into the classroom, and Edward reacts like he's just smelled a used diaper full of Indian food? The audience guffawed at that. There are even more moments like both of those in the sequel. Spare yourself the pain and rent a movie or read a book instead. Just not a Twilight book. Use this time to bone up on The Lovely Bones novel before that movie comes out.
If you're still on the fence about seeing it, I'll just sum up Bella's emotional ride for you: "Edward loves Bella. Bella loves Edward. Edward leaves Bella. Bella gets sad. Jacob loves Bella. Bella kind of likes Jacob. Edward's back. Bella loves Edward. The End." There, I just saved you ten bucks.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
11-19-2009 @ 1:04PM
Kate said...
HUZZAH!
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 1:21PM
Michael Byng said...
I love Twilight hate. Its the only thing that gets me through this stupid "saga".
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 1:46PM
Rich said...
Reason #6: They sparkle
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 8:28PM
Xploited13 said...
That was in #1
11-20-2009 @ 3:22PM
Rich said...
Its worth repeating :P
11-19-2009 @ 2:12PM
yaya said...
its so easy to criticize....what books have you wrote???
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 7:28PM
Derick said...
Written?
11-19-2009 @ 10:18PM
Bubbameister33 (Confused by Fanboyism) said...
Lol.
11-19-2009 @ 2:25PM
Holly said...
I'm enjoying the Twi-hate as much as the next person but I'm trying to remember a vampire story where "They don't sit around looking emotional and pining for their loved ones" Outside of Nosferatu, nothing's coming to mind. Plus I devoted several years of my life to worshipful Buffy viewing, I'd be hypocritical to hate Twilight because it features vampires with feelings in love with a girl several hundred years youger than them.
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 9:58PM
robert said...
here you go Holly, a short list of vampire movies where they don't sit around looking emotional and pining for their loved ones.
Near Dark
Cronos
30 Days of Night
Lost Boys
The Forsaken
Salem's Lot
The Night Flier
and there's a lot more out there.
11-19-2009 @ 10:08PM
Holly said...
Good to know. Any worth a watch? I'm quite curious about Lost Boys
11-20-2009 @ 10:51AM
robert said...
all are worth watching, although some may have aged better than others.
lost boys is a vampire genre classic as far as i'm concerned, as well as near dark.
11-23-2009 @ 3:47PM
Eric H said...
30 Days of Night is definitely not worth watching, unless you really hate yourself.
11-19-2009 @ 3:00PM
Mandy said...
When is the last time you had fun? I'm taking my daughter tonight in her "I Sparkle" tee shirt with body glitter all over. I would imagine I am going to end up squealing and getting all sparkly too. It's called being silly. Girls do it very well. Those that don't, should. It's TONS of fun. Makes good memories too. Better than sitting around being a hater.
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 10:48PM
EatingPie said...
Twilight has a very, very, very specific audience target. And that audience really likes it. Everyone else doesn't get it, and it becomes easy to be a judgemental hater.
This is especially true when half the human race (the male half) doesn't relate... and a lot of *females* over 30 also don't relate. It's a *girly* movie... not "chick flick" but movie for girls.
I read the books and was actually disappointed by this revelation, since I read them in preparation to see the movie... but they convinced me otherwise, being male. And, yeah, I thought a lot of stuff was silly (the sparkle scene just killed me!). (However, the last book was supremely awesome.)
Anyway, all this from someone who is the in the Twi-hater demographic... just trying to say...
Right on! Movies should be fun! Forget the stupid haters. Dress up and enjoy!!
-Pie
11-20-2009 @ 2:06PM
Tucker said...
I'm sure you're both extremely lovely ladies, and I am willing to buy your arguments in a heartbeat - as soon as I stop getting eyerolls when I want to see an action or sci-fi flick.
I can't stand the Twilight garbage, but I can respect and tolerate a little bit of fangirlism assuming due respect is paid in return. Unfortunately, the vast majority of "silly" teenage girls have never heard the word 'respect', and as such turn any small piece of their pop culture into nails-on-chalkboard, cringe-inducing, inane drivel.
There's plenty of stuff I enjoy switching my brain off to - but I don't annoy the hell out of everyone surrounding me when I indulge.
11-19-2009 @ 2:35PM
khia213 said...
I can't wait for the hype machine for this nonsense to shut down. Is there anything else going on in the entertainment world? Hell, even Jon and Kate don't annoy me as much as this tribute to teen age angst.
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 2:33PM
rudeboypwns said...
I think its hilarious when people take the time out of their days to write some long article about why a movie they probably didn't want to see in the first place was bad. Get over it! The people who want to see this movie are still going to see it despite your public outburst about why you hate Robert Pattinson and Taylor Lautner. Also, considering the growing fame and love of RPattz from women all over the world, he probably would be hailed by women if he walked into a club. That's just how it is. And I have to give credit to Taylor Lautner for gaining 30 pounds of muscle just to be in this. This movie is also helmed by a different director. So, whether you loved Twilight or hated it, this will be different as it is in the hands of a different person. Quit hating!
Reply
11-22-2009 @ 8:49PM
Katy said...
The writer of this article works for a movie website. It's his job. If you don't like it, don't go on the website. He's just giving good reasons not to go and waste your money on this movie. If you don't like people writing honest movie reviews, what the hell are you doing on Cinematical? Besides, Twilight mania is out of control. Some people need to fight back or it's only going to get worse.
11-22-2009 @ 9:46PM
rudeboypwns said...
Haha, calm down! And I was just responding with my thoughts to his questionable review. No need to get crazy! Someone writing a terrible review that obviously has more to do with his jealousy of the actors then the movie itself is not going to stop "Twilight Mania" so all of you haters just need to build a bridge and get over it