Is This the World's Worst Film Critic?
Filed under: Newsstand
Hate and ye shall have a voice. Exercise shocking taste and ye shall have a voice!I guess it was inevitable. News programs have slowly become overrun with sensationalism, voices comfortably spewing out the most shocking commentaries they can, annoying those who disagree and rile up those who love a little inappropriate sass with their politics. And it's only natural that this would slowly leak into the movie reviewing world. Guardian has thrown up a love/hate piece for film critic Fiore Mastracci, who they call "a critic so dreadful he's bordering on genius." A once under-the-radar critic, his review of The Road has been making the rounds.
Where many critics love flicks like The Road or Fantastic Mr. Fox, Fiore is a lover of Punisher: War Zone, The Pink Panther (2006), Hitman, Transporter 2... In other words, he's that Regular Joe type moviegoer who equates good cinema with those brainless adventures on the big screen. Then again, the Guardian says he was also a film teacher and used to have his own cable show. So, somewhere, there seems to have been some schooling.
Maybe he's the Gwar of the film critic set, one whose fame and art is nothing like their education and smarts. Whatever the case, his reviews are full of catch-phrases like "celluloid masturbation" and "excrement on celluloid," and he loves throwing in an Obama jab when he can.
Is he merely the best-worst film critic out there? Or an expert in sensationalized film critique for that part of the public that hates to feel anything but laughter and adrenaline rushes while in that theater seat?










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-01-2009 @ 7:33PM
J Mason said...
Not a bad film critic just a fanboy with no discernible writing skills and a poor grasp of the English language. Worse is his arrogance thinking he's a professional film critic.
Read a few of his reviews- he's not the worst I've seen just he's full of himself.
Reply
12-01-2009 @ 7:54PM
Knarf Black said...
Bad Critic checklist:
Brief synopsis of the film... check.
Abrasive, hyperbolic, and repetitive language... check.
References to his own previous writings... check.
Slobs v. Snobs intellectual class warfare... check.
Substantive criticism of the film... [not found]
Dude barely gives a single reason why he considers it bad. Twice as much ink was spilled making fun of the lead kid's name.
Reply
12-01-2009 @ 8:10PM
NP said...
When you google his name, the second result is a Rotten Tomatoes forum thread called "Fiore Mastracci is an idiot." Nice.
Does he write FOR Rotten Tomatoes??
Reply
12-01-2009 @ 9:21PM
Brent Schmidt said...
Transporter 2? You sure it isn't actually Dennis from Sunny?
Reply
12-01-2009 @ 10:00PM
Jimmy said...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1otPZdd1TnQ#t=7m40s
Reply
12-01-2009 @ 10:01PM
Jimmy said...
Really reminded me of this.
12-01-2009 @ 10:34PM
Kevin said...
I thought this would be talking about Armond White for a second.
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 10:41AM
Tommy said...
what about harry knowles over at aint it cool news?
His, ahem, "review" for The lovely Bones is one of the worst pieces of writing i have ever had the misfortune of reading!
http://www.aintitcool.com/node/43177
Reply
1-06-2010 @ 10:27PM
F. MASTRACCI said...
HELLO MONIKA:
One of my fans, and they are legion, pointed me to your article. Thanks for the web publicity and the link to the Guardian article. I plan to use the 'genius' reference in upcoming promotions.
Some of your points are in error. The television show is still going strong. Currently my 446th episode is on. The show has also won three national television awards. Outtakes, in TV format began in 1988. So, rather than being a 'Johnny-come-lately' as your article implies, I actually predate most of the other commentators you reference. Guess I was way ahead of my time. Genius indeed.
Feel free to contact me if you want to do a real profile, instead of rehashing talking points from entertainment liberals whose ire I've augmented. - FIORE
Reply